3 ms·
I never said it was illegal. I was responding to the implication that because you put something publicly on the web, it's somehow ridiculous to object to certai
by JohnFen 3y ago
I never said it was illegal. I was responding to the implication that because you put something publicly on the web, it's somehow ridiculous to object to certain uses of it.
As to the legality, that remains unknown until a court makes a ruling. I suspect that this lawsuit will go nowhere, but I'm just speculating along with everyone else.
- signatoremo 3y agoOf course as the data’s owner you can object to anything. Who is to say that you are not allowed to hate certain practice? On the other hand, you can’t prevent people from using your data if you put it out in public without condition (in the form of some acceptable licenses). As an analogy, if you put a picture of your living room in the sidewalk, you can’t prevent me from looking at it, study it, when I walk by. I may even benefit from it by copying your style or decoration. You may however cover it, with a warning. I’d clearly violate your terms if I still look at it against your will, although I may not violate any laws.
- __loam 3y agoThe problem is that a lot of that public data is protected by copyright.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoIt’s not obvious to me that using public data to train AI is a violation of copyright. Many are claiming it is, but as far as I know the courts haven’t weighed in on it yet.