5 ms·
Buybacks don’t necessarily “suppress” price discovery, they’re just another mechanism for imputing per-share price, like revenue, margin, etc. If you wish, it’
by gen220 3y ago
Buybacks don’t necessarily “suppress” price discovery, they’re just another mechanism for imputing per-share price, like revenue, margin, etc.
If you wish, it’s trivial to filter out the effect of buybacks. Look at market cap over time instead of price over time. Look at market cap divided by revenue over time, instead of market cap divided by share price over time.
Buybacks are not always the best use of capital, but with BRK as a key shareholder, you feel that it must make sense in their circumstance. The same money Apple invested in buybacks, its competitors have invested in dubious hiring sprees and unchecked R&D.
I wouldn’t add to my apple position, but I wouldn’t consider selling any time soon. The folks at BRK know better than me!
- slashdev 3y agoI think you misunderstand me. What I’m saying is that price inelastic demand for the stock through buybacks puts upward pressure on the stock price, no matter the current price, preventing the normal market process of price discovery from working well. This then is amplified by passive investment. I think that’s what makes buybacks so effective. I’m not saying anything about it making it harder to determine the intrinsic value of a stock, which I think is what you’re talking about.