3 ms·
This isn't 100% different than the situation that Google addressed initially. There is information expressed/stored in the Web that is of relevance to the user
by neilv 3y ago
This isn't 100% different than the situation that Google addressed initially.
There is information expressed/stored in the Web that is of relevance to the user's current information need. This is in pages, some of which are higher value than others. There is also a constant battle with bad actors trying to promote information or pages beyond its value or possibly relevance.
If interactive Web search is still going to exist at all (not just BS all our work with AI), then this is an opportunity for Google or someone else to step up.
This could mean aggressive new ideas that weren't viable before. For example, consider going full anti-BS. Basically, any whiff of attempting to manipulate search hits, or stealing/republishing content, or using generative AI is considered a strong signal for low quality, punishable by search engine death sentence. Suddenly, legacy genuine original content percolates to the top, and there's once again a market for high-value content creation. This one could be hard to do sufficiently well, and there might be conflict of interests in disrupting the status quo (e.g., some of a search/adtech company's revenue streams and departments/careers might currently depend on delivering low-value search hits), which could make it painful or face internal resistance.
I don't know who has the will, resources, and agility to do this. One existing player that could've done it with startup thinking a couple decades ago seems to have become more a machine and careers-driven for a long time. Another player has spent decades often operating in bad faith towards everyone, and though they've shown many times that they continue to be capable of long-cons, I'd guess they're probably culturally incapable of reasoning holistically about an approach fundamentally about integrity. Most potential upstarts don't have the know-how nor resources, and startup thinking would need to get back out of investment scam mindsets (whether VC-growth, crypto scams, or founders just trying to get their exit) and go back to trying to do something genuinely great for its own sake.
- seanp2k2 3y ago> some of a search/adtech company's revenue streams and departments/careers might currently depend on delivering low-value search hits What I've come to realize is that most sites that actually get significant traffic these days that run ads (so, all of them) don't really care too much if companies paying for ad space get a good ROI. There are so many stories of companies launching a campaign on Facebook with something like a $10k budget, not configuring the targeting exactly correctly, and burning through their entire ad budget in a few hours with only a few conversions to show for it. Looking at Twitter recently, the only advertisers they seem to be able to attract look to be overseas companies selling junk products for cheap, usually with some kind of "made you look" aspect like bikinis. On that last point, YouTube Shorts also seem to very heavily weight things that appear as if they're going to show some kind of nudity, which of course they don't, just very clickbait-y looking thumbnails in general that don't match the actual content of the short. Does YT Reels require that the thumbnail be a frame from the actual reel? That always seemed like the best policy to me, but of course people game it by putting one "hero" thumbnail frame in that doesn't actually come from the rest of the video to be able to select that as the thumb.
- BoxOfRain 3y agoThis exact problem winds me up when it comes to sailing channels on YouTube, I get that most people just want to look at attractive people sailing about in exotic locations but I wish there was a way to tell YouTube that if I'm searching about boats I'd actually much rather watch someone's long-term restoration job on a 1970s project boat or a very experienced person talking about sailing in the places I actually live near. There's more of that sort of content than I could watch in a lifetime but it only takes one accidental click and your weeks of carefully training it for 'this, not that' falls apart like wet cake. Surely from the perspective of someone buying ads (admittedly I block them so it's a moot point in practice) they'd rather hawk high-value sailing equipment at me than low-value generic youtube tat I've never shown any interest in? I know it's very much not in their interest to develop this since your eyeballs are the product but it would be so great if you could explicitly give the YouTube algorithm heuristics like: 'if the context is sailing exclude videos that heavily feature couples/relationships' or 'if the video sounds like that particular breed of shrill, hyperactive vlogger I'm definitely not interested'.
- jahewson 3y agoThis is a losing proposition for Google because they already dominate all of internet advertising. The more Google is dependent on a smaller number of high-quality content creators the more those creators can demand a bigger slice of the ad revenue pie. Big publishers even run their own ad platforms to cut out Google.
- freediver 3y ago> For example, consider going full anti-BS. Basically, any whiff of attempting to manipulate search hits, or stealing/republishing content, or using generative AI is considered a strong signal for low quality, punishable by search engine death sentence. We are doing something like this at Kagi search. While it is difficult to detect each of these on their own, what is easy to detect is the purpose of the web page if it has advertising on it (and most of these pages exist for the purpose of monetizing low quality content). So we downrank ad-filled pages in our results. It is a simple but effective method for filtering out low quality content.
- Seattle3503 3y agoInteresting. Google has a conflict of interest in doing the same.
- scary-size 3y agoI can attest to that. I’m using Google for work and Kagi for private stuff. There’s quite an overlap in search categories (e.g. tech stuff). With Google, I learnt to scroll past the first three-ish links. On Kagi I had to relearn that the first link is actually the most relevant.
- RileyJames 3y agoThe problem with getting ban happy and that generated / black hat content doesn’t care. It expects to be banned. They just make more. But higher value, none automated content gets killed by google (Adsense ban, negative seo or just out ranked by crap) and then they give us and stay dead. These are hard problems to solve. But google at scale efforts have failed.