3 ms·
If these auctions were common, it seems like it would be a ripe opportunity for arbitrage. In a case like this if you thought the market value was $100k, someo
by crazygringo 3y ago
If these auctions were common, it seems like it would be a ripe opportunity for arbitrage.
In a case like this if you thought the market value was $100k, someone with no interest in the license should go ahead and bid something like $60k anyways. If everybody else placed silly bids like $4 "just in case nobody else bids for real", you'll win and resell it and walk away with $40k profit.
Of course this assumes there is an actual market for the thing -- that a telecoms company really will take it off your hands for $100k.
Although if there really is only one person in the world who wants something and they would pay $100k for it... and literally nobody else has any interest in it at all... then there's a good argument to be made that it really is worth $0. Like a remote island that is utter perfection for one hermit, but of zero interest to anyone else.
- traek 3y agoA key property of a Vickrey auction is that it is incentive compatible, i.e. that it isn't possible to achieve a better expected outcome by bidding something other than your true valuation. Your example relies on the telecom company (or any secondary buyer) not bidding in the auction or bidding only $4. A strictly dominant strategy for the telecom company would be to bid $100k in the auction, winning it for $60k (the second-highest price).
- qup 3y ago> In a case like this if you thought the market value was $100k, someone with no interest in the license should go ahead and bid something like $60k anyways. If everybody else placed silly bids like $4 "just in case nobody else bids for real", you'll win and resell it and walk away with $40k profit. No, in a case like this, you would risk having to fork over 60k, and you would in reality win nothing. The company that bid 100k gets it for 60k, you spend and receive nothing.