3 ms·
You're worried about skin color being used as a determining factor, but you were admitted based on zip code. That's trying to admit disadvantaged people, but n
by AnimalMuppet 3y ago
You're worried about skin color being used as a determining factor, but you were admitted based on zip code. That's trying to admit disadvantaged people, but not doing so based on skin color. So maybe in this specific case, they're already looking at it with more nuance? Or at least a different axis than skin color?
- solardev 3y agoWhile a charitable view, my impression is that was unlikely. The school itself was already located in an impoverished area. They didn't need to recruit from the other side of the state to find disadvantaged students. And their materials said nothing public about special admissions for disadvantaged people. It wasn't until I met face to face with a counselor that they let me in. My guess -- it's only a guess, I can't prove this -- is that the counselor had some leeway to determine whether to admit me, and that there was an unwritten mandate to prioritize candidates of color. I don't know if whites from those same zip codes would've gotten the same treatment. It seemed to me like the face time was a possible way for the university to hide race quotas behind judgment calls. I don't have the numbers for this though, just a hunch. And to their credit, we did have poor white applicants who did get in, obviously, or I wouldn't have gotten to know them. It wasn't an especially selective school to begin with. But it did seem like zip code recruiting was a proxy for race based recruiting. If they wanted income based recruiting they could've done that from anywhere without geography as a constraint.