10 ms·
Apple Shuts Down “My Photo Stream”
- thorncorona 3y agois it time someone starts killedbyapple.com lol
- yodon 3y ago> is it time someone starts killedbyapple.com? If the fiercest complaint you can muster is that Apple is shutting down a service that was, by today's standards, poorly designed and risky to use (photos only existed for 30 days if you didn't save them) and that has been superseded by a much better product (iCloud) for more than 9 years, well, I guess you must have more time on your hands to be outraged about product decisions than I do.
- thorncorona 3y agoIDK man, they tend to push the industry in anti-consumer ways. They killed the audio jack. That's pretty heinous. And they removed the sim slot. And the finger print reader. And they actively try to kill 3rd party repair.
- wahahah 3y agoOn the other side, they brought a fingerprint reader that actually stored biometric data safely, innaccessible to the OS with the first secure enclave.
- bamfly 3y ago> They killed the audio jack. That's pretty heinous. Yeah, this still sucks. It'll probably never stop being worse than having the jack. > And they removed the sim slot. ... this has been really nice? The new virtual-sim thing has been strictly an improvement, for me. But there may be some use-cases I don't need that it's been worse for, IDK. > And the finger print reader. Poor success rate for me in the best of times, and I had to re-train it every few months or shifting temp & humidity would drop the unlock success rate to like 10%. Face unlock has been a huge improvement for me, and keeps getting better, a couple years of Covid mask-related trouble aside (but, YMMV).
- lockhouse 3y ago> They killed the audio jack. Annoying, but easily fixed with an adapter or bluetooth headphones. > And they removed the sim slot. They're just ahead of the curve on this one. The entire industry is moving to eSims for a number of reasons. This wasn't just Apple. In fact, Samsung was the first major company to release a product that used it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ESIM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ESIM > And the finger print reader. Finger print readers are available on iPhone SEs, iPads (except Pro models), MacBooks, and even the latest version of their desktop keyboards. Every other device either uses Face ID or is something that just doesn't make sense to have biometric unlocking as a feature in the first place. > And they actively try to kill 3rd party repair. Apple devices are not easy to repair, but they do have this: https://support.apple.com/self-service-repair https://support.apple.com/self-service-repair Which is better than what many manufacturers have.
- i386 3y agoNo. They are pretty sensible with their product calls. Either it ends quickly (ping) or they see it through (Apple TV)
- minimaxir 3y agoOr it's like AirPower where they said they were confident they were going to release it but eventually backpedaled.
- asdff 3y agoOr how 3d touch was going to change ios then that must have cut into margins too much and only lasted a few models.
- bamfly 3y agoI could never get it to work consistently enough to make it worth learning what it could do & making it part of my workflow. It got in the way more often than I triggered it on purpose, even when I was trying to give it a fair shot. On Macbook touchpads, all it did was make my drag-n-drop operations fail ~70% of the time. I never did figure out a legitimate use for it on that platform, but then, I had to disable it as soon as I figured out that was what was messing me up. I don't need drag-n-drop to become a dexterity game. And I don't have any fine motor control deficiencies or anything. It was all just too damn fiddly to be worth using. Similar with the touchbar. Turns out my fingers just barely brush the F keys when I hit a couple of the number keys. No problem with physical F-keys, as there's almost no pressure applied, but the touchbar? Had to all but completely disable the damn thing to stop triggering it by accident. Not gonna change my typing muscle-memory for the sake of a fad interface that's not even available on most of the keyboards I touch in a day. Apple's not above making mis-steps. They do it pretty often, in fact.
- asdff 3y agoBootcamp. Actual rosetta that can run 32 bit or powerpc apps. Airport and Time Capsule. The list goes on of pretty nice software and hardware that apple has abandoned over the years. I think a website like this would be pretty interesting to see all the products and features we've lost through the years.
- idk1 3y agoI still miss Bing to this day, there were dozens of users. Dozens!
- nomel 3y agoI would love to see one. I've, personally, never had Apple pull anything out from under me, so I'd be really curious what it would even contain.
- andybak 3y agoI got a bunch of emails about this but I don't really understand what it is. (I barely uses Apple Photos)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gjsman-1000 3y agoIt's a weird feature I doubt anyone used. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201317 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201317 It's a service that existed three years before iCloud Photo syncing, being released in 2011 with iCloud in 2014. It's safe to say almost everyone uses iCloud. It appears that it let you "stream" your photos to other devices without having to plug them in, but photos were only saved for 30 days if you didn't save them to local storage from the stream. So it wasn't really a storage product as much as a weird, convenient? way to move photos from an iPad to a Mac, for example.
- highwaylights 3y agoThe idea of photo stream was that you could have your photos on more than one of your devices but not stored on an ongoing basis in the cloud. The photos would be stored in the cloud for up to 30 days to allow each of your subscribed devices to download them within locally within that timeframe, then would be deleted.
- TheJoeMan 3y agoAnd when you are a celebrity who gets their icloud hacked, or the feds file a warrant, there’s no photos for Apple to give.
- n42 3y agoI lost a couple years of photos of my life to this stupid thing, because it wasn't very clear to me that photos were only kept around for 30 days
- highwaylights 3y agoEven though I don't really use it, this really frustrates me. Apple is moving iCloud further into macOS and making the Mac more akin to an Apple Chromebook with every release. Time Machine gets little to no love, and users are getting steered ever more strongly towards backing up data onto iCloud. Even buying an Apple device isn't really buying a device anymore. You're really buying a transferable lease for 6-7 years on a device that has a hard stop to go to landfill after that time due to software obsolescence by way of unpatched vulnerabilities. I don't actually dislike Chromebooks at all, but this is saddening when you've bought a computer to use it as a computer and any sense of ownership or agency is quietly clawed away.
- thorncorona 3y ago> You're really buying a transferable lease for 6-7 years on a device that has a hard stop to go to landfill after that time due to software obsolescence by way of unpatched vulnerabilities. If you define a lease as a period of time where a device gets security patches, has this ever not been the case?
- freedomben 3y ago> has this ever not been the case? Windows XP got patches for over 10 years IIRC. It was a different time, but you did ask "ever"
- thatguy0900 3y agoI'm not really seeing a big enough difference between 7 and 10 years to call one ownership and the other leasing to be honest
- setr 3y ago…so it still has a hard stop, just 3-4 years further into the future?
- CivBase 3y agoWindows 10 was released in July 2015 and is currently set to receive updates until October 2025. That's a little over 10 years. And with previous generations of Windows there was nothing really stopping you from upgrading to a newer OS on the same old hardware - although you might run into serious performance issues with a modern Windows OS on 10+ year old hardware. But you could also switch to plenty of other OSes. I assume that's also an option for 7+ year old Macs?
- SilverBirch 3y agoI guess they must have pretty good data indicating that photo stream doesn't add any value. Yes, it is just another view on an existing data set, but if people used it I'm sure they wouldn't get rid of it. I can't imagine it's that expensive to run, unless the storage used for it falls outside of the icloud storage that they charge for.
- bamfly 3y agoI've been a pretty heavy Apple user since ~2011 and had to search to find out WTF this even is (TFA didn't give me enough info to determine what the point of it was).
- agloe_dreams 3y agoThat is exactly it. It was a 30 day backup with no cost and no storage inclusion. It could keep people from buying iCloud storage
- bamfly 3y agoAnyone maintaining their own backups as a cost-savings strategy must have found a much more efficient way to do it than I have. Plus value their time at $0/hr. And/or are doing it in a way that's guaranteed to lose much of their data at least once in their lifetime. I doubt enough people were still using this that it'll make much difference in iCloud profits even if all of them who weren't already paying for iCloud, start.
- mikl 3y agoThis is a feature that’s long been superseded by iCloud Photos and it’s been disabled by default on new installations of iOS for years. I don’t think anyone will miss it.
- user3939382 3y agoIf you're looking for someone who can find a problem with a product decision from big tech, you've come to the right place.
- abirch 3y agoYour comment reminds me of this xkcd https://xkcd.com/1172/ https://xkcd.com/1172/
- soligern 3y agoNot for people like me that refuse to use iCloud or store personal data (photos, videos) on any cloud service. I’m especially annoyed they put Find My and Apple Pay behind iCloud which means I can’t use it.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI was never thrilled with it, but I'm probably not their target demographic.
- antimora 3y agoOur family is using Amazon Photos with Family Vault feature that collects photos in one place. We use Amazon Echo Show to display the photos. We got tired by Echo's spam (we want to use only for photo frame and other features) and we would like to transition to iCloud Photos but we cannot find a similar solution. Can anyone recommend a good set up with iCloud Photos and some sort of hardware to view our photos on an always on display? We do not wish to manually copy our photos to be clear.
- vtail 3y agoSomething like this? https://www.tomsguide.com/how-to/how-to-turn-an-old-ipad-into-a-digital-photo-frame https://www.tomsguide.com/how-to/how-to-turn-an-old-ipad-int...
- sholladay 3y agoAn iPad mounted to a wall or on a stand would be my suggestion. You can leave it plugged in and set the display to never turn off. There are a few different ways you could display your photos. One way would be to set the lock screen wallpaper to shuffle photos. The benefit of this approach is it leaves your iPad in a pretty normal state, easy to unlock and use at any time. However, your photo frame is then limited to the customizations you can make to the lock screen, which is still pretty good for your use case and has gotten better recently. Another option would be to set up a slideshow in the Photos app or similar and then use Guided Access to keep the screen locked to that app or slideshow. The benefit of this approach is that you can display anything with tons of customization. However, there’s a bit of extra complexity in setting it up, unlocking the device to use it if you need to, and setting it up again afterward. My advice is to try the lock screen wallpaper approach first and then switch to Guided Access if you don’t like it. The last piece is making sure you have all the right photos from the whole family. For that, use an iCloud Shared Photo Library. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT213248 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT213248
- hebetude 3y agoFree way to share photos across all your devices. Super great feature when I tuned off iCloud Photos due to costs. I’ll miss it, this won’t push me to shell out for iCloud storage though.
- simsla 3y agoWhy don't they just migrate everything to iCloud for you? This is a very clunky deprecation path, and people *will* lose precious photos because of this. Badly managed.
- CharlesW 3y ago> This is a very clunky deprecation path, and people will* lose precious photos because of this.* Probably not, since the very small number of people who used it were warned many times, and My Photo Stream was always a temporary destination (photos went away after 30 days).
- drcongo 3y agoI'm a heavy iCloud Photos user and I always hated this feature. Glad to see the back of it.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoI don't even know what this is but where's the outrage about big tech shutting down random services like there is with every Google killing?
- ajdude 3y agoPerhaps it's because Apple is killing a service that apparently nobody uses while Google tends to kill services regardless if people are actively relying on it. Like you, I have also never heard of this service and I am all in on the Apple ecosystem. Meanwhile, I have recognized every service Google has shut down.