8 ms·
"Kagi is building a novel ad-free, paid search engine and a powerful web browser as a part of our mission to humanize the web." With 670K? Cuil went through a
by Animats 3y ago
"Kagi is building a novel ad-free, paid search engine and a powerful web browser as a part of our mission to humanize the web."
With 670K?
Cuil went through about $30 million to develop a standalone search engine.
And that was fifteen years ago, when search was simpler.
There may be a market for a search engine company that profitably runs a low-cost operation with very few ads and makes real efforts to keep out spam. Everybody is fed up with Google and Bing. There's a great opportunity here to disrupt the industry and destroy a trillion dollars in market cap.
But not for $670K.
- yxre 3y agoI use it, and it's better than google and duckduckgo. What features are they missing?
- johnnyanmac 3y agosomeone below linked to the fact that they do leverage other search engines for their tech. So that can explain the lower cost: https://kagi.com/faq#Where-are-your-results-coming-from https://kagi.com/faq#Where-are-your-results-coming-from It's more about curation (and I guess some machine learning) than completely new tech.
- PufPufPuf 3y agoHave you seen what they've already built? The product is out there and very usable: https://kagi.com/ https://kagi.com/
- golemotron 3y agoThat $30 million might not have yielded a great search engine but it did produce Cuil Theory, a branch of mathematics with the potential to change the world: http://cuiltheory.wikidot.com/what-is-cuil-theory/ http://cuiltheory.wikidot.com/what-is-cuil-theory/
- sunnybeetroot 3y agoThis is a joke about how bad the search results of Cuil were right?
- golemotron 3y agoYes, but very amusing regardless of how it came to be.
- ColinHayhurst 3y agoCongratulations Kagi. We beg to differ on the need to raise large sums. Like Kagi we are on a marathon not a sprint. We have built a no-tracking and completely independent crawler search engine and infrastructure from the ground-up having raised £3m from angels only. Cuil, Blekko, Quaero and Neeva who raised 10s/100s of $m may have come and gone; meanwhile we have been slowly building since 2004, with a user and API customer base that is also growing healthily.
- hgsgm 3y agoDo you have an option to filter out or downrank porn when I search for a slightly obscure initialism?
- ColinHayhurst 3y agoWe have Adult Search option available for API customers. This will be rolled out on mojeek.com very soon.
- freediver 3y agoThanks Colin!
- ignoramous 3y agoPer TFA, this money was mostly raised from Kagi's existing customers. They aren't building a web crawler. Kagi is a search "client" (it is one way to build on a shoestring budget, alright), augmented by an in-house small-scale just-in-time crawler. > From here, we take your query and use it to aggregate data from multiple other sources, including but not limited to Google, Bing, and Wikipedia, and other internal data sources in order to procure your search results. https://help.kagi.com/kagi/privacy/privacy-protection.html https://help.kagi.com/kagi/privacy/privacy-protection.html > We also have our own non-commercial index (Teclis), news index (TinyGem), and an AI for instant answers. https://help.kagi.com/kagi/search-details/search-sources.html https://help.kagi.com/kagi/search-details/search-sources.htm... I like Kagi's general vision for LLMs + Search. There's a real chance small competitors can compete with Google with clever use of LLMs' zero-shot summarization, categorization, intent recognition, and answering abilities.
- kaba0 3y ago> competitors can compete with Google Especially when google continues to be worse off year after year. Just search for my damn keywords, like you did 10 years ago, especially when I have already put quotes around them because you Re useless!
- grantcarthew 3y agoI've been using Kagi since I could first get onto the product. As soon as it came out of Beta, I subscribed. I had no idea how intrusive Google was. I love Google services. Google Cloud is far better than the others. That said, the search is just poison. I now spend time looking at results, not searching for results. I have to admit though, ChatGPT did make me consider dropping the subscription. Mr Chat has weakened the value of Kagi to me. They have their own AI summarizer engine though: https://kagi.com/summarizer/index.html https://kagi.com/summarizer/index.html
- ignoramous 3y ago> Google Cloud is far better than the others. Per their own documentation, Kagi servers are hosted on Google Cloud.
- qmarchi 3y agoThat in of itself isn't such a scary thing. There's real restrictions, contractually, that Google has on accessing any data the a customer generates, and of which carry hefty fees for Google. This is one of the reasons on why some Google products never launch with support for Workspace accounts. There's just too much red-tape that a team doesn't want to deal with. Source and Disclaimer: I was a Technical Solutions Engineer for Google Cloud.
- unshavedyak 3y agoAs a subscriber to both ChatGPT and Kagi, agreed. You may be interested to know that Kagi also has https://labs.kagi.com/fastgpt https://labs.kagi.com/fastgpt. It's been pretty good in my tests so far, nothing magical just fast and similar to a search input field.
- furyofantares 3y ago> I have to admit though, ChatGPT did make me consider dropping the subscription. Mr Chat has weakened the value of Kagi to me. I felt the same, but I do still need web search, and I do still want it to be as good as possible, so it's still worth it to me. And actually, as I type this I'm less sure about how much ChatGPT has reduced the value of web search for me. I start with ChatGPT for almost everything that's not "news". But I still frequently do web searches branching out from what I learned via ChatGPT. It's fewer total searches than I've done before, but each one might be more valuable. And since I'm flowing from one tool to another, not having to wade through ads and bad ui and SEO spam also becomes even more valuable.
- shafyy 3y agoStop drinking the VC kool-aid. It's possible to build almost any software business without huge upfront investments.
- Sakos 3y agoThere's a huge difference between typical VC funding and what this is. Kagi is already a self-sustaining business with a working and effective search engine. This is extra funding on top that they have available for improving Kagi. That's great. You don't need 30 million for that.
- Tade0 3y agoPerhaps the business is already sustainable and that $670k will just let them hire an additional person to speed things up a bit? There's a lot of wasted effort in this industry. Slack has 1500+ employees just to make a chat app. Granted, it's a damn good chat app, but Mozilla is maintaining a browser with half as many people, with not everyone focused on Firefox at that. My friend is now in a project where he billed for three weeks until all the issues with his dev account were sorted out. It remains unclear when he will be able to start actually working. I spent two years building a web app + gRPC server that perhaps could have been just the latter. I could go on. Point is, you can blow through $30mln easily but that doesn't mean you have to.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoI think a small operation is exactly the sort of outfit to do it. Makes you focus on what is important. The absolute worst way you can arrange a search engine project is as some sort of manhattan project with a humongous budget and an army of professors and experts. History is littered with bold and ambitious Google killers that went nowhere. You can throw almost any amount of money at an operation, and it will gobble it up. I think search in particular is very prone to bloated R&D budgets and various forms of mission creep. Yet the underlying reality is that software development scales very poorly with organization size, and the larger your organization is, the harder it is to steer and the more difficult it is to make the right calls. A squad of 3-4 motivated and talented guys is absolute peak get-shit-done.
- andsoitis 3y ago> I think a small operation is exactly the sort of outfit to do it. Makes you focus on what is important. They're focusing on 2 things: a search engine AND a Mac-only web browser.
- hgsgm 3y agoA nearly impossible project and a nearly pointless project make a perfect pairing.
- sofixa 3y ago> Mac-only web browser Such a waste. MacOS users might be open to paying (for Kagi in general) because they're used to paying for a bunch of things other OSes get included or as freeware, but still, the market share is small (depending on the source, 10-30%). And even if many of those would enjoy a Mac-native app, there are at least some, like myself, that refuse to use single platform tools. I have a bunch of devices on a bunch of different OSes, I'm not going to use a very special browser on one of them, losing sync, history, muscle memory when switching. That's the reason I can't stay on Arc even if I quite like some of it's goals and structure.
- freediver 3y ago
- raincole 3y agoThe less money they raise the more hope I have in them. So long story short, my opinion is the exact polar opposite of what you said.
- resolutebat 3y agoI'm happily paying $10/mo for Kagi, I find it genuinely better* than Google already. And yes, it's genuinely amazing that it's a pipsqueak startup that's pulling this off. * For core search, that is, obviously there's vast slabs of services like maps, translate, etc etc where they're not even trying to compete.
- detourdog 3y agoThis demonstrates to me how distorted searching has become. The early days of the web. The standard thing was to show someone yahoo which was a human curated list of sites. The other site was a search engine from one of the colleges I think it was Lycos. This changed with ads. Suddenly search engines were used to find people searching.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoAt their current pricing, about 10k paying users would get them 600K/year in revenue. Which is what they just raised. Enough for a small team and modest infrastructure. You don't need a lot to serve 600K users. All they need to do is nail enough value add for those users. The wider goal of disrupting Google/Bing is a different game. But getting a small company to 10K paying users might be doable given enough of a value add. Of course they are based in the Bay area, so this kind of money doesn't have a huge runway there.
- detourdog 3y agoThey have already done it I’m a paying subscriber.
- dcow 3y agoKagi has been around since 2018. They're privately bootstrapped (not by a VC firm). 670K is not the only money that's gone into the business. 670K is how a bootstrapped company responsibly raises money.
- thiht 3y agoI have no idea how you could justify a $30 million budget. $670k seems much more reasonable to me. I can imagine where this budget goes, the numbers make sense.
- fho 3y agoHave you tried kagi? Because I have and it is pretty good. I was sold when they summarized several "listicles" (ie your typical Top10 blog spam) into one concise listing. "Yes these results would pop up for your search ... but you probably don't want to look at them".
- tailspin2019 3y ago> But not for $670K. As someone who has already replaced Google with Kagi, as far as I'm concerned they've already done it. I've never paid Google for anything (apart from with my data) but I've been paying Kagi for almost a year now. The model is different. From what I've seen so far, it's better. The amount of money you burn through is not a good indicator of whether you'll end up with a good product or viable business at the end, IMHO