4 ms·
Unfortunately in general, but fortunately in this one particular very specific case race is very correlated to lots of measurable things in America. So, I think
by bee_rider 3y ago
Unfortunately in general, but fortunately in this one particular very specific case race is very correlated to lots of measurable things in America. So, I think colleges will easily succeed in promoting diversity while having ostensibly race-blind admissions policies.
The Supreme Court can I guess try to go case-by-case banning metrics. This stupid whack-a-mole game will look pathetic on their part and burn up whatever tiny bit of institutional legitimacy they have left, but at least they’ll probably fail.
- gettodachoppa 3y ago>So, I think colleges will easily succeed in promoting diversity while having ostensibly race-blind admissions policies. The diversity Harvard wants is the golden calf of American liberals: black Americans. Diversity is almost always code for black people. No other race seems to deserve any attention. See how campaigns like #OscarsSoWhite were propagandized as discrimination against blacks even though the percentage of black actors winning Oscars was nearly identical to their percentage of the population, i.e. Oscars were perfect representational of black people, meanwhile every other race was greatly under-represented. A race-blind policy that factors in class/income will result in more poor asian students dominating placement, likely at the expense of black students. We already know from the discrimination lawsuits how much contempt Harvard has for asian Americans, I assure you Harvard don't want this kind of diversity.
- PathOfEclipse 3y ago> The Supreme Court can I guess try to go case-by-case banning metrics. This stupid whack-a-mole game will look pathetic on their part and burn up whatever tiny bit of institutional legitimacy they have left, but at least they’ll probably fail. Conservatives aren't stupid enough to think they can and should solve all problems via judicial fiat, which is about as divisive, autocratic, and undemocratic as it gets. But, conservatives also know that there's been decades of terrible jurisprudence to undo, many of it done by activist judges. In particular, yesterday's ruling on affirmative action undid California Board of Regents Versus Bakki (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regents_of_the_University_of_California_v._Bakke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regents_of_the_University_of_C...). While the ruling actually declared that racial quotas violated the equal protection clause of the constitution, it simultaneously opened a massive back door to enable effective racial quotas in the name of "diversity". All universities had to do was prove a "compelling interest" in having diversity and they could continue factoring race into the admissions process. This ruling, among other things, inspired the "critical mass" argument, stating that to get the diversity benefit you have to have enough of each racial group: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/151579503.pdf https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/151579503.pdf What's the difference between requiring a critical mass and having racial quotes? Well, not much in practice! In another bit of terrible jurisprudence, the court upheld the critical mass argument as late as 2015: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/14-981 https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/14-981 Unfortunately, our courts have made a lot of bad rulings in the past, and it's far past time they got undone or reworked.
- bee_rider 3y agoWhat do you think the long-term trajectory is? In the absence of judicial activism I guess schools will be able to set their admissions criteria to whatever they want (other than some protections for individuals in protected classes).