3 ms·
> I can personally memorize and recite copyrighted works all I want, Whoever told you that is lying to you. You are not legally allowed to personally memorize
by pessimizer 3y ago
> I can personally memorize and recite copyrighted works all I want,
Whoever told you that is lying to you. You are not legally allowed to personally memorize and recite copyrighted works all you want, any more than you're allowed to personally memorize, write down copyrighted works, and distribute them as much as you want.
All piracy is a process of computer-assisted remembering and reciting.
- mrtranscendence 3y agoWell, you could memorize and recite copyrighted works all you want, as long as you're doing it in an empty room without anyone listening.
- criddell 3y agoWould you say reading a book to my kids before bed is illegal?
- mrtranscendence 3y agoSorry, I was being a little flip. There's more to it than that, of course. Is the performance sufficiently transformative, is it educational, is it non-profit, etc.
- DirkH 3y agoLast I checked I can legally enter any bookstore with copyrighted books, pick up a book, and read it. And then tell anyone what I read. I can't go write and commercialize what I learnt directly, but I'm not breaking the law by quickly seeing how some book I didn't buy ends so I can talk about it at a party - and then everyone knows how it ends which might affect whether they want to buy said book and upset the author. But, tough shit, what I did was legal. I can even use the ending as one set of input from dozens of inspirations for my own book where the end result is transformative enough where the sources are unrecognizable. And if I had learnt about the endings from a dozen books without buying those books I didn't break any laws even though I am now commercializing something in being inspired by them all to make something new.
- anktor 3y agoMaybe it would be useful what "tell anyone what I read" means. Because if you mean 1 to some in a room, then most likely. If you use any type of broadcasting then most definitely no. Try reading outloud a script from a recent movie on twitch/youtube/radio/tv and whether it gets DMCA'd or not. Same for books, songs I guess... not? But not sure.
- DirkH 3y agoI just mean I can socialize and talk about it without the police telling me that's illegal because I didn't pay to be allowed to talk about said plot points