6 ms·
> "Elections are largely monopolized by older people who mostly tend to be homeowners". > Sounds like democracy? Young people might get their first chance to
by lmm 3y ago
> "Elections are largely monopolized by older people who mostly tend to be homeowners".
> Sounds like democracy?
Young people might get their first chance to vote at age 23 - assuming they paid for the right kind of ID, or navigated an impenetrable web of underpaid bureaucrats to get the mythical free ID. And if they manage to get off work on election day. Meanwhile the elderly are reliably on the register (because they're not being forced to move around, because again they own a home) and encouraged to vote even if they're expected to die before the results take effect.
- _dain_ 3y ago>Young people might get their first chance to vote at age 23 - assuming they paid for the right kind of ID, or navigated an impenetrable web of underpaid bureaucrats to get the mythical free ID. uhh what? we're talking about britain here. I don't know what kind of yank(?) political dysfunction you're alluding to, but nobody has any trouble voting because of a lack of ID here. you don't need one to vote. you notify the electoral roll when you move into a house or flat, then a few weeks before election day you get a bit of paper in the post, you can bring it to the polling station to prove you live there.
- switch007 3y agoYou’re a little out of date with your info https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/about-14000-people-england-denied-vote-due-id-rule-electoral-commission-2023-06-22/ https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/about-14000-people-england-...
- peterfirefly 3y agoThe article says that 70% of them hadn't bothered to bring their ID. Hardly the result of draconian laws, is it? It also doesn't say how many of the 30% actually had the right to vote. It only says that they "brought a type that was not accepted".
- edent 3y agoThat is not correct. During the recent elections in England about 14,000 people were denied a vote due to lack of ID. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-65988959 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-65988959
- WalterBright 3y agoGreat Britain has 67 million people. 14,000 people is unlikely to swing any election, even if they all voted in lockstep.
- switch007 3y ago67m is the UK population, not the GB population. And 67m is nothing close to the size of the electorate of the local elections that number comes from. And as another commenter wrote, a small number of votes can matter a great deal.
- mhh__ 3y ago14,000 in the right places could easily topple a government in a tight election because of FPTP - although one can obviously not choose in reality. In 2017 for example the minimum number of votes across the country needed to take down Theresa May (or more realistically have her form a true minority government) was something like 2500. We have an extremely disproportional electoral system.
- peterfirefly 3y agoThat would have been 2500 in exactly the right places. 2500 in exactly the right places could also have given the Conservative Party even more seats. If we are talking about 0.25% on average then I doubt it could have changed much in these local elections (back in May in England and Northern Ireland). If anybody wants to play with the data from the General Election in 2017 they can do so here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Results_of_the_2017_United_Kingdom_general_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Results_of_the_2017_United_Kin... Sort the table by "Mjrty." in ascending order. Right at the top we see wins for SNP, Labour, SNP, Labour, and Labour that easily could have been wins for Lib Dem, Tories, Tories, Tories, and Tories.
- matthewmacleod 3y agoThe government has introduced a requirement for photographic ID for all UK parliament elections, as well as local elections in England. This has been quite heavily discussed, so I'm surprised you haven't heard about it.
- acheron 3y ago> yank(?) To be clear, it’s not a real problem in the US either, but some people like to pretend it is. Don’t believe things you read on Reddit or wherever.
- _dain_ 3y agooh I already know it's not, you don't even have to be alive to vote let alone show ID
- dahwolf 3y agoI was referring to the idea that in an aging country, even if young/old people would equally show up to vote, the older people will have more votes. Which is democracy. It is fair in that sense, although surely it will not feel that way at all times.
- jezzamon 3y agoYou could imagine a system where similar to how we split votes into geographical regions via things like electoral colleges or having a locally elected representatives, there could be a similar splitting of votes into age ranges to ensure each group is sufficiently represented (Not advocating for this, just an interesting thing to think about)
- dahwolf 3y agoIndeed, democracy is two wolves and a sheep deciding what's for lunch. It's just an unusual and new idea to see young people as a minority as this never was the case to this extend. As it comes to housing though, I remain convinced that the issue is not as political as many make it out to be. See my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36486626 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36486626 Meaning, even if the young seize more political power, there isn't going to be a law they can pass that says "cut rent in half".
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoThere is also no law they can pass to reverse climatw change. Once some things are fucked, they are really hard to fix
- RestlessMind 3y agoCalifornia is one of the worst affected states for housing, and yet > they paid for the right kind of ID, or navigated an impenetrable web of underpaid bureaucrats Pretty much everyone starts driving around 16-18 and has a driver's license > manage to get off work on election day CA is an early voting state where ballots are mailed to you ~1 month in advance. You can drop them off at your convenience at one of the numerous drop-off locations. Really, CA makes it as easy to vote as possible including same-day registration. There is no excuse for young people to not vote, except for their apathy.
- ozr 3y agoThis is a wholly imaginary problem.
- WalterBright 3y agoOh come on. If there was the mass of people who couldn't get registered to vote, the Democrats would pull out all the stops to get them registered.
- lmm 3y agoYou mean the SDP? They haven't been an independent party since 1983, and have been politically irrelevant for even longer.
- alistairSH 3y agoDoes the UK not have any equivalent of the US “motor voter” system? When we update our info at the department of motor vehicles, there’s a checkbox on the form to automatically register to vote. So getting on the register is mostly automatic once you have the paperwork in order to get a driver’s license (which is a necessity to function as an adult in most of the US).
- tmnvix 3y agoI would guess that few countries have the type of situation that exists in the US where a driver's licence is almost essential in order to go about daily life. Many people in the UK don't bother with a licence. It can be prohibitively expensive when you consider the costs of lessons, a vehicle, and of the licence itself.
- throwaway2037 3y agoMany people in the UK don't bother with a licence. Eh. "Many" is such a vague term. Like, 5% could be considered many. UK is a driving country, period. where a driver's licence is almost essential in order to go about daily life. This is true in all highly developed countries if you live outside the largest cities. You need to drive. It is baked in the cost of your life. Renting is much cheaper outside of the city, but somewhat offset by the cost of driving.
- techer 3y ago“in the 5 years from 2015 to 2019, an average of 74% of people in England had a full driving licence“
- resonance1994 3y agoThe provisional licence is enough as a voter ID though. I just used it in the last election.
- nirimda 3y agoI note your statistic refers to "people" and not "adults". Usually, some proportion of the people of any given country are ineligible to receive a drivers licence on the basis of their age. It seems that age is 17 in the UK, although I'm not sure whether that counts as full or provisional until they've got a bit more experience. I'll assume full. According to https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/ukpopulationpyramidinteractive/2020-01-08 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populati... there's about 1.2% of the people in each age group <17 in England, which means 1.2*17 ~= 20 of the people in the England are ineligible for a drivers licence. So there's only about 6% of people in the England who could have a full drivers licence, but don't. So either they give licences out in the cornflakes at Tescos, or almost the whole adult population of the UK wants a drivers licence.