4 ms·
> Let's use TV as an example. So yep, if you spend your time on one of those cable channels where you watch rich people all the time, pretty soon it's not that
by gwern 15y ago
> Let's use TV as an example. So yep, if you spend your time on one of those cable channels where you watch rich people all the time, pretty soon it's not that you'll understand how rich people live, it's that pretty soon you'll start believing that it is better to live like they do.
In Brazil and India, rich people on soap operas don't have many kids; sure enough, when you correlate the opening of TV stations with birth rates... http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/10/fertility-fall-still-puzzling.html#comment-435086 http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/10/fertility-fall-still-p...
- dripton 15y agoIt's also possible that there's a co-factor: TV appeared about the same time as reliable birth control.
- gwern 15y agoReliable birth control penetrated each district or governmental sub-unit at the same time as the TV stations?
- dripton 15y agoPossibly. (Not necessarily at exactly the same time.) I read the study, and they did attempt to isolate this effect from others, but correlation is still not proof of causality.
- patja 15y agoI read some speculation that these declining birth rates with the availability of television was due to having a new alternatives to sex after the sun went down. Without TV and electricity (lighting for reading and other activities) there are not as many activities available to compete with baby-making.
- zalew 15y agoA very plausible reason. In Poland, martial law led to baby boom.