3 ms·
Ernst Jünger’s narratives of complicity
- empiricus 3y agoOne of my favorite authors, and I have read many things. Do you think you could do better in the midst of history?
- mbustamanter 3y agoHe was born in the German Empire, fought in both world wars, lived through Weimar, rise of the Soviet Union, rise of the Third Reich, saw his country split in two, saw the Berlin wall fall and the collapse of the USSR. That's a very high bar for me to reach, and I don't know what the modern equivalent would be.
- bloak 3y agoI've not yet read anything by Ernst Jünger. Which would you recommend?
- Amezarak 3y agoThe Storm of Steel is his most popular book and his WWI memoir, but I think his best fiction work is The Marble Cliffs. It’s one of the few books I immediately reread. In general I recommend totally discounting articles like this until you’ve read enough to have your own feel. Secondary sources are only to pique interest. They are almost always wrong.
- PradeetPatel 3y agoI'd strongly recommend his war memoir "Storm of Steel", essentially the war viewed through the eyes of an Imperial German officer. It provides a stark contrast to "All Quiet on the Western Front" - a more well-known novel on WW1 from a German perspective.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Amezarak 3y agoI always think it’s worth mentioning that All Quiet on the Western Front is a work of fiction, written by a guy who was on the front for about a month, at which time he was wounded and unable to return until a few weeks before the end of the war. Junger is writing a memoir based on the four years he was in the war, much of it at the front. I suspect Remarque gets more attention not because of greater literary merit, but because his sensibilities are easier for us to understand and better accord with that of our teachers. Junger is a much more alien read, and for that reason much more worthwhile.
- kurthr 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230626103526/https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/07/03/on-the-marble-cliffs-ernst-junger-book-review https://web.archive.org/web/20230626103526/https://www.newyo...
- leroy_masochist 3y ago> ...passages like this set the tone: “In these men there lived an element that underscored the savagery of war while also spiritualizing it: the matter-of-fact joy in danger, the chivalrous urge to fight. Over the course of four years the fire forged an ever purer, ever bolder warriorhood.” Such dire blather proliferated through the German right after the defeat of 1918. The article's author might regard this as "dire blather", and it is indeed true that such sentiments were amplified throughout the interwar German right, but it's still a pretty good description of what regular exposure to shared hardship and danger will do to men grouped together in infantry units.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoWhy go to war when instead, you can go to WINE BAR with "gf" and enjoy tasteful banter? On a more serious note, this sentiment: "Virtue and sacrifice are anachronisms, wars mere catastrophic conflicts to be prevented by skilful management" seems very relevant to the disconnect between Jünger and a contemporary NY journalist. I'll copy the eugyppius thread [0] on a text by Rolf Peter Sieferle, it is succinct and beautiful. From Sieferle, Finis Germania p. 40f.: "Politics belongs to an older stratum of existence, ordered in terms of state & history, crystallised in statesmen, leaders & ideologues. It has programmes, values & goals. It demands virtues & commitment directed to a superordinate whole... The ultimate purpose of politics is war: the willingness of the individual to sacrifice himself for a higher cause, for his society. 'System' characterises newly emerging orders of higher complexity, which have gradually displaced politics. Systems organize themselves without focus, without values, goals & programmes. Their only maxim is freedom and emancipation for the individuals. Virtue and sacrifice are anachronisms, wars mere catastrophic conflicts to be prevented by skilful management. 'System' creates order via self-generated constraints of objectivity, but not by normative orientation. The structures of systems are as inescapable for individuals as a magnetic field is for iron filings. They do not 'know' anything about it, but they align themselves with the preset paths. The most important processes are not controlled and beyond theoretic grasp. In advanced 'western' countries, it is 'System' that has prevailed. The rest of the world, in contrast, still thinks for the most part in terms of politics, and this appears to Western eyes as anachronistic fundamentalism." [0] https://twitter.com/eugyppius1/status/1673780970481422336 https://twitter.com/eugyppius1/status/1673780970481422336
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> "élitist libertarians" Why the e acute? "élitist" (used twice in TFA) is not a word in french. The word "élitiste", with an 'e' at the end, exists though. The english word is "elitist" if you ask me.
- throwanem 3y agoOne of many frank embarrassments to be found in the New Yorker's house style, which is a mishmash of usages obsolete for varying spans of decades and others like this which were never current at all, apparently assembled in the misguided belief that such behavior connotes arch playfulness rather than leaden pretense.
- rightbyte 3y agoIt is a thing in academic writing. E.g the randomly chosen article "The Populist Challenge to Élitist Democracy in Europe" in Oxford Academic. At least he does not mix in French and German.
- armitron 3y agoNot sure why anyone would bother with newyorker these days. Just go read Jünger and ignore the forgettable tripe presented in this article.
- slibhb 3y agoI quite like Junger. The Glass Bees is a really interesting parable about technology. It predicts parts of the modern tech industry quite accurately. Most of the potshots in the article are cheap. I like this quote from Jean Cocteau about Junger and World War II: "Some people had dirty hands, some had clean hands, but Junger had no hands".
- voldacar 3y agoThis just reads like a hit piece written by an intellectually uncurious and fragile person. It's not even an interesting hit piece.