4 ms·
The other cost: Typically the solution to high CO2 in indoor air is to exchange it with outdoor air. Most users will open a window. The energy cost of that
by londons_explore 3y ago
The other cost:
Typically the solution to high CO2 in indoor air is to exchange it with outdoor air.
Most users will open a window. The energy cost of that is relatively huge, when room air is heated or cooled.
In modern eco buildings, there might be counterflow heat exchangers - those can recover 80+% of the heat - but still, the energy loss through air exchange can quickly add up to be a major component of the buildings energy bill.
I believe we should work towards buildings that don't exhaust dirty air to the environment. Throwing away contaminated stuff and letting nature deal with it is 1900's thinking. We should instead break that CO2 back into oxygen, filter the dust, and remove VOC's. We should fix the air, not replace it.
So far, to my knowledge, nobody does this except on submarines.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoSubmarines don't turn CO2 back into O2. They "scrub" the CO2 out using Soda Lime (or similar). They use electrolysis or oxygen candles to generate new oxygen. https://www.analoxgroup.com/blog/how-do-you-breath-onboard-submarine https://www.analoxgroup.com/blog/how-do-you-breath-onboard-s... After the soda lime is maxed out, it's tossed. At least so far as I understand you can't meaningfully re-use it for scrubbing, though there are other industrial uses where it can be re-purposed. Also O2 electrolysis takes a fairly substantial amount of electricity, which is OK when you've got a nuclear generator on your hands. So.... it's a lot cheaper (and more environmentally friendly) to use an ERV system in your HVAC system even at "only" 80% recovery. Let the plants do what they are good at and deal with capturing CO2 and giving us O2. The problem is we don't generally build insulated enough or tight enough houses to matter. If everything was built to passive house standard, we'd save HUGE amounts of energy globally.
- rascul 3y ago> After the soda lime is maxed out, it's tossed. At least so far as I understand you can't meaningfully re-use it for scrubbing, though there are other industrial uses where it can be re-purposed. Does it get re-purposed? Is there an issue to "tossing" it out of the sub while submerged?
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoIf I remember my chemistry correctly Soda lime + CO2 results in Sodium Bicarbonate (baking soda) and Calcium Carbonate. I'm not a submariner, so I have no idea if they have re-purposes use for it onboard. I would assume it is stored, like all trash/waste, onboard until the sub is resupplied.
- 57FkMytWjyFu 3y agoThe soda lime solution is only used for shipboard casualties. The normal service system on a submarine uses a regenerative fluid to scrub the air of CO2. This fluid smells like cat piss.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoInteresting. I did more research and there isn't a ton out in the public domain, but it looks to be that the USN and others are using MonoEthanolAmine (MEA) as a regenerative CO2 scrubber. MEA >Weeks et al. (1960) reported that volunteers who smelled MEA vapor described the odor as ammoniacal, musty, or foreign; some volunteers were unable to characterize the odor. > Ethanolamine is a colorless, viscous liquid with an odor reminiscent of ammonia. Ammonia is a lot of what "cat piss" smells of, so that tracks. Thanks! That was really interesting to read about! * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethanolamine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethanolamine * https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/ADA389253 https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/ADA389253 * https://www.sonistics.com/wp-content/uploads/01-KEY-DEVELOPMENTS-4.pdf https://www.sonistics.com/wp-content/uploads/01-KEY-DEVELOPM... * https://nap.nationalacademies.org/read/11170/chapter/10#197 https://nap.nationalacademies.org/read/11170/chapter/10#197
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 3y agoAir filters seem pretty efficient; it's just a fan and a filter. If you exchange the air as well, you're sending clean air to the environment. (Though it has more CO2.) For oxygen, fast-growing indoor plants might help a little, but apparently you'd need a lot of them. [1] > Plants produce 22 L for every 150 g of growth (ref 2). They would need to increase in weight by 3.75 Kg (8 pounds), each day, to produce the oxygen used by one person. > Keep in mind that plants grow slowly. Adding 3.75 Kg to your houseplants every day would require a huge number of plants. Carbon capture: not as easy as it sounds. You'll need plenty of sunlight. Grow lamps? What would you do with eight pounds of plants per day? Hopefully some parts are edible, closing the cycle a little. I've heard that people growing cannabis will buy CO2, so if there were some other way to capture it then they'd probably take it. [1] https://www.gardenmyths.com/houseplants-increase-oxygen-levels/ https://www.gardenmyths.com/houseplants-increase-oxygen-leve...
- londons_explore 3y agoFractional distillation of air is fairly energy efficient (and can get rid of VOC's and give you heating/cooling 'for free'), and can very effectively capture CO2 into dry-ice. Sadly it's currently factory-sized technology, not something you can install in the basement.
- djmips 3y agoSubmarines and spacecraft.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sliken 3y agoThe main source of CO2 in a home are things that turn natural gas into heat, in particular gas stoves, and surprisingly common problems with gas water heaters and gas furnaces. Saw a study that mentioned during inspections that only 25% of homes got rid of the CO2 exhaust to the degree they should. I personally ended up with crazy high CO2 levels, turns out hail crushed the exhaust lid, blocking the airflow, and led to scary high levels that were so bad hand writing changed. Took awhile to track it down, then I started graphing the CO2 levels, figured out was going on, and fixed it the same day. Fortunately hand writing returned to normal. Most homes aren't going to have serious CO2 levels from just human breathing. Sure modern homes can be so well insulated you have problems, but said homes should be engineered for a specific airflow exchange rate and use heat exchangers as necessary.