10 ms·
> It is really not so repulsive to see the poor asking for money as to see the rich asking for more money. And advertisement is the rich asking for more money.
by lolinder 3y ago
> It is really not so repulsive to see the poor asking for money as to see the rich asking for more money. And advertisement is the rich asking for more money. A man would be annoyed if he found himself in a mob of millionaires, all holding out their silk hats for a penny; or all shouting with one voice, “Give me money.” Yet advertisement does really assault the eye very much as such a shout would assault the ear. “Budge’s Boots are the Best” simply means “Give me money”; “Use Seraphic Soap” simply means “Give me money.” It is a complete mistake to suppose that common people make our towns commonplace, with unsightly things like advertisements. Most of those whose wares are thus placarded everywhere are very wealthy gentlemen with coronets and country seats, men who are probably very particular about the artistic adornment of their own homes. They disfigure their towns in order to decorate their houses.
— G.K. Chesterton, The New Jersusalem
http://www.gkc.org.uk/gkc/books/GKC_New_Jerusalem.html http://www.gkc.org.uk/gkc/books/GKC_New_Jerusalem.html
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- oatmeal1 3y ago> It is really not so repulsive to see the poor asking for money as to see the rich asking for more money. Does this guy really not understand the difference between someone asking for money in exchange for nothing as opposed to asking for money in exchange for something of value? If Coca-Cola was advertising a Venmo address to send them money in exchange for nothing it would be much more annoying than what they currently do.
- amatecha 3y agoMaterially speaking, there's barely a difference. It's actually funny you mention pop/soda, because it's nearly free to produce. It's water with some flavour and sugar, in a plastic or glass bottle.
- leetcrew 3y agothis is kind of disingenuous. the "bill of materials" for a bottle of soda may be measured in cents, but most of the $1.75 you pay at the store is the cost of getting it there and storing it. it's not a phenomenally profitable business. but besides that, people actually enjoy drinking soda. I certainly do from time to time, and I don't find the price unfair.
- amatecha 3y agoUhhh, yes, soda is phenomenally profitable, especially considering all the accounting loopholes to make expenses appear far higher than reality (not that this is unique to any given corp). > CocaCola revenue for the twelve months ending March 31, 2023 was $43.493B > CocaCola net income for the twelve months ending March 31, 2023 was $9.868B > CocaCola net profit margin as of March 31, 2023 is 22.69%. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KO/cocacola/revenue https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KO/cocacola/revenu... (note I also specifically argue that soda is nearly free to produce, not nearly free to store, or transport, or market, etc.)
- greatwave1 3y ago> CocaCola net profit margin as of March 31, 2023 is 22.69%. Which means that it costs them $1 to produce every $1.23 of soda that you purchase. This is a long-shot from being "nearly free" as you claimed earlier, and materially different from "asking for money in exchange for nothing".
- lostlogin 3y agoI’d like to know what it costs if you remove advertising and any other cost that doesn’t directly contribute to getting sugar water into the bottle.
- amatecha 3y agoIt doesn't actually though. Like someone else mentioned, they spend an untold amount of money on advertising. Like $4 billion in 2022, aka 10% of their revenue. https://www.statista.com/statistics/286526/coca-cola-advertising-spending-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/286526/coca-cola-adverti... That's not a cost to produce their product, or even ship it, or store it. That's strictly just "buying more customers", which has no bearing on my initial claim - that soda is extremely cheap to produce.
- lolinder 3y agoIn context he's responding to the negative views that his fellow English expressed at the time (1920) towards people who were aggressively selling their services as tour guides in Jerusalem. He's pointing out that they put up with equivalently aggressive sales tactics in London, with the only difference being that it's the rich asking for more money rather than poor people trying to scrape by.
- hnlmorg 3y agoHasnt there been numerous reports of Coca-Cola consuming so much drinking water in local communities to make their product that the locals end up having to buy Cola for hydration instead?
- amatecha 3y agoPretty much https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/apr/23/pepsi-coke-bottled-water-consumer-reports https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/apr/23/pepsi-coke-b...
- jkaplowitz 3y agoIn some places local communities are also dependent on bottled water because their tap water isn't safely drinkable ... and it's not rare for Coca-Cola to own one of the major bottled water brands, as well as Coca-Cola being a popular drink itself. Everything I just described is true in Mexico for example.
- jeegsy 3y agoIts not really for nothing is it? You 'feel good' in exchange for giving money to a poor person. Isn't it the same feeling albeit for a different reason that Coca-Cola is selling?
- 34679 3y agoEvery fast food drive thru now asks if you want to "round up" your total for some charity of their choice. Not because they want to make the world a better place, but because all that "rounding up" becomes their charitable donation, reducing their tax burden without costing them a cent in actual charity.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoIve been noticing this, as well as an increase of places asking for tips that have no business asking for tips. Any little thing to extract just a tiny bit more money from people I guess.
- yafbum 3y agoAnd yet > It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own self-interest. We address ourselves not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities, but of their advantages." — Adam Smith
- dredmorbius 3y agoPay close attention and note that Smith is talking about individuals-as- butchers, brewers, and bakers. Not multinational conglomerate monopolist meat-packing, alcohol, and shelf-stable baked goods manufacturers. As individuals, Smith's artisans would have faced ample competition both within a community and from others nearby if they attempted to strong-arm customers or degrade products (though there was plenty of both going on, as attested by food-quality and food-purity laws dating back to Hammurabi). They lacked any appreciable ability to lock in more than a very localised monopoly absent armed force or coercion, though those too were abundantly evident (see: America's Colonies and the British East India Company, both of which Smith also writes of).
- valval 3y ago[flagged]
- dredmorbius 3y agoI'm having difficulty determining what your point is here, and with whom you're agreeing and/or disagreeing. Care to clarify?
- valval 3y agoMy parent was somehow dedicating more empathy towards single-man operations than large companies, and I aimed to tone that sentiment down.
- tsimionescu 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Buttons840 3y ago> It is a complete mistake to suppose that common people make our towns commonplace, with unsightly things like advertisements. In other words, the average person isn't advertising; at least, not in an intrusive way. Indeed, the best at any particular job probably are not advertising, because the effort they spent on advertising is effort that was not spent on the job. After buying expensive medication in the United States, I come home and the TV is showing a 90 second commercial from a pharmaceutical company with a catchy song and is overall very well made--guess I know why my medication was expensive. Do we even need advertisements for prescription medication?
- boplicity 3y ago> And advertisement is the rich asking for more money. Actually, one of the main innovations of the past 20 years is that advertising has become easily accessible to those who are not rich. Small businesses and individuals can easily become advertisers on FB, Google, Etc. This has helped, many, many people earn a living. Myself included. I'm certainly not a millionaire.
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago> They disfigure their towns in order to decorate their houses Is YouTube a town?
- hgs3 3y agoOverall I agree, but I will play devils advocate and say that an ad can also be useful for raising awareness that a product exists. Perhaps rather than outright condemning ads their display could be limited to only immediately after the product is first released (e.g. limited only for N days).
- pipes 3y agoIt really isn't the same as someone asking for money in return for nothing.
- hrldcpr 3y agoI'd never thought of it quite like that, in terms of rich beggars versus poor beggars. Thanks for sharing.
- Waterluvian 3y agoProfound. Thanks for sharing this. That really frames what I’ve been struggling to describe. Advertising isn’t some necessary lifeblood of many industries. It can often be something like the endless trench warfare between Pepsi and Coke, vying for slivers of mindshare. I also think that advertising is often a crutch for incompetence. Build a good product and it can take off all on its own. People advertise for you. Or build crap and hire an industry to manipulate people into wanting your crap. Advertising is manipulation. Watch any ad and ask, “what emotion are they trying to con me into feeling?”
- eloisant 3y agoThe Pespi vs Coke advertisements are not about getting marketshare from each others. It's about establishing a duopoly, tell to consumers "here is your choice" and overshadow all the other alternatives.
- yafbum 3y agoGood products hardly ever take out on their own. I'm not sure what computer you're logged on from, but to take that as an example, I'm pretty sure it's made by a company that would likely go under if it chose not to advertise. Advertisement is sometimes just to inform and build awareness, sometimes to build brand, but often to persuade, and sometimes it exploits unethical persuasion techniques. The gap between ethics allowed by society and your own personal ethics are very variable from place to place and person to person. For example in a lot of places it's illegal for doctors and pharma to advertise; some might consider it a good thing not to exploit hypochondriacs, but is it ethical if it results in patients not knowing about an actual cure for their condition? These things are endlessly debatable, they're very far from a black and white situation.
- lolinder 3y agoDo good products fail to take off on their own because advertising is an absolute necessity, or is it because advertising allows bad products to saturate the market so thoroughly? In a hypothetical world without advertising, would it still be true that good products couldn't take off on their own merits? Or would they spread effectively by word of mouth in the absence of the noise generated by the advertising industry? I don't have an answer to this question, it's purely hypothetical. And even if it is true that in this hypothetical world, good products would spread, we're still left with a prisoner's dilemma to resolve in the real world.
- transistor-man 3y agoWhat's remarkable is this quote comes from a book written in the 1920's
- dredmorbius 3y agoA period of rapidly-expanding advertising. See Hamilton Holt's Commercialism and Journalism, dating from 1909: <https://archive.org/details/commercialismjou00holtuoft https://archive.org/details/commercialismjou00holtuoft> And I do mean see it. Read the damned thing, or at least the first dozen pages or so. It's a highly-readable, information-dense, and exceedingly insightful look at the development of commercial publishing in the US at the time, and its author is a magazine publisher himself.
- 0xcde4c3db 3y agoHard to believe this was already being articulated so clearly over a century ago: > No wonder that the man who realizes the significance of all these figures and the trend disclosed by them is coming to look upon the editorial department of the newspaper as merely a necessary means of giving a literary tone to the publication, thus helping business men get their wares before the proper people.
- lolinder 3y agoAnd this: > Thus you see advertising has made possible the great complex papers and magazines of the day with their corps of trained editors, reporters, and advertising writers, in numbers and intellectual calibre comparable with the faculty of a good-sized university. Advertising makes it possible to issue a paper far below the cost of manufacturing — all to the benefit of the consumer. So far as I know there is not an important daily, weekly, or monthly in America that can be manufactured at the selling price. But, on the other hand, with the growth of advertising a department had to be created in every paper for its handling. As advertising still further increased, rival papers competed for it and the professional solicitor became a necessary adjunct of every paper, until now the advertising department is the most important branch of the publication business, for it is the real source of the profits. Because the solicitor seeks the advertiser, and, therefore, is in the position of one asking for favors, he puts himself under obligations to the advertiser, and so in his keenness to bring in revenue for his paper, he is often tempted to ask the aid of the editor in appeasing the advertiser. Thus the advertiser tends to control the policy of the paper. > And this is the explanation of the condition that confronts most publications to-day. By throwing the preponderating weight of commercialism into the scales of production, advertising is at the present moment by far the greatest menace to the disinterested practice of a profession upon which the diffusion of intelligence most largely depends. If journalism is no longer a profession, but a commercial enterprise, it is due to the growth of advertising, and nothing else.