6 ms·
As much as this type of corruption sucks... I gotta say recreation.gov is way better than what came before it, with every state and federal system doing their o
by solardev 3y ago
As much as this type of corruption sucks... I gotta say recreation.gov is way better than what came before it, with every state and federal system doing their own random thing with terrible UX and horrible performance, and many campsites having no online presence at all.
Many places now on recreation.gov used to require you to fax in reservations and wait days for a confirmation, or else just do the drive up and fill out a paper slip thing the morning of (too bad if they're all gone).
Sure, it'd be nice to clean up the fees and get more money to the parks themselves, but I gotta give credit to the website for cleaning up what used to be a nightmare and turning it into a pretty streamlined (if slightly more expensive) process.
Edit: Imagine if we had a similar system for the departments of motor vehicles... pay 20% more but get it all done in minutes online instead of hours at the local office. Who wouldn't pay for that if they could afford it?
Of course it would be better to have actually functional public services, but our governments just don't seem to be set up to actually be effective at basic services. Is it worse for public dollars to get funneled to a public private partnership with an overhead, that at least delivers a functional product, or to just disappear forever into the coffers of bureaucrats and their cronies with nothing to show for it?
- tonymet 3y agoat what cost? and what is the governance model? The suit is more about the lack of governance with the free structure and not abiding by the law about establishing fees . Here's one example from the article Last year there were 22,435 lottery applicants for a permit to run the Middle Fork of the Salmon River in Idaho. Only 330 individuals received a permit. Yet, all applicants paid the $6 lottery fee -- even unsuccessful lottery applicants. Under Booz Allen’s arrangement with the federal government, it could pocket all lottery fees, which amounted to $134,610 just for the Middle Fork lottery
- taftster 3y agoThat's interesting and extremely agitating. I had always thought the majority of the lottery fees were going back to the park for use and maintenance of the resource. I get it, there is an underlying profit motive that needs to be satisfied by the hosting company (Booz). And recreation.gov is sure tons better than anything that came before (especially for rafting trip lotteries). But yeah, there's a lot of money there that really should mostly being going back to the management entity.
- Ductapemaster 3y agoI would like to understand why this is a problem? Objectively, they ran the lottery, distributed the permits, and charged a fee to do so. What is your objection specifically? I don't intend to passively inject an opinion — just trying to understand your position.
- natpalmer1776 3y agoThe item of value being offered by the lottery is taxpayer funded, whereas most lotteries fund prizes via the proceeds of the lottery tickets. In this way, it can be considered exploitative since the proceeds don’t go back into “the pot” to any degree.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe value being provided here is the website, which received no taxpayer funding other than the lottery proceeds.
- natpalmer1776 3y agoAh, I stand corrected, looking at Booz’s website I see that the agreement from the start was no upfront cost to taxpayers.
- singleshot_ 3y agoTherein lies the rub: the people we selected to represent us turned us into a cash flow which they then sold to a government contractor. Instead of buying us a website, they sold us.
- StillBored 3y agoBut an endless cost on the backend... Sounds like a great deal. At least for one political party who's entire theory of government is starving the beast. Labeling a fee based rental agreement as not being a tax is more important than what the actual final use cost actually is. Even if the users actually paying the fee end up spending orders of magnitude more in the long run. Its a fantastic way to hide immense sums of corruption, it just needs to be done one dollar at a time.
- solardev 3y agoFor clarity, I'm totally for this suit, and hope that the public can claw back those dollars. But in the grand scheme of things, that seems like such a minor technicality. $6 to $15 here or there, a couple times a year on vacation, is way better than the alternative systems that were common before recreation.gov, with faxed lotteries, long delays, and high uncertainty. It used to be common that you'd just have to drive to the place, wait an hour or two in line, pay the admission fee (if you don't have a annual pass), then sign up for some lottery on the spot at like 7am and wait a few hours to hear back. If you don't get it, well, there goes your plans... but you're already there. By contrast, a small fee here and there for the ahead-of-time guarantee of a reservation is totally worth it. $130,000 to run a lottery system effectively? That's not a whole lot. Even if it costs a few million, nationally, to run them... that's nothing. I can pretty much guarantee you the NPS, USFS, and BLM together wouldn't be able to run a smooth national reservation & lottery system with the same budget and fees. The agencies themselves are so far removed -- in both mission and skill set -- from modern app UX that they probably wouldn't be able to get the job done even with 10x the budget. I don't doubt that the contractor (Booz Allen Hamilton) is a scumbag for pocketing those fees, which are unnecessary to begin with (it's not like it costs $15 in CPU or human processing time to do a change). It'd be great if the public gets those back. All I'm saying is that recreation.gov is totally and absolutely worth it despite these fees, despite the increased costs to the public, because it actually works, vs the chaos that came before it. That website makes public lands FAR more discoverable, accessible, and reliable -- at the cost of minor corruption. I think that is an ultimately acceptable tradeoff, even if it's not ideal. (And it's not like I'm some libertarian; I love our parks and public lands, but digital anything just really isn't their strong suit. I'm grateful they outsourced it.) Maybe what we need, in lieu of effective federal digital agencies, is some sort of public-FOSS partnership that can take the place of public-private partnerships. But that's much harder for the agencies to deal with than a central commercial entity with designated contacts, support, etc. And the FOSS model isn't really set up to communicate in the real world with the super complicated division of public lands across federal/state/local/agency divides, each with their own little fiefdoms and idiosyncrasies and rules and regulations. I wonder how other countries manage similar use cases (digital presence for public lands)? Recently went hiking in Taiwan and reserved a trail permit; the UX was terrible even by 90s standards -- at least it was online -- but at least it worked. Not sure how they funded it, but I don't remember there being any fees.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y ago> Yet, all applicants paid the $6 lottery fee -- even unsuccessful lottery applicants. You actually need the lottery fees not to be refunded, otherwise people will spam the system, knowing they will get their lottery fee returned to them if they are not successful.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Imagine if we had a similar system for the departments of motor vehicles... pay 20% more but get it all done in minutes online instead of hours at the local office. The counties here have provided that for at least 30 years and without any 3rd party or paid priority for the non-poor.
- jonhohle 3y agoI doubt there was online self-service for the DMV in 1993 anywhere in the world.
- connicpu 3y agoNot the internet as we know it today, but I wouldn't be surprised if some isolated departments experimented with dial-in services back then. If you could make a phone call and you had a modem, you could connect to a remote terminal.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoMy fault. I missed the online qualification and rushed right to part where our tax dollars buy great service and low wait times (and Sat hours). We've only had an online option for about 10 years.
- jonhohle 3y ago> Imagine if we had a similar system for the departments of motor vehicles... So petition your state reps to do it. AZ provides tools for self-service for most common tasks. With the exception of buying a car out of state and wanting to move a vanity plate over a few years ago, I can’t remember the last time I went to the DMV. It helps that our licenses don’t expire until we’re 65, so until my kids need to get their license, I don’t see a need to go back. My vanity plate - FREEBSD -required an appeal to get to begin with because their system flagged it as a drug reference (free based). I had to _mail_(!) an appeal letter. When I went to transfer it, it was reflagged and they couldn’t even help me at the DMV, and instead of going through the appeal process again I just dropped it.
- solardev 3y agoI don't think I've ever successfully petitioned anything from any government, local or state, much less federal. I've tried. Our governments don't seem to be set up to respond to your average constituents at all, just rich businesspeople and politicos. These days it's all about culture wars and inflation, and no representative cares about day to day services and infrastructure.
- akiselev 3y ago> Imagine if we had a similar system for the departments of motor vehicles... pay 20% more but get it all done in minutes online instead of hours at the local office. You don't have that? The only time I've ever had to visit a DMV office in the decade and a half was upon first moving to the state since they need to take a photo for the new ID and inspect the VIN number on the new registration. There was some sort of ticketing system so even when I got there without an appointment, I didn't have to stand in line long The online stuff is usually cheaper since its all renewals.
- solardev 3y agoIt just depends on your state and what particular service you need. I've moved around a lot and lived in a few states, and some of them were particularly bad. But yes, simple in-state renewals tend to be the easiest, and can often be done online. But things like custom license plates (for an already registered vehicle) or cross-state transfers (when you've been driving for 20+ years) or changing your address or donor status or whatever... can be more difficult than necessary.
- q845712 3y agoas someone else is already saying -- Arizona basically already has this for DMVs. There's a parallel system of privately owned and operated offices where you can make an appointment to e.g. get your drivers license. You show up right around your appointment time, there's somebody ready to help you within minutes, and everything is streamlined / easy. Most pleasant experience I've ever had of getting a license in a new state. In that case it was never clear to me whether I paid extra for the private service or not, but whatever I paid seemed unremarkable.
- solardev 3y agoI wish we had a trickle-up, trickle-down system where states could experiment with different strategies/providers for tackling some public use case, and the successful ones could push that up to Congress to then disseminate back down to other states. But alas, either that never happens because nobody cares (most digital services) or it becomes a political battleground (California vs Texas in education). Sometimes I hate our system of powerful states vs centralized nations...
- Karrot_Kream 3y ago> But alas, either that never happens because nobody cares (most digital services) or it becomes a political battleground (California vs Texas in education). Sometimes I hate our system of powerful states vs centralized nations... You hit the nail on the head. We have a trickle down system, where states implement services differently. The reason states don't learn from each other is because of the huge culture war. Texas would rather freeze the state than learn from California, and California would rather pay 20x for public infrastructure than accept a contractor based out of Nevada due to the state's political leanings. It infects every piece of cross-state collaboration and is also why Federal budgetary politics are so acrimonious these days.
- havnagiggle 3y agoThe emissions testing place near me charges over $10 fee for credit cards for renewing your tags, and cash is not accepted! It's outrageous, and the line is out the door to get renewals everyday. The number of government endorsed middleman scams is ridiculous.
- sh1mmer 3y agoIt’s seems like a pretty cynical take to say that simply having a modern, standard platform for national parks (or whatever gov service) necessitates that platform must be cost inefficient. I don’t see how improving the status quo and asking/enforcing federal contractors charge reasonable prices should be mutually exclusive. Even if the contractual approach remained the same (Eg charge lottery fees and use that to pay Booz) presumably the point of this suit is to ensure that Booz are charging only charging a reasonable overhead for their services. If it turns out their overhead is unreasonable one could either scale the fees down, or scale down Booz’s cut and give the rest to the specific parks for their own use.
- solardev 3y agoI agree with you. I hope the suit results in either the elimination of the fees, or that a large portion (90%+) goes to the parks instead of the contractor.
- asdff 3y agoCost efficiency is like jumbo shrimp when it comes to government and you as the customer. OK, this website is now "profitable" charging x for y. Well, its not like Y was produced out of thin air beforehand. The taxpayer always pays. Its in the name. A system like this merely moves where the point of sale happens from one point in the stream to another. It's not any more profitable than what came before really, especially considering all this "profit" effectively is shot into the sun out of the system as it enters booze allens checkbooks instead of having it go back into the public purse.
- sh1mmer 3y agoSurely it’s a question of which tax payers. Is it the tax payers using national parks (and entering lotteries or making reservations) or all tax payers? Charging for service also allows non-tax payers to contribute too. I’m not saying I’m for either approach but I still the cost efficiency is orthogonal to how it’s funded. If it were more transparent how much Booz were making, and how much web traffic, reservations, lottery entries, etc they were dealing with then the reasonable profit overhead for their work could be more easily be understood by the public.
- londons_explore 3y agoA centralised system should be cheaper. Instead of 50 states all having separate DMV offices, all too small for a decent website, now it is just one office double the size with a small web dev team. That should be substantially better and cheaper. Same for the forest service.
- londons_explore 3y agoThe downside of a central system is that sites can't set really custom rules. Things like "we don't allow anyone not associated with the XYZ festival to book a spot in the 3 days leading up to the XYZ festival" are really hard to handle with a big centralized booking system - whereas they are easy to handle with a little local office that does everything by hand.
- solardev 3y agoYeah, a complex rules engine is indeed one of the challenges of such a system. But you can at least handle the most common scenarios and take some of the load off the park. Like in Yosemite, a basic Half Dome permit is handled through recreation.gov, but if you're doing overnight backpacking or big wall climbing in addition to Half Dome, those could be handled differently and outside of recreation.gov... https://www.nps.gov/yose/planyourvisit/hdpermits.htm https://www.nps.gov/yose/planyourvisit/hdpermits.htm For a festival, though, I imagine it could be handled similarly to hotel rooms... block off a certain # of sites for the exclusive use of some "XYZFEST23" coupon code or similar. Not sure if recreation.gov actually supports that, but it's not an insurmountable problem.
- akira2501 3y ago> Of course it would be better to have actually functional public services, but our governments just don't seem to be set up to actually be effective at basic services. It's amazing to me that people will just blow by this point while accepting corporate monopolization of what should be a public resource. > or to just disappear forever into the coffers of bureaucrats and their cronies with nothing to show for it? It's better that the people who do this are punished. Either with criminal charges or with the removal of their ability to bid for future government contracts. The government is a sucker client. They pay huge contracts, always on time, and never follow up after they get screwed. And no, it's not better to just punt on this issue and throw even more money at a greedy rent seeking middleman.
- idopmstuff 3y agoWhat's the solution, though? You're criticizing "accepting corporate monopolization of what should be a public resource," which is fair, but you're also ignoring the actual problem that we have a public resource that can only handle an amount of utilization that is less than demand. We need a system to allocate demand. The post you're responding to isn't saying these things are good, but it's taking the practical perspective that the current system is better than what existed before and probably better than what the government would produce itself. It's easy to say that we shouldn't accept involving corporations in this way, and it's easy to say bureaucratic waste/theft should be punished. I think most people here would agree with you in a theoretical perspective. The problem is that we have to deal with the constraints of the real world, which the parent post addresses and you ignore. I'd invite you not to ignore them and just criticize, and instead to propose a solution - what do you think is the right way to allocate usage of national parks and related service that does not involve private corporations and also avoids bureaucratic waste?
- solardev 3y ago> It's amazing to me that people will just blow by this point while accepting corporate monopolization of what should be a public resource. I think it's more a matter of picking your battles. What are the things that our government does poorly, which should be handled better? Let's see... education, healthcare, science and arts funding, housing, wars, surveillance, immigration, highways and bridges, Amtrak... It's hard enough to improve (for example) local transit, petitioning a dozen people across 1-3 agencies for a few tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of improvements. But to try to get Congress to implement a system affecting thousands of sites across all 50 states, across the NPS, USFS, USFWS, BLM, Bureau of Reclamation, Army Corps of Engineers, etc... where do you even start with such a thing? Of all the letter, protests, petitions, voicemails, public meetings, etc. I've experienced, I've never once received a meaningful reply (much less actual positive change) from any politician higher than city-level. Our governments are just not set up to be responsive to regular citizens. You have to have a shit ton of money or power to matter at all. When even organized nonprofits with established lobbies struggle with this -- a lot -- what is the average citizen supposed to do? Our lack of meaningful representation is a major systemic flaw of our so-called democracy, not something some rando on HN can single-handedly solve (unless, maybe, you're one of the major tech CEOs on here... hey Vercel or Cloudflare, wanna help us make a better reservation system and forever earn public gratitude? lol) > It's better that the people who do this are punished. Either with criminal charges or with the removal of their ability to bid for future government contracts. Is it that black and white? Recreation.gov isn't the failure that (say) Healthcare.gov or WhiteHouse.com (the petition site) was. In fact it works very well. And from the news article, apparently the lottery fees were supposed to pay for most of the website in lieu of an upfront fee (though there's some question about a questionable $120 million fee). In terms of government digital efforts, honestly, this is probably the best one I've ever seen. Can't remember the last time it broke or crashed, and I've made dozens of reservations through it smoothly. And the cost to me... maybe $20/year? > The government is a sucker client. They pay huge contracts, always on time, and never follow up after they get screwed. Agreed. Part of our election cycles and extreme partisanship politics =/ Day to day services get deprioritized vs hot-button issues. > And no, it's not better to just punt on this issue and throw even more money at a greedy rent seeking middleman. I think a reasonable fix would to be just renegotiate the fees and give a larger portion to the parks, while still trickling some % to the contractor. Maybe open it up to a bidding process. But frankly I think this contractor is doing a much better job than the government itself could. The feds are terrible at making functional websites. Obama started some efforts and Biden is continuing them (Login.gov, the TSA systems) but they're still not very seamless. It's just not a part of their culture. Maybe that will change in time, but until then, I'd rather have an expensive but functional service than some ideologically purer but unusable system.
- jtbayly 3y ago> campsites having no online presence at all. I don't think this was an improvement. It has led to fewer people being able to use the campsites, as they are easily and cheaply reserved. Thus, people who have plenty of money to spare reserve them on the off-chance of wanting to use it that day. But when that day comes, they don't show up.
- LoFiSamurai 3y agoYep. Personally seen people book two weeks for the off chance they might go for one of those days.
- berkle4455 3y agoUnless they're doing individual daily reservations, it doesn't work like that. You forfeit the entire reservation if you don't arrive on the start date, but you can always depart early.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoYou can edit your reservation, which means you can book two weeks, then change it so you only use the last three days of July 3,4,5 (for example). This means that by the time reservations open for July 3, all the spots are taken.
- ethanbond 3y agoSounds like the solution to that is just a large deposit that’s refundable upon arrival?
- varenc 3y agoDoesn’t that still just favor people with more money? If you’re tight on money you won’t be able to afford the deposit. And if you’re really rich you still don’t care about the deposit. Also in many places the camping fee itself is already steep.
- 1024core 3y ago> pay 20% more but get it all done in minutes online instead of hours at the local office. Who wouldn't pay for that if they could afford it? Prompt access to government services should not require extra payment. Because then you're providing them an incentive to further kneecap the system. Hypothetically, imagine if this figure (20%) was now 2000%. Would that be fair? I'm sure some people would be able to pay that sum for processing in minutes, while the rest of us have to wait several hours.
- colechristensen 3y ago> pay 20% more but get it all done in minutes online instead of hours at the local office A AAA membership in California does this for you for some things. Zero wait to register a purchased vehicle in silicon valley, possibly Mountain View I don't remember it's been a couple of years. On the other hand I look like an axe murderer on my CA drivers license as the convoluted process took three hours and required starting over twice due to mistakes by the clerks.
- asdff 3y agoI always here people having such trouble at CA DMVs and I wonder how that ends up happening. I don't have any problem and I go to pretty busy big city DMVs too. I think its because I book an appointment ahead of time online, because whenever I show up they usher me right in to the clerk past the line of pissed off people outside. One time when this happened the person first in line nearly fought the DMV worker for letting me in, people behind him had to try and calm him down and I got inside as soon as I could.
- solardev 3y agoThere is a lot of variance between different DMV offices in California, between different services, and between the individual staff members who are helping you. I've had no-appointment things get done in 5 minutes as a walkup, and also 3-hour waits despite having an appointment. Total crapshoot =/
- solardev 3y agoI used to think California's was bad, then I tried to move my license to Chicago... that took 8+ hours (literally... got there before opening and stayed until after closing) at the local office there, 4-5 different sets of lines (3 of them in the same office), and I think a total of 12 bureaucrats, queue watcher, and security guards. Then I tried had to do the same thing in Oregon a few years later. That took one person about 20 minutes to finish. It's just crazy how much variance there is between states & offices.
- jjav 3y ago> Imagine if we had a similar system for the departments of motor vehicles... pay 20% more but get it all done in minutes online instead of hours at the local office. Who wouldn't pay for that if they could afford it? I can't tell if this is a reference to AAA or you're not aware of it? That's basically what the AAA membership gets you. But at least in California, the DMV these days directly supports doing all the common things online so I haven't had a AAA membership in a long time nor have I had to go in person to the DMV in a long time.
- solardev 3y agoWhat AAA can and cannot do for you varies by state. I don't live in California (any longer).
- rz2k 3y agoI think these types of fees happen often, are discovered, then they are refunded. This even happened with me with a government agency where we had a collegial relationship. The administrator found out we had paid for data that was supposed to be public, told us no one was authorized to impose a fee, and joked that they must have wanted to throw an office party or something. He was actually very serious about apologizing and refunding the fees, but it wasn’t a big deal. It becomes a problem when people take the attitude that what’s done is done. The fees should be refunded, at least from the consultants back into the public purse, and they should take much greater precautions when it comes to “public private partnerships” and monetizing access to public land.