13 ms·
> merely switching to a now-popular position If their job is to be representative of the people in their community and those people have a popular opinion, tha
by duxup 3y ago
> merely switching to a now-popular position
If their job is to be representative of the people in their community and those people have a popular opinion, that doesn’t seem to strike me as wrong necessarily.
- morkalork 3y agoProblem is when you cast your vote based on a position and they change their mind after because it's not popular with donors etc.
- duxup 3y agoIf it isn’t popular with voters I wouldn’t call that “popular opinion”.
- eesmith 3y ago"popular with donors" can be a far smaller set of people than voters.
- duxup 3y agoI don’t think about fits the context of what I was responding to originally.
- eesmith 3y agoI think zdragnar's position is that there can multiple reasons for someone to change their position; two being "genuinely changing their mind" (making them "thoughtful"), and "someone merely switching to a now-popular position" (making them "someone who lacks conviction and unreliable"). Your view seems to be the inner state doesn't matter - they still represent the will of the people they represent. morkalork's position seems to be that if someone lacks conviction and is unreliable then a problem may be they get elected then switch to represent the interests of a donor more than the electors.
- pjc50 3y ago"unpopular populism" is definitely a thing; policies presented as populist that are only supported by a minority. Usually because that minority is "swing" voters.
- __s 3y agoNot all popular opinion is created equally. Canada recently had the Conservative party vote out their leader O'Toole, & he had a poor reputation for unclear positions on policy: https://tnc.news/2021/09/21/erin-otooles-top-five-flip-flops-and-walk-backs https://tnc.news/2021/09/21/erin-otooles-top-five-flip-flops... When someone shifts their positions to whatever happens to be popular it comes off more like someone who's motivated by gaining power rather than trying to improve the lives of their constituents Not all popular opinion is created equally. People want leadership, & coming off like one's thoughts on policy is "what does polling say will make people like me?" isn't strong leadership
- zarathustreal 3y agoTwo things: 1. Representation is representation of interests, not of people - what is in your best interest may not be the same thing you think you want 2. Representation doesn't mean you need to hold the same opinions, representation is symbolic by definition. If it were as simple as "well they're not giving the people what they want, get them out of office!" we wouldn't need a politician as the middle man we could just simply vote on legislation directly