3 ms·
Hooks definitely build a complex data structure. They don't actually run immediately/imperatively. Even `useEffect(callback, undefined)` (no defined dependencie
by WorldMaker 3y ago
Hooks definitely build a complex data structure. They don't actually run immediately/imperatively. Even `useEffect(callback, undefined)` (no defined dependencies) which gives the illusion that it runs "immediately" on every render is still an illusion of sorts and there's a complex scheduler apparatus feeding on the data structures under the hood that useEffect builds.
The data structures that Hooks build in React gets built in a strangely bound, somewhat liminal `this` space so it effectively "disappears" in JS. That's certainly not how I would have built it. You are right that I probably would have used something more like JS Promises, given the choice. But I didn't build React's Hook systems, I'm just an outside critic. I'm very happy to agree that use of `this` bound things is about as impure functionally as you get in JS. (That said, it is a very JS solution that predates React and gets to old debates of whether or not JS is truly "OO". Prototypical OO is a gray space between OO and functional paradigms.)
Hooks are never imperative, even in the most complex multi-hook components. They use and build data structures. Those data structures are mostly hidden from view and hard to inspect, but they exist.
- valenterry 3y ago> Hooks definitely build a complex data structure But you don't. It is react that builds the datastructure in the background, not you that builds and controls it. Hooks might be declarative, but this is actually orthogonal to being pfp or not. All of that is totally fine btw., there is no need for everything to follow a pfp style. It's a tradeoff. But we shouldn't call something pfp that isn't, even if it is closely related.