3 ms·
It seems like these days there are a hundred people working on AI and millions more who are making a career just discussing it. We don't need more ethicists, fu
by paxys 3y ago
It seems like these days there are a hundred people working on AI and millions more who are making a career just discussing it. We don't need more ethicists, futurists, policy researchers, influencers, journalists, think tanks and whoever else in the space. There is nothing original left to say about any of these topics. If you aren't contributing to actual progress in the area then it's best to not shove yourself into the conversation at all.
- erwald 3y agoThe author of this article is Dan Hendrycks, who has a PhD in ML from UC Berkeley and was one of the contributors to the GELU activation function (among other things).
- 93po 3y agoHow many people have a full time job discussing only AI? It's guaranteed not that many. Also to say there's nothing original left to say is ridiculous. There is a ton we haven't figured out yet.
- ethanbond 3y agoOkay then keep the AI in boxes and out of society. Notice that people perked up and started caring about AI development primarily when these were introduced to the public? Could it be that the public has a legitimate stake in new technologies that are introduced to it? "It seems like these days there are a hundred people dumping chemicals into rivers and millions more who are saying 'don't dump chemicals into the rivers.' We don't need em! If you aren't dumping chemicals into rivers then it's best not to shove yourself into the conversation at all."
- c_crank 3y agoAs far as the public goes, their primary concern would be how LLMs could put a lot of them out of work in the artistic fields. AI Doomsdaying is primarily a hobby for nerdy scientists who believe too much in the singularity, not the average Joe.
- ethanbond 3y agoI don't understand the relevance of this comment.
- c_crank 3y agoYour comment framed AI Doomsdaying as being a concern of the public, when it is pretty far from being something the public cares about.
- ethanbond 3y agoPaxys initial claim was "there are millions of people uninvolved in making AI who are commentating on AI and they should shut up." Take it up with them if you disagree that there are millions of people who care. It's not relevant to my point, which is that you need not be directly involved in the development of a technology to be a stakeholder in its development, especially when it's being deployed to the public at massive scale and breakneck speed.
- chinchilla2020 3y agoNone of these think tank types represent society. Let society decide what they want to do with AI, not a bunch of compromised hype chasers.
- ethanbond 3y agoIt sure is easy to disregard critique when one can pick from such a bottomless barrel of ad hominem. Do I work for a think tank and didn't know it?
- chinchilla2020 3y agoI wasn't talking about you. I was talking about the AI talking heads in the media today.
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoYou don't represent society, certainly not more than the millions of people with ChatGPT subscriptions.
- ethanbond 3y agoI didn’t claim to. Paxys claim is that if you are not involved in the development in AI, you are not a stakeholder in its development. My claim is that as soon as something begins affecting the public (e.g. by mass deployment), then the public is now a stakeholder. As a general rule, as soon as you start doing something that affects other people, they have a stake in what you’re doing. This is a basic, basic tenet of a society. It applies to listening to loud music, driving fast, and yes, developing AI. Pretty straightforward.
- troll_v_bridge 3y ago>”There is nothing original left to say about any of these topics. If you aren't contributing to actual progress in the area then it's best to not shove yourself into the conversation at all.” This is one of the more hypocritical statements I’ve read recently. If you study the history of science, it evolved from thought experiments.
- munificent 3y ago> If you aren't contributing to actual progress in the area then it's best to not shove yourself into the conversation at all. By that same token, if you aren't working to make landmines more efficient, you don't deserve to have an opinion about landmines.
- logicchains 3y agoIt's very easy to understand what a landmine does even to a layman, but the majority of even technical people have magical, fantastical ideas about what LLMs like GPT are, completely divorced from the mundane reality of how such things actually operate.