4 ms·
That Starlink estimate must be low, they currently have 1.5 million customers and a significant percentage of total bandwidth is over ocean and thus mostly wast
by Retric 3y ago
That Starlink estimate must be low, they currently have 1.5 million customers and a significant percentage of total bandwidth is over ocean and thus mostly wasted.
If you assume a pessimistic 100x over subscription and 50% waste over oceans and non serviced countries * 50mbps (upload + download) * 1.5 million customers that’s well over 1.5 TBPs current capacity for customers which then doubles when you include their base stations. And they that’s today when the current 3887 Satilites which mostly v1.0 and v1.5 which have dramatically less individual bandwidth than v2.0.
PS: Also your port estimate overstates total bandwidth as each point to point link requires a port on each side, and packets generally make multiple hops through the internet.
- zirgs 3y agoDoes it count as a waste if their main selling point is to deliver internet access to places that are hard or impossible to reach otherwise?
- ilyt 3y agoWell you're calculating bandwidth so yes
- zirgs 3y agoBut Starlink would have no reason to exist in the first place if it didn't offer service in those remote places.
- Retric 3y agoMost Starlink customers are in areas “easy” to serve by high speed internet like the eastern US. It’s really only economical because of poor internet access across most of the US compared to similar density areas in other developed counties.
- welterde 3y agoYou are underestimating the capacity of modern core routers. A single PTX10016 router could route the entire starlink customer base with no over-subscription at all (230 Tbit/s vs 75 Tbit/s from 50 Mbit/s * 1.5M). Actual estimates of the total capacity of Starlink puts it more in the 20Tbit/s range (and that's without taking into account coverage over less populated areas).
- Retric 3y agoFirst my 3 Tbit/s estimate was wildly pessimistic and only covered current network utilization. Adding missing countries plus ships more than doubles land area, 42,000 satellites is more than 10x current satellites, v2 is ~10x current individual satellite bandwidth. So current goals are at least 200x current bandwidth. (Satellites also so point to point links which we are ignoring in terms of what the total routing capacity of the network has.) Total estimate for a “fully deployed” Starlink network is therefore 600 Tbit/s from my pessimistic estimate (or half that if your thinking in terms of customer bandwidth vs traffic handled by the network) A more realistic estimate is more like 3,000 TBPs as lower density areas can offer higher bandwidth per customer a village of 100 in the Sahara gets the same bandwidth as a town of 100,000 in the US. How much of that actually gets used is a different story. PS: Individual switches can handle a surprisingly large percentage of total internet bandwidth as packets travel through many of them. 100 switches / average of 4 hops per packet has 25x the bandwidth of a single switch.
- welterde 3y agoI was only talking about the currently deployed constellation, which of course is much smaller, but for which we have actual numbers from measurements. For the completed Phase 3 constellation I have read numbers in the range from 1.7 - 2.3 Pbit/s as theoretical maximum. So would need around 8-12 PTX boxes to reach the same total routing capacity as the whole future constellation. The current single-fiber bandwidth record is 1.53 Pbit/s. And nevermind that Starlink will run out of ground station / inter-satellite link capacity long before reaching the theoretical maximum.
- 3y ago
- foobiekr 3y agoCurrent generation 12 slot chassis with 51.2Tbps per slot is 612Tbps per chassis, and so a pair is 1228Tbps which is roughly your estimate. Companies like Juniper and Cisco sell tens of thousands of the previous generation per year _today_. Starlink is not even a drop in the bucket in terms of forwarding. Moreover, with a very tiny exception over antarctica or open ocean, every single packet forwarded by starlink is hitting a terrestrial link after a single ground-space-ground hop. Nobody is going to be making backbones out of Starlink or anything that looks like Starlink. Only the people who know nothing about modern networking performance think otherwise.
- Retric 3y agoIf you followed the thread, my estimate was ~3,000 TBps, welterde gave “1.7 - 2.3 Pbit/s” = 1700 to 2300 TBps. 1228 TBps is well below both of our estimates. Last I checked global IP traffic it’s still well under 2,000 TBps looking at the rate traffic is increasing Starlink really can act as a major internet backbone. Also, Starlink customer to Starlink customer is very compelling for may applications. Undersea cables for example can create much higher latency between areas than their physical separation for example Australia to Madagascar. Similarly there’s still quite a bit of point to point microwave tower connections etc that can now be cheaply replaced.
- welterde 3y agoYou are not comparing the same thing here though. If you applied the same theoretical maximum method to all networking hardware (or even just core router class hardware) sold today you would arrive at numbers very very much in excess of a couple Pbit/s. For it to be really viable as a backbone it would need to be able to do several 100 Gbit/s from one location and that Starlink cannot do (or is built to do). A single satellite has less than 100Gbit/s of RF capacity and you will only have a couple visible above you at any one time. And after that bottleneck comes the inter-satellite link capacity bottleneck which is less than half of that if the information I have found is correct (4 links à 10Gbit/s). I don't think they will be able to sell more than 10 GBit/s service to anyone and that only in not so populated areas. A single datacenter can reach low Tbit/s of connectivity _alone_ _today_. I don't see how it could make any dent whatsoever in the backbone market. The other usecases are a different discussion and not as dependent on very high bandwidth numbers.