3 ms·
That was a stretch of executive authority. From the plain reading of the statute, loan forgiveness and modification was supposed to be for unusual and emergency
by Animats 3y ago
That was a stretch of executive authority. From the plain reading of the statute, loan forgiveness and modification was supposed to be for unusual and emergency situations. Payment postponement during the pandemic would probably have survived judicial scrutiny. But broad cancellation was overreach.
- legitster 3y agoMy tinfoil hat theory is that the administration is probably relieved right now. The implications of this were wild had it succeeded. This way they can have their cake and eat it too - they can say they tried and were stymied(!) by a crooked court, meanwhile they are not on the hook for adding half a trillion dollars into an already heavily inflationary economy.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoI suspect you are correct. And frankly, I think Congress should stop trying to dodge responsibility by letting the executive stretch its authority to take care of problems Congress won't.
- Sparkle-san 3y agoEvery textualist on the supreme court should have read section 2.a.1 and said "yup, that gives the executive branch the ability to do basically anything in regards to student loans during a state of emergency which we were in." Instead they invoked the Major Questions Doctrine which seems like a principle made out of whole cloth specifically for when textualism doesn't work the way they want it to.
- legitster 3y ago> 9 The dissent complains that our application of the major questions doctrine is a “tell” revealing that “ ‘normal’ statutory interpretation cannot sustain [our] decision.” Post, at 23, 30. Not so. As we have explained, the statutory text alone precludes the Secretary’s program. Today’s opinion simply reflects this Court’s familiar practice of providing multiple grounds to support its conclusions. See, e.g., Kucana v. Holder, 558 U. S. 233, 243–252 (2010) (interpreting the text of a federal immigration statute in the first instance, then citing the “presumption favoring judicial review of administrative action” as an additional sufficient basis for the Court’s decision). The fact that multiple grounds support a result is usually regarded as a strength, not a weakness.
- justin66 3y agoI doubt this is useful out of context. It turns out the dissent has something to say about more than just the court's use of the goofy (I think Kagan's phrase was "made up," which is fair enough) major questions doctrine.