4 ms·
Hmm.. When working with a I vi IV V in G, it tells me that a substitution of Bm7 for Em produces a ii-V-I in C. It does nothing of the sort! Now a Bm7-5 -> F
by Perenti 3y ago
Hmm.. When working with a I vi IV V in G, it tells me that a substitution of Bm7 for Em produces a ii-V-I in C. It does nothing of the sort! Now a Bm7-5 -> F -> Am is a 2-5 in C, but that's not what it's working with.
- someweirdperson 3y agoI don't see any display of the function, only absolute. Where does it show them? Not only display, it would be nice to be able to choose chords by function instead of absolute, too.
- java_city 3y agoExcellent suggestion! I will add chord input by function in the next version.
- executesorder66 3y ago> it tells me that a substitution of Bm7 for Em produces a ii-V-I in C. That's because it's using GPT-4. Which means it just makes stuff up, and you can't rely on it to tell the truth. It's a fun tool to see possibly novel output, but you can never rely on it to be accurate or correct.
- java_city 3y agoThis is true. I have come across other instances where the explanations are incorrect. The app is not ready for prime time, but fine-tuned models can improve this.
- viraptor 3y agoYou don't need to fine tune GPT4 for it. A tiny in comparison model trained specifically on chords would do much better for creativity and the explanations could be generated without any AI.
- java_city 3y agoThere are lots of ways to solve this problem. Procedural, tiny model, fine-tuned large model, expert systems, etc.