Yes, he has, because there is a top-down command hierarchy in the army, and soldiers get punished if they refuse orders. They are basically just tools of the ge

Yes, he has, because there is a top-down command hierarchy in the army, and soldiers get punished if they refuse orders. They are basically just tools of the general. But in case where one has killed by his own volition (not being under direct order), the motivation is irrelevant.