3 ms·
On the contrary, the loop is: 1. "Computers will never be able to X, as that requires imagination and intuitive thinking" 2. "X is at least 50 years away" 3.
by ben_w 3y ago
On the contrary, the loop is:
1. "Computers will never be able to X, as that requires imagination and intuitive thinking"
2. "X is at least 50 years away"
3. Press release: Computers do X (last I saw: Diplomacy (the game not the job), interpretation of medical scans)
4. "X isn't real AI, it's just brute force search/a big database/a glorified Markov chain/linear algebra" (LLMs and diffusion models go here, self driving cars)
5. Computers better at X than most/all humans, but still improved by having human collaborators (Go is either here or 6, IIRC also some variations of Poker, Starcraft, half the Amstrad back catalog)
6. Computers only made worse by having a human trying to help (Chess goes here)
- throwuwu 3y agoYou conveniently left out the media hype cycles
- ben_w 3y agoThe hype cycles are not relevant.
- paxys 3y agoNow do flying cars, self driving cars, brain interfaces, 3D printed organs, fusion power, humanoid robots... For every piece of tech that exceeded people's expectations, there are five more that never got out of science fiction books despite decades of continuous investment and constant media hype.
- ben_w 3y ago> flying cars, Helicopters. Also a bajillion startups that charge 100k, currently iterations are basically human sized quadcopters. Not sure how relevant any of that is though, as I was specifically writing about AI… > self driving cars, I tagged #4 already > brain interfaces, 3D printed organs, fusion power, humanoid robots. All #2, IMO, with a few that might count as a #3 technically but not being good enough to deserve it. Although, again, not sure it's relevant, as they're not AI. (Have any of those been dismissed as absolutely impossible rather than just hard? I'm not a student of mass media, so I don't know where to look. But brain interfaces seem to me to be what the very first use of galvanic cells on frog's legs were pointing towards, and artificial fusion has been obviously possible in principle since the 50s because of the fusion bomb…)
- pfsalter 3y agoI'd say that none of these have been proved to be impossible but they're hard in a different way than a lot of the developments we're used to because of Moore's Law.
- chinchilla2020 3y agoThat isn't the loop. A lot of predictions about computers have turned out wrong. The biggest one in my lifetime was the belief that social media would bring the world together, create world peace, and spread economic prosperity. Usually the technologies that surprise us were predicted by nobody. They just show up. Go watch "2001: A Space Odyssey". Then go watch some music videos from 2001. You will get a better idea about how accurate these predictions are.
- 1970-01-01 3y ago>That isn't the loop. Unfortunately, you're right, that isn't the loop. Any new tech is also the novel weapon of tomorrow. I can't even think of a counter-example.
- chinchilla2020 3y agoI'm jealous of your username, zero.
- antifa 3y ago> social media would bring the world together, create world peace, and spread economic prosperity. I don't it'll happen, but it's a little early to declare yourself the winner.
- chinchilla2020 3y agoFair enough. Give it a couple more decades to play out completely.
- civilized 3y agoEven GPT is not at all what anyone predicted before the late 2010s, when we started seeing Transformers scaling up and improving rapidly with more data. Now that we've cottoned onto that trend, it's all anyone talks about. Which is going to make it extra funny when it doesn't deliver what so many predict.
- nonameiguess 3y ago