3 ms·
Most carriers should be able to put together an independently audited process to ensure your old data cannot be mined. Locked boxes, chain of custody, secure tr
by bluGill 3y ago
Most carriers should be able to put together an independently audited process to ensure your old data cannot be mined. Locked boxes, chain of custody, secure transfer, cameras and two people in the room... until the phone is physically destored.
Though it would be nice if they had a get the old data off that dead phone and return to you process. (Which reminds me, I need to setup backups on my latest phone
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Locked boxes, chain of custody, secure transfer, cameras and two people in the room It's difficult to see this being profitable. Or even possible, given the meagre training most carriers' employees at physical stores seem to have. Easier: a device that shreds the phone onsite, in front of the customer.
- pjc50 3y agoThere are various document destroying firms with shredder-on-a-truck that probably already offer that service, for businesses. Not economical for a single device though.
- throwanem 3y agoHard to see how it's very economical even for many devices, given you have to take each one far enough apart to remove the battery or else throwing it in the shredder sets your truck on fire. A better play might be to liaise with phone repair shops both carrier-owned and independent, since they already do this as a matter of course, and it's quicker if you don't care what damage you do in the process. Lot of cats to herd, though, that would be.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> you have to take each one far enough apart to remove the battery or else throwing it in the shredder sets your truck on fire Lithium-ion batteries can be safely shredded. You need to ensure they're discharged and/or shredded in an inert atmosphere [1]. [1] https://www.recovery-worldwide.com/en/artikel/efficient-and-safe-recycling-of-lithium-ion-batteries-and-accumulators-3566105.html https://www.recovery-worldwide.com/en/artikel/efficient-and-...
- throwanem 3y agoOh, well, I can't see any way that could go wrong!
- Nextgrid 3y ago> given the meagre training most carriers' employees at physical stores seem to have Training is one thing, but the primary issue is wages and career prospects. Nobody working in a customer-facing role at a mobile carrier is paid enough to give a shit to do proper data protection - in fact they might be paid more by a malicious actor (bribery) to intentionally compromise data protection, just like it happens with fraudulent SIM swaps.
- simias 3y ago>Easier: a device that shreds the phone onsite, in front of the customer. Given that most phone these days have non-removable batteries, can one really shred them safely? And wouldn't it make it harder to recycle if you can't isolate the various components? It's not too difficult to destructively open phones to remove the battery and destroy the motherboard, but that requires some tools and know-how.
- KineticLensman 3y ago> Easier: a device that shreds the phone onsite, in front of the customer. My local PC repair shop has a hard-disk destroyer that you can use to destruct your own drives. It's basically a lever-operated vice-crusher with a four-foot lever that you use to close the jaws. As soon as I discovered it I was able to destroy the hard drives that I'd been keeping in a bucket in my garage. The shop keeps the bits and manages the e-waste disposal. Bonus: it gives you an upper-body work-out
- martin8412 3y agoAren't a lot of carrier stores in reality franchises?
- chongli 3y agoHow about a portable shredder right in the store, with a nice big glass window on it? Bring your phones in and let your kid drop them in the shredder and watch the snap-crackle-pop, and get paid a nominal amount for each one!
- sofixa 3y agoThere are lots of parts that can and should be recycled (at the very least the battery), so that sounds like a waste.
- chongli 3y agoThey could have tools there to quickly pop out the battery so you can recycle it separately from the rest of the phone.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoSerious question, but how do they intentionally recycle phones/batteries/ ewaste? My first guess would that everything goes through a shredder. Precious metals and plastics are then separated because any kind of disassembly at scale would be infeasible.
- opwieurposiu 3y agoHigh value items are disassembled by robot, like in the case of iPhones. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MC81peMLEfo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MC81peMLEfo Medium value stuff is shredded into a big pile and then they leach the gold off it with cyanide. It has a much higher concentration of gold then raw gold ore. Low value stuff is shipped to poor countries where the copper is extracted by burning and picking through the ash. Very toxic process.
- codetrotter 3y agoNudes are already being stolen from customer phones during phone repairs. Don’t hand in your phone when there is any chance that data can be recovered. If your phone can boot, wipe it. If your phone cannot boot, remove the battery and then smash everything else into tiny little pieces with a hammer.
- bombcar 3y agoIt would be nice if “contains data” chips were mandated to be bright pink, then you could know what parts to destroy. Open phone, snap off the pink, recycle the rest.
- prepend 3y ago> Most carriers should be able to put together an independently audited process to ensure your old data cannot be mined. I don’t trust any carrier to do this honestly or competently. And I don’t have the time to audit their process. I also don’t care enough to do a secure wipe but would gladly take out the storage card and destroy it. That way I’m certain. It’s not that it’s not possible. It’s that I don’t think it’s worth the work for a negligible benefit.