3 ms·
The problem is that there isn't a legal framework for "things tied specifically to LGBTQ" and "things that aren't". So the hill-being-died-upon isn't the cake
by jfengel 3y ago
The problem is that there isn't a legal framework for "things tied specifically to LGBTQ" and "things that aren't".
So the hill-being-died-upon isn't the cake or website, but the more general distinction of whether anybody can just make up a reason to discriminate. In this particular case, they went out of their way to fabricate an instance, specifically for the purpose of drawing a distinction where previously there was none -- with the intention of expanding that distinction.
That is, of course, a slippery slope argument, except for the fact that it is a conspicuous and deliberate plan to head down that slope. The Court could, theoretically, interrupt that descent. But this decision is a signal that they will not.
And yes, that's precisely going backwards on things that actually matter. It sends signals that the courts will also back all of the crap going on in Florida, using similar reasoning.
- nerdjon 3y agoEven if this particular instance is fabricated, to my knowledge the past cake battles were not. Or the photographer. I realize from a legal standpoint we don't have a good way to define this. My issue is also not this specific case. But we have been talking about people providing services for gay marriages for 10 years now? Including a few court cases. What bothers me is that those earlier things ever made it to court in the first place and it didn't just end with "well ok I will find someone else". Like what did fighting about this minor thing get us other than making people (conservatives) angry? Thats my problem and concern here. We spent so much time talking about this stuff that doesn't matter, while making the conservative base angry, and I can't shake this feeling that it's biting us in the ass now.
- mrkeen 3y ago> What bothers me is that those earlier things ever made it to court in the first place and it didn't just end with "well ok I will find someone else". What things are you willing to find someone else for? A different doctor? A different lawyer? A different water fountain? Why didn't Rosa Parks simply start a more inclusive (business savvy) bus service and put the bigots out of business?
- hindsightbias 3y agoWhether concern troll or not, there are going to be a lot of people blaming liberals when this court overturns Obergefell.
- text0404 3y ago> Like what did fighting about this minor thing get us other than making people (conservatives) angry? "Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty" if we don't fight about "minor things" then they'll continue to strip away rights until all the "minor" things together are a major thing. it surprises me that you have such a dismissive attitude towards the fight for equal rights since you self-identified as gay (i am also gay).
- nerdjon 3y agoNothing about forcing someone to bake me a wedding cake or make a website for my wedding is moving the needle at all for equal rights when I could just as easily go to someone who would happily take my money. It never has. Maybe in 10-20 years when people stop giving a shit than sure, we can say they are clearly in the minority and we can have a different discussion. But we are not there. At best talking about this stuff is a distraction at worst it is actively moving us backwards. And I fear that we are on the worst side of things considering how drastically things have changed in the other direction in the last few years. The fact is we have to look at why after making so much progress we are regressing and I refuse to put all of that blame on the opposition when we picked the stupid battles like cakes. Frankly at this point in time I don't give a rats ass about someone baking a cake or making a website when trans kids can't get the healthcare that they need and we have schools across this country trying to erase queer identities. Also the issues with many of the racial books being removed from school. This is not the issue we should be talking about and never was.
- fzeroracer 3y agoExcept you're missing the forest for the trees. These cases are used to deny rights to trans people as well as gay people. The religious right to discriminate is used to hammer down all minorities. The fact that you're blaming the victim of the case is really quite absurd. You can't fathom that each of these smaller actions comes together to make a body of argument against the rights of minorities to exist. They're already doing this to excise transgender healthcare by claiming that they have a free speech right to not treat them. And again I encourage you to actually read this case before you respond, though I doubt you will. The people that brought this case forward literally made up a gay couple so they could have an argument against needing to serve them [1]. This isn't us picking a bad argument, this is systematic dismantling of our rights by bad faith actors. [1] https://newrepublic.com/article/173987/mysterious-case-fake-gay-marriage-website-real-straight-man-supreme-court https://newrepublic.com/article/173987/mysterious-case-fake-...
- EA-3167 3y agoMy concern is related, but separate. "Religious exceptions" are the number one excuse people are using to evade regulations around vaccinating children, and that particular hobby comes with a body count. We need to get to a point where people citing their religion isn't an excuse to pick and choose how and which laws apply to them. Forget cakes, forget LGBT or anything else, just think about how this framework is already being abused.
- waterbadger 3y ago[flagged]
- EA-3167 3y agoPutting aside that conspiracy theory with no basis in medicine or science, I'd like to highlight the irony of worrying about "murdered infants" when the anti-vaxx movement produces more of just that.
- waterbadger 3y ago[flagged]
- cogman10 3y agoAnd some people believe the third eye closes if you are exposed to wifi radiation. Shall we shut down all wireless communications because some people are dangerously misinformed?
- cogman10 3y agoLet's be specific here on what we are talking about. We've already seen cases where county clerks have decided not to issue wedding certificates because of their religion. We've seen pharmacists refuse to issue drugs because of their religion. The slope is here and the SC is signaling "it's ok not to do your job if you're a bigot". So what's next? Doctors that refuse to treat "gay" diseases like HIV? Where's the line? Can a school teacher refuse to teach a child how to read because it's against their religion to let women read? Should we allow biology teachers to refuse to teach evolution because that's against their religion? This isn't just about gay rights, never was. This is about how much power saying "it's my religion" can grant you and protect you from being a bigot moron.
- mariojv 3y agoThe doctor refusal step has already happened in Florida. They passed a very vague bill giving medical practitioners and organizations the right to refuse care based on religious belief: https://www.aclufl.org/en/press-releases/aclu-florida-statement-bill-allows-healthcare-providers-and-payors-refuse-healthcare https://www.aclufl.org/en/press-releases/aclu-florida-statem...
- jfengel 3y agoSo what's next? Doctors that refuse to treat "gay" diseases like HIV? That's already in the works: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/arkansas-governor-signs-bill-allowing-medical-workers-to-refuse-treatment-to-lgbtq-people https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/arkansas-governor-sign... Should we allow biology teachers to refuse to teach evolution because that's against their religion? That too: https://www.eenews.net/articles/okla-bill-targets-existing-scientific-theories/ https://www.eenews.net/articles/okla-bill-targets-existing-s...
- cogman10 3y agoThis is pretty important for people to see. I was not being hyperbolic. What we've not seen is the SC case to make this a national standard rather than just a state only standard. All it will take is someone getting fired and then suing (If that hasn't already happened, might just be making its way through the lower courts).