6 ms·
Not sure these "options" are going to satisfy business risk analysis. We are looking into moving away from all things CentOS, RHEL, or projects like Rocky. It w
by verdverm 3y ago
Not sure these "options" are going to satisfy business risk analysis. We are looking into moving away from all things CentOS, RHEL, or projects like Rocky. It was going to be Rocky, but no more. Red Hat got blue washed and is now ruining their reputation
- freedomben 3y agoMy impression from being somewhat involved in the (early) communities of Rocky and Alma, is that the Rocky people are quite a bit looser with violating EULAs, ToS, etc. Sometimes that is the superior approach, but with something like RHEL rebuilt it makes me nervous. Alma by contrast are very professional. Rocky also has an antagonistic view toward Red Hat, while Alma views Red Hat as partners. People can hate on Red Hat, but without them none of the rebuilds would even be possible. There's still a lot that Red Hat could do to kill them if they wanted to. Anyway my main point, I'm not worried about Alma getting wiped out, or about them making a bad decision that ends them in legal hot water and jeopardizes the project.
- hospitalJail 3y agoI havent been following the saga, just learned about it last week. Was Red Hat losing money? Or they wanted more money?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fuzzylightbulb 3y ago"It's not the pile, it's piling it higher."
- verdverm 3y agoThey sold out to IBM which was already dying, now they are taking Red Hat down with them... sad times I worked at a different office that got blue washed, it was depressing af, feel bad for the long-time redhatters
- sudosysgen 3y agoIBM thought they could extract more than the already nice margins Red Hat was generating.
- yndoendo 3y agoIBM sees economic utility as just making money. They don't see the utility of name branding and ease of transition. For example, I was using CentOS for prototype development. No way would I be able to get RHEL for this. CentOS allowed for not having to hassle with development license management with RHEL. Meaning more time spent on trying to get something work vs handling business to business logistics. This way, if the prototype was deemed acceptable, I could hand off OS management to IT and they could handle B2B logistics. Now I no longer prototype with an easily transferable RHEL style OS. Means IBM just reduced their probability of receiving future support contracts. This is where IBM lacks understanding of economic utility.
- lamontcg 3y agoThe better example is that small companies could build on CentOS and when those small companies become big or get bought by someone big and get infested with useless middle management, RedHat could then sell support contracts into those businesses. CentOS was basically a big loss-leader to get lock-in and just wait until middle management went looking to throw money at vendor support to have someone else to blame. IBM is now going to be cutting that channel off. They might juice a few more contracts in the short term, but mostly they're going to push small businesses away from the RHEL ecosystem entirely and cut off their pipeline of new leads.
- jjnoakes 3y ago> I was using CentOS for prototype development. No way would I be able to get RHEL for this. Why doesn't the free RHEL developer subscription work for this use case? (Honestly curious, as I use it for similar prototype development and want to make sure I'm not missing something).
- omniglottal 3y agoIf you spin up a bunch of cattle, your automation and testing is going to want to be for your specific use case to get the meat from them - the moment you need to waste even 10 minutes dealing with (even uncertainties around) subscription management to name and enumerate each of your "pets", then you know the vendor doesn't care about your real-life problems and will persist in generating roadblocks to fulfill their business requirements while ignoring yours. Where an option exists to do the CI/CD/testing/prototyping with an airgap or where no communication with the mothership is required, and no requests for licenses/subscriptions are needed for you to do your job, that option begins to look very appealing. Sure, you may get a bunch of free dev licenses - but I believe the integration cost of using them costs more engineering effort than option #2: not bothering with any engineering integration effort to fulfil another business's requirements while you should instead be working on your own.
- LordKeren 3y agoCan you share the top contenders for replacements?
- verdverm 3y agodebian most likely, still have to do a proper evaluation, it's a big lift to go from yum to apt though...
- Spivak 3y agoYeah, the saddest bit about RHEL dying is that they really were the best distro by a wide margin. Redhat beat every piece of software into the RHEL way and what came out was an incredibly cohesive system. SELinux for all the years everyone cursed its name ended up working great in the end. All while being the most adventurous and ambitious distro in terms of adopting new userspace primitives.
- cratermoon 3y agoRedHat was the first linux distro I ever installed on one of my own machines, so it has some sentimental value for me, but it's been a long time since I used it either personally or at work.
- CookieCrisp 3y agoI started doing this yesterday, and with chatgpt 4’s help it hasn’t been as bad as I feared - I’ve been able to dump Ansible playbooks into it and ask for Debian package names/alternatives - obviously it depends on what you have, and my needs are definitely not nearly as demanding as they will be for a lot of companies, but I have around 100 servers that I will be switching over, and what I feared would be a mammoth task is now looking like something I can knock out in a couple weeks
- aeyes 3y agoNot really because people who are using RHEL in the first place are $BigCorp which run enterprise software (for example Oracle) for which you can only get support if you run on a supported enterprise OS. So we'd just run RHEL for the clients who needed these support contracts and used CentOS for everyone else to still have a homogeneous environment. With Debian I can't get this kind of support. So the options are reduced to Oracle Linux and SLES/openSUSE.
- traceroute66 3y agoAnd now with the release of Debian 12 ("bookworm"), Debian is now sufficiently up-to-date for most users.
- NegativeK 3y agoHas RHEL ever been about being up to date? I thought their selling point was maintaining ancient ass software.
- rurban 3y agoYou are mixing that up with Debian
- brazzledazzle 3y agoThey backport a lot so you can run your ancient-ass software knowing you have maintained security patches.
- betaby 3y ago> sufficiently up-to-date for most users Always has been, compared to RHEL
- Twirrim 3y agoThe "problem" with Debian is the lifecycle. You get about a 12-24 months at most of security patches, and that's effectively it (the patching model after that is unreliable). That means you've got to allocate resources for upgrading/validating far more regularly than you would with other distributions. Depending on the size of your business, that could get really expensive and disruptive, for negligible benefit. Canonical Ubuntu has a longer support on their LTS releases, and may be preferable. If you can get past annoyance with things like snaps.
- tsimionescu 3y agoIt should be noted, as many businesses are finding out, that you can't redistribute Ubuntu binaries or sources as-is, since they contain registered trademarks of Canonical. So, if you want to ship Ubuntu-based systems, you actually have to maintain your own version of all of their software stripped of the trademarks and re-compiled, or pay them. It seems Canonical is getting more interested in actually enforcing this, I believe they mostly ignored it for a long time now. Debian seems like a much simpler alternative than doing all this. Source: https://ubuntu.com/legal/intellectual-property-policy https://ubuntu.com/legal/intellectual-property-policy > Any redistribution of modified versions of Ubuntu must be approved, certified or provided by Canonical if you are going to associate it with the Trademarks. Otherwise you must remove and replace the Trademarks and will need to recompile the source code to create your own binaries [emphasis mine]. This does not affect your rights under any open source licence applicable to any of the components of Ubuntu. If you need us to approve, certify or provide modified versions for redistribution you will require a licence agreement from Canonical, for which you may be required to pay. For further information, please contact us (as set out below).
- p_l 3y agoI'll admit it's a big source of schadenfreude for me and I hope compliance reaches similar decisions at $DAYJOB.
- techwizrd 3y agoThis has definitely spooked us as well. We have numerous images based on our rocky base image, so we're looking at what moving away from all things RHEL, Rocky, etc. as well.
- brnt 3y agoI don't understand all these CentOS forks: you're still dealing with Red Hat and reinforcing their ecosystem for free. What if those forks poured the effort behind Debian? A truly democratic distro that cannot pull rugs from under your feet.
- Kwpolska 3y agoIf you want Debian, just use Debian. The idea behind CentOS and its successors is to have a free distro that is bug-for-bug compatible with RHEL, so that you can support users of your software who are on RHEL, or use software supported only on RHEL for free.
- brnt 3y agoThat's the idea, but Red Hat is making that ever more difficult. And I can understand why. Why would you build your world on such shifting sands, when all those forks could pitch in on Debian long term support instead? Or just shell out for RHEL?
- fragmede 3y agoBecause it hasn't hurt Apple to have their proprietary garden and Red Hat has learned from that. Once you're big enough, people are going to do the work to support your nonsense (eg Asahi Linux) and build their world on your shifting sand. So why would you, as Red Hat, put in extra effort and not be capricious and hard to work with? It just costs you money that you apparently don't have to spend. Call it the Elon Musk is an Asshole (EMA) era of business.
- garbagecoder 3y agoThe gratuitous anti-Apple remark. Walled gardens are at least as old as video game consoles and I can run whatever I want on macOS even if I can’t on my phone. Somehow, whenever anyone spots a flaw in the FOSS model, it’s Apple’s fault. This is what people wanted, this is libre. Red Hat can sell for money. Remember, kids, CC violates a freedom!
- _ea1k 3y agoI'm not sure that the old model did either, tbh. The clones were never a great choice if you needed to satisfy business concerns.
- cratermoon 3y ago> Red Hat got blue washed I'm not sure I understand the term. Wikipedia says, "Bluewashing is term used to describe deceptive marketing that overstates a company's commitment to responsible social practices. It can be used interchangeably with the term greenwashing but has a greater focus on economic and community factors." If I follow your usage, you're saying that Red Hat states they are committed to the ethics and social responsibilities of FOSS and the GPL but the actual practices violate those factors. If they are using GPL code but not releasing their code, then I would tend to agree, but IANAL. Can you clarify a bit?
- CHY872 3y agoIBM = big blue. Red Hat were bought by IBM a few years back.
- cratermoon 3y agoAh, I hadn't thought of that angle. IBM has become the CA Technologies (formerly Computer Associates International) or MicroFocus of the 21st century.
- that_guy_iain 3y agoI read messages like this and it always seems like folk think Red Hat are missing out because people aren't using a free competitor. What I think this change will make happen, 80-95% of the companies using CentOS or Rocky stop using RHEL based linux distros. But the rest start paying Red Hat. Those who moved away were never going to buy anyways so why should Red Hat care if they don't use a free competitor that used their work?
- ROTMetro 3y agoThere's two ways to increase business income, extract more $$$ from a captured user base or create value to attract revenue. One is a sign of a healthy company looking at future growth, the other the sign of a zombie company that has to put a tighter squeeze on you quarter after quarter to keep their numbers up. The people making purchasing/vendor decisions take into consideration the risk of going with a 'zombie' company, so those that do pay are also likely to consider moving away as well.
- that_guy_iain 3y ago"Zombie company" is a weird way to describe a profitable company. How many people are going to say "You know what, this solves my problem really well but I am scared they're not going to solve future problems?" Especially in the sector that Red Hat are in, a world where there is a famous quote of "No one gets fired for buying IBM". IBM/Red Hat are not in the cycle where they create new products and create value that way, they're in the business of buying things and increasing their market share that way. And have been for quite some time.