4 ms·
This is also a very good article: https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/composite-submersibles-under-pressure-in-deep-deep-waters https://www.compositesworl
by jacquesm 3y ago
This is also a very good article:
https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/composite-submersibles-under-pressure-in-deep-deep-waters https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/composite-submersib...
- mpenick 3y agoInteresting find! Lots of information about the winding and the materials used. I wish there was more information about the epoxy used to adhere the titanium endcaps to the hull. I also wonder what changed between the Cyclops 2 and the Titan.
- mpenick 3y agoI also wonder what changed between the Cyclops 2 and the Titan.
- nimbleplum40 3y agoNothing. Cyclops 2 is the Titan.
- pvaldes 3y agoI assume that just the name. Cyclops was a monster that lost his one eye in battle. The submarine had one window and the name suggests that window being damaged at some point. Titan suggests a more positive and strong image without suggesting the bad parts. In any case the submarine couldn't avoid the cyclops destiny and cyclopsioned entirely.
- jacquesm 3y agoTitan is simply short for Titanic...
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe titanium endcaps weren't connected with epoxy, but bolts. https://twitter.com/Alphafox78/status/1671872409861869568 https://twitter.com/Alphafox78/status/1671872409861869568
- SirSourdough 3y agoI believe it’s both really. My understanding is the end caps are bolted to a titanium flange, not the carbon fibre hull directly. The titanium flange the caps are bolted to is epoxied to the hull.
- nickpinkston 3y agoYea, you generally try to avoid drilling holes or even casting threaded bosses into carbon or other composites, especially this extreme pressure rig, because it really reduces the strength versus an strong adhesive that evenly applies pressure without breaking/disrupting the composite material.
- SkyMarshal 3y agoThey use some sort of glue to seal the titanium rings to the CF hull, then the Titanium hemisphere end caps are bolted to the rings. Here’s their own YT vid showing the construction process: https://youtu.be/WK99kBS1AfE https://youtu.be/WK99kBS1AfE
- daxuak 3y agoI suppose the article meant cap itself was a carbon fiber/epoxy build, implying nothing about the connection? On a separate note, although the submarine failed catastrophically, that doesn't mean every decision it took was wrong. I wonder if the bolts actually make sense under high water pressure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bambax 3y agoNot really. There were titanium rings at each end of the cylinder, fixed with glue, and then the caps were bolted onto said rings.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SkyMarshal 3y agoI believe Cyclops 2 is Titan, just renamed. Cyclops 1 is a smaller steel-hulled submersible.
- ubermonkey 3y agoWhat little I know about composites/carbon fiber STRONGLY suggest it's a terrible approach for a submersible. Am I wrong?
- pvaldes 3y agoThe results speak loudly by themselves. This is not the first submarine build and many of the other are still on duty after decades.
- dan_quixote 3y agoNot necessarily. CFRP is plenty strong to handle the task. But it's a complicated material - though not necessarily new. I think one complication people underestimate when comparing to steel or titanium is that CFRP is NOT isotropic - meaning that its physical properties are NOT the same regardless of orientation. Another is that CFRP has so many dimensions to its strength (e.g. orientation of resolved force vs fiver orientation, fiber diameter, fiber length, fiber material, epoxy material, etc). Yet another is the concept of fatigue life. Steel is very forgiving in this regard - as long as you don't strain it enough to reach plastic deformation, you're good almost forever. CFRP (and even aluminum) have a lifetime no matter what. In that case, you need decent non-destructive testing techniques of which I'm certainly not an expert. I have one major unanswered question about it though...is there any reason they needed the weight savings one gets from CFRP? Every sub I've ever heard of requires additional ballast to dive even when using tried-and-true steel hull. If they didn't need the weight savings, it was completely absurd to use CFRP.
- jcalvinowens 3y agoThe metal pressure vessels are very negatively buoyant. The bathyscaphe Trieste used 32000 gallons of gasoline to achieve positive buoyancy. Modern DSVs use incredibly expensive and fragile syntactic foam. A CFRP pressure vessel can be naturally positively buoyant, or much closer to it. Titan's dry weight was less than DSV Limiting Factor, despite having much greater internal volume and carrying 3 more people. Also, being able to load and launch in the water, rather than loading on the deck and needing a human rated crane to launch as most DSVs do, probably saved a lot of money operating Titan.
- everybodyknows 3y ago> Length, 2,540 mm; outside diameter, 1,676 mm; service pressure, 6,600 psi; pressure safety factor, 2.25. “They basically said, ‘This is the pressure we have to meet, this is the factor of safety, this is the basic envelope. Go design and build it,’” Spencer reports. And he was given six weeks in which to do it. Six weeks. Classic checkbox-driven Technical Program Mismanagement (TPM) by whim of pseudo-technical overreaching hucksters.