3 ms·
Even if 100% of the court agreed, 9 people can't possibly represent 300 million in any representative way. Even Congress with 535 representatives isn't many. O
by solardev 3y ago
Even if 100% of the court agreed, 9 people can't possibly represent 300 million in any representative way.
Even Congress with 535 representatives isn't many. One representative for each 600,000 citizens? When was the last time a thousand Americans agreed on anything, much less half a million?
We have one of the worst ratios in the world:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_legislatures_by_number_of_members?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_legislatures_by_number...
Edit: And the SC isn't representative anyway. They're appointed by the elites for the benefit of the ruling party, and there's a lot of politicking for those seats. Way too much power and corruption -- for life. The institution itself is a problem.
- catiopatio 3y agoThey’re not supposed to be representative. Democracy isn’t perfect, and they’re a check against some of the failings of the system. Frankly, I’m shocked at how upset some of you are over racial discrimination being banned.
- solardev 3y agoThere's not really checks and balances when all three branches are in cahoots for the benefit of party over people, primarily won through electoral shenanigans and political games. We literally have a system that continously overrules the will of the majority with a small group of electoral elites, justified using some byzantine algorithm of electoral boundaries. That isn't a democracy, it's a farce. I don't really care about affirmative action much one way or the other. I care about the lack of representation in my so called democracy, and the Supremes are a huge part of that problem.
- catiopatio 3y ago> We literally have a system that continously overrules the will of the majority … That isn't a democracy, it's a farce. Avoiding the tyranny of the majority is a major reason we intentionally don’t have direct democracy.
- solardev 3y agoThrough a legal framework enumerating basic inalienable rights, perhaps. But substituting a tyranny of the majority for a tyranny of the minority isn't an improvement.
- fzeroracer 3y ago[flagged]
- catiopatio 3y agoThat’s a reductive view of the laws and cases involved. The cakeshop case was about compelled speech, and the conservative justices’ politics are not “neocon”.
- fzeroracer 3y agoDiscrimination is discrimination, no matter how you try to slice it. The compelled speech argument was a line of bullshit to discriminate against customers because it all hinged on their religious right to discriminate against people they did not like. That's the crux of it all.
- londons_explore 3y ago> 9 people can't possibly represent 300 million in any representative way. If they were 9 randomly selected citizens, then the majority vote of the 9 matches the result of a majority vote of the 300 million nearly always, particularly for decisive issues. For example, if 90% of the population think something, then there is a 0.089% chance that a majority of the 9 citizens disagree. Obviously judge selection isn't random, and thats probably your main concern.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoThe SC is, by design, a little undemocratic. They're a check against the more democratic parts of the government, with the limitation that they basically can only make things legal. Since the default is that people are free to do whatever, laws can only restrict people's abilities to do stuff. The Supreme Court gets to shoot down laws, so they can only let us do more stuff.