4 ms·
> The wiki DMCA Online Copyright Infringement Liability Limitation Act states "To qualify for the § 512(c) safe harbor, the OSP must not have actual knowledge t
by Natsu 15y ago
> The wiki DMCA Online Copyright Infringement Liability Limitation Act states "To qualify for the § 512(c) safe harbor, the OSP must not have actual knowledge that it is hosting infringing material or be aware of facts or circumstances from which infringing activity is apparent." IANAL but it was pretty damn apparent that MegaUpload was being used for infringing activity to me.
I believe it applies to specific acts of infringement, not a general knowledge that a certain service is used for infringing activities. Otherwise, the entire internet you're using right now would be illegal.
(EDIT)
More on that point here: https://ilt.eff.org/index.php/Copyright:_Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act https://ilt.eff.org/index.php/Copyright:_Digital_Millennium_...
Scroll down to "Actual or “Red Flag” Knowledge" and look at the cases interpreting it.
(END EDIT)
Almost everything online is copyrighted. It only becomes copyright infringing when you lack the copyright holder's permission. Unless the copyright holder has said otherwise, you don't know what has and has not been authorized by them. You can probably guess for things like Hollywood movies, but that's why the DMCA puts the burden on them to identify data they have not authorized.
It's their property and they're the only ones who actually know what they have and have not authorized. It may be an impossible burden, but shifting that to people less able to bear it won't help anyone.
- Natsu 15y agoAlso, can you provide a source for the claim that "Premium users could spend money to "clone" files by generating a new link without having to upload a single byte."? I find that allegation more troubling than the rest because I can't see a need for it, while all the other parts have substantial legitimate uses. I mean, there's nothing wrong with letting people monetize their own files or with driving traffic to MU, it's only when the content is infringing that there's a problem. But I've also never been a premium member of that (or any other) site so I've never seen that sort of clone feature before. And if there's no good use for it, it would support the claims that it was designed to skirt the DMCA. I find the claim surprising because I read the indictment against him and I don't remember seeing it in there. But it was a very long indictment and I might have missed that part, which is why I'm going to ask for a source.