4 ms·
So you tried to run your app on it and ran into trouble, and you conclude that Fedora is an unstable hunk of shit? Also, this attitude that Fedora is just a te
by freedomben 3y ago
So you tried to run your app on it and ran into trouble, and you conclude that Fedora is an unstable hunk of shit?
Also, this attitude that Fedora is just a tester for a commercial product is absurd. I suppose this is the same logic that makes CentOS Stream just a "beta" of RHEL (but strangely, these same people don't consider RHEL a "beta" for old CentOS even though consistency would demand this).
Anecdotally, I've used a lot of distros over many years, and Fedora has been by far the most stable and "just works" of any of them. There were a couple of rough years with the Nvidia driver, but I blame Nvidia for that.
- fariszr 3y agoOld CentOS wasn't downstream from RHEL, it was a clone. While stream is upstream for RHEL.
- freedomben 3y agoYes it was a "clone", but it was "downstream". In fact Alma themselves just a couple days ago in their post pointed out the CentOS Stream is "upstream" while Alma is "downstream" of RHEL. CentOS always lagged RHEL by a little bit of time. Big security things it was usually days, but other times could be weeks or even months on new minor version increases. The only way for it be just a clone would be to near-instant rebuild, which has never been the case.
- christophilus 3y agoI agree with this assessment. Happy Fedora user here, but I am a bit nervous about the I Mification of RedHat and the potential long term ramifications for Fedora.
- christophilus 3y agoNo idea why iOS corrected “ramifications” to “I Mification”. Too late to edit, though.
- kkielhofner 3y agoMy conclusion was, essentially, that if I can't get our application to work with Fedora in a way that is practical, approachable, and sustainable for our "average" user it should likely be unsupported. I should also add I was working with at least one person who has a tremendous amount of experience with Fedora and they were taken aback by the whole experience as well. I should also note our application, specifically, (more of a long term support appliance) would likely represent an undue support burden because of the fairly rapid Fedora release cycle. As a random tangent, how is DNF /still/ so ridiculously slow? I don't get it. Ubuntu/Debian is our main development platform so of course it "just works" there (in addition to various other Debian/Ubuntu derivates). However, when I repeated the same exercise for Arch (as one example) - a distro I have zero experience with - the process was completely painless and we had it implemented and documented in something like 30 minutes. Even though it is a rolling release the Arch wiki has substantially better documentation alone than anything I could find in the Fedora ecosystem (random hodgepodge blog posts for the last three major versions). Again, I've been using Linux near-universally since 1997. I've had these debates (religious flamewars) plenty of times before and I have no interest in rehashing them. That said I don't know how anyone could debate my central point (let alone call it "absurd") - that Fedora is a testing ground for a stable LTS, commercially supported product (and one that with recent events is even more so). This is all right there, clear as day, in the official documentation[0]. So maybe not "absurd"? I suppose I just don't understand the general preference for Fedora (other than momentum and familiarity) when there are plenty of other choices around where the primary goal is a free, stable, and open release. On that note - IMO the best thing about open source is choice. Use whatever works for you, why would I care? I do not. [0] - https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/quick-docs/fedora-and-red-hat-enterprise-linux/ https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/quick-docs/fedora-and-r...
- strzibny 3y agoFedora is really great. I use it on desktop for over 10 years now. Very stable (like 2 issues in all that time). Much better than alternatives.
- eredengrin 3y agoSame, I distro hopped for a while across various ubuntu and ubuntu derivatives, always ran into weird issues, stability problems, etc (and still do at work where we use ubuntu). Installed fedora eventually and have been using it ever since, outside of a packagekit bug like 7 years ago that didn't clear the cache and ate my disk space, it's been pretty smooth sailing.