16 ms·
Show HN: Mofi – Content-aware fill for audio to change a song to any duration
I worked on a web service that allows you to import a song and define a target length that the song will be shortened or lengthened to. It does this by analyzing the song and finding repeating audio patterns. This is helpful for making any song match a video or performance with a set duration. You can also specify areas of the song to prefer or avoid. An example is available here: https://mofi.loud.red/edit/8bd3fdf780f8c3927e41029f3b957f8a7ed96863 https://mofi.loud.red/edit/8bd3fdf780f8c3927e41029f3b957f8a7...
The cool thing is that after the song is analyzed on the server, the client can recompute and preview the results completely client-side through an implementation that uses Web Workers and WebAssembly. The audio previewing uses Tone.js. I am thinking of writing up some more details about the implementation in the future.
I'm still working on a way to explain this easily, but I like the idea of carrying over the concept of content-aware fill from images to audio.
Please let me know if you have any comments or questions!
- redox99 3y agoDoes this create "new" music for the filled parts, like some AIs (MusicLM, MusicGen, etc) do? Or just repeat in a more seamless way?
- jaflo 3y agoIt does not create new music from scratch using one of the techniques you mentioned, but just reuses parts from the song, blending the transitions between them. That is a cool idea though!
- sd9 3y agoInfinite roll: https://mofi.loud.red/edit/517b150b00ca475016cd64c2ed0730266735aa5c https://mofi.loud.red/edit/517b150b00ca475016cd64c2ed0730266...
- smokeydoe 3y agoThis works great with the clips made from MusicGen. The loops are seamless. Thank you for making it free. I would love to know more about how you are analyzing the audio.
- Pr0ject217 3y agoThis is pretty cool! Will you consider open-sourcing it?
- ljlolel 3y agoCool!
- MatthewWilkes 3y agoSurprising that the only mention of intellectual property in the FAQ and the legal terms page is about copyright that the service claims in the outputs, not restrictions on the inputs.
- liminalsunset 3y agoThe ToS for this claims that you have to pay for it to use the results commercially, but I couldn't find the pricing for it anywhere or any way to sign up. Interesting, as the primary use case for this seems to be something along the lines of editing music to fit into video projects.
- jaflo 3y agoI plan to implement paid features later with a basic free tier. I am still trying to figure that out. I've updated the terms to be more clear about that!
- liminalsunset 3y agoAh, I see. Nitpick: It currently says "Do not upload rights that you do not have the rights to".
- jaflo 3y agoWhoops, thank you, will update!
- naltroc 3y agosince there is no login mechanism, I used the anonymous feedback section to request their agreements with BMI and ASCAP for creating liscenced mechanical renditions of copyrighted materials.
- jaflo 3y agoThis is a good point, I have updated the site to only allow you to view content you submitted and also made it clear that you need to have the rights to the audio to edit it.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoCan’t wait to use this to stretch my 19 minute prog rock tracks into 190 minutes :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- codetrotter 3y ago> This is helpful for making any song match a video or performance with a set duration. This is perfect for TikTok videos! Will definitely be using your tool. Very cool! > I am thinking of writing up some more details about the implementation in the future. Please do :D
- Solvency 3y agoHow did you make the animation in the homepage? It's definitely not a screen recording...it feels like something animated in After Effects at 60fps. Is that true? Or did you use something else?
- jasonjmcghee 3y agoLooks a bit like https://www.screen.studio/ https://www.screen.studio/
- jaflo 3y agoCorrect, this is it! It's basically a blend of screen recording and AE. The recording is made and then the software smoothes cursor movements and creates the zoom effects.
- sundaeofshock 3y agoI know I’m in the minority here, but I hate it. The artist created created a song of a particular length for a very specific reason. I prefer to listen to a song the way it was meant to be listened too.
- jstanley 3y agoThey created it that length for their reasons. You might want it a different length for your reasons. It's not clear that their reasons trump your reasons, given that your modification has no effect on them whatsoever.
- wrigby 3y agoThat’s fine, as long as you have obtained permission from the copyright holder to create a derivative work. Otherwise, their reasons very much do trump your reasons.
- Blahah 3y agoSharing a derivative work could breach copyright, but if you are doing it for yourself you don't need permission.
- sundaeofshock 3y agoI choose to listen to songs by an artist because I enjoy the choices that artist made.
- Majestic121 3y agoThat's fine. Other people make other choices.
- ralusek 3y agoSometimes they create music at a particular length because that's what worked well on radio, or TikTok, or for a club set. I would go so far as to say that song length is probably chosen for some specific non-artistic constraint more often than it is chosen for some reason intrinsic to the art. So changing the music to accommodate your own constraint, i.e. "this is the part I like when I'm working out and wish it was longer" seems completely reasonable, and isn't even justified in being considered some sacrilegious act.
- KolmogorovComp 3y agoSeems really nice, though for some reason after pasting a YouTube link it's stuck when reaching 100%, would have liked to give it a try.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jaflo 3y agoLooks like the machine ran out of disk space, I bumped it and it should work. Could you try again?
- KolmogorovComp 3y agoWorks well now, thanks! Overhaul quite impressive even though sometimes the cut is still noticeable.
- 71a54xd 3y agoDo these get tagged by contentID on Youtube?
- quickthrower2 3y agoI can finally see and hear what Bohemian Rapsody would have sounded like had they caved in to make a radio-friendly cut.
- kunalgupta 3y agoPerfect! You automated my hobby of extending music videos to last up to the max video length available on YouTube in 2008 https://youtu.be/XCJs_eAkNS8 https://youtu.be/XCJs_eAkNS8
- cheschire 3y agoThere's a specific sect of deadmau5 fans that would love to use this to generate multi-hour continuous mixes of a song called Strobe.
- jermeh 3y agoI feel attacked
- all2 3y agoThe YT 10 hour videos are calling your name. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYT9vQLxt5c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYT9vQLxt5c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n88U4n3Z3Iw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n88U4n3Z3Iw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YMF5djy3HNE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YMF5djy3HNE
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoI hate that the frequency of the bass kicks doesn't match the frequency of the eyes flashing, so they go out of sync. The eye flashing feels about 1 bpm slower than the beat.
- cheschire 3y agoSo the difference there is that's just the song on repeat. OP's tool here will try to fill the song in with content-aware filler similar to how Photoshop uses a content-aware fill feature to try to guess what could be in the gaps. For people who know every beat of Strobe, it sounds odd when things don't hit the same way, but at the same time it's kind of like a unique live mix.
- josuepeq 3y agoThis is neat, I have wondered if anything of this nature existed, in the past, as a child of the 80s/90s attempting to master the art of the perfect mixtape… 30 minutes a side down to the second the tape runs out, would be a win. But for today’s music, shortening the 2010s/2020 already shorter lengths would mean a song might not be more than a minute in length. On average, full unedited tracks today end up being a bit shorter than they used to be, solely due to the economics of streaming. Rather than paying for the content second by second, it is done by paying per track play. The result is a lot of 2 minute tracks, which were produced with the “verse” parts getting jammed together into the “chorus” with no break in vocals, which also uses pitch adjustments, “the “bridge” is an afterthought that is terrible, or more recently, nonexistent……… Instrumental solo? Anyone? Bueller? Music is no longer anticipated, budgeted for, and purchased on launch day with great fanfare. We have grown accustomed to the idea that we should have everything available at our fingertips, and as a consequence of this we get exactly what we pay for.
- seanthemon 3y agoI agree, I think another part of it is accessibility to tools and content. Same thing happens with gaming to an extent, when tools became more accessible, so did the content, but the quality dropped significantly, even among AAA games. I think music suffers even more so because we're all so tuned into having the best at our fingertips that if a single moment in a song isn't to our liking we can skip and forget about it completely - i think this fuels the fast-short song market, easier to saturate with many short songs and get listens rather than to work/slave on a longer more intricate piece. Back in the day, mixtapes with songs were slaved on and cherished, today slaving over something is seen as a negative quality.
- autoexec 3y ago> if a single moment in a song isn't to our liking we can skip and forget about it completely I do sometimes worry about this. Some of my favorite songs growing up were ones that I didn't care for initially but which grew on me only after listening to it repeatedly. Now it's easy to dismiss anything that doesn't hook me right away. Thankfully albums are still being released, and you can force yourself to listen though them, or keep more of the "meh" songs in your playlists for longer periods of time, even adding them back into rotation after a while. I don't think I'd give up the variety we have now though and go back to only having what songs are pushed at us through top 40 radio or the limited selection found in local stores. I get my music now from countries all over the globe. Finding old stuff all the time I'd never heard and new things just released. We can still invest in the music we listen to and be rewarded. We just aren't forced to, so it needs to be deliberate.
- ConnorMooneyhan 3y agoI'm a tad disappointed. Cool idea, but I haven't gotten anything to really sound seamless when shortening or lengthening yet.
- jaflo 3y agoIt definitely works better on pop songs or music with repeating choruses or patterns as those can be matched to each other more easily. What kind of music did you try it with?
- stu2010 3y agoWhat's the maximum length? I can't find it documented anywhere and keep running into it when trying to try this with Tool tracks.
- jaflo 3y agoThere is no enforced maximum length for either input or output right now. In practice, the remote machine times out trying to analyze a song after 10 or so minutes. For output, your machine will take forever to generate really long results.
- stu2010 3y agoI see an error saying "Remote media exceeds maximum duration" for this track that is 9:24 long: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7JG63IuaWs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7JG63IuaWs I'm guessing that's the timeout?
- jaflo 3y agoI had forgotten about this check actually! I just removed it and deployed the changes. You can try again but am unsure if it will break something (it will spin indefinitely, but I would give it up to 10 minutes). Good luck!
- Philip-J-Fry 3y agoThere used to be something called the eternal jukebox I think. But you could give it a song and it would endlessly loop the audio like you have here. But it would also switch it up and change the parts it looped. And it would have a nice visualisation showing how the parts of the song connect and the different paths it takes. I think it was https://eternalbox.dev/ https://eternalbox.dev/ since that's all I can find on Google. But that site is down.
- gffrd 3y agoYes! It was "Infinite Jukebox," created by Paul Lamere … it was awesome because it would analyse a track, then visualize its "components" and you could watch as the new "infinite" track looped back on itself and jumped from point-to-point in the original track to create an everlasting one. He created some excellent products from the Rdio API, and later Spotify … and I believe his analysis engine ended up being the foundation upon which Spotify's _play more tracks like these_ capability is based. Looks like he's moved over to publish on Substack—there's a recent(ish) post reflecting on 10 years of Infinite Jukebox: https://musicmachinery.substack.com/p/the-infinite-jukebox-10-years-later https://musicmachinery.substack.com/p/the-infinite-jukebox-1...
- rzzzt 3y agoThe Echo Nest had lots of cool toys: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Echo_Nest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Echo_Nest Edit: I remember a multitrack file format from the past that allowed following both a composer-defined path as well as random/infinite ordering of sequences, it was called digimpro: https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=102403 https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=102403
- jaflo 3y agoThe Echo Nest was really cool... they got bought my Spotify and some of the Echo Nest APIs made it into Spotify I believe: https://developer.spotify.com/documentation/web-api/reference/get-audio-analysis https://developer.spotify.com/documentation/web-api/referenc...
- personjerry 3y agoI created a 10 minute version of The Less I know The Better (https://mofi.loud.red/edit/dde278b8c131c1a6e47117ceb29d1ceb6ee7a80d https://mofi.loud.red/edit/dde278b8c131c1a6e47117ceb29d1ceb6...) but the export doesn't seem to work, it just errors out with "Invalid Crossfade" multiple times
- jaflo 3y agoWhoops, looks like there was a bug, just fixed it, could you try again?
- personjerry 3y agoLooks like it works now, thanks!
- cchance 3y agois it just me or does exporting not work to share it with people, it says i need the original song to view that link above ?
- sergiotapia 3y agoThank you, now I can remove Dababy from Dua Lipa - Levitating. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUVcZfQe-Kw&pp=ygUTZHVhIGxpcGEgbGV2aXRhdGluZw%3D%3D https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUVcZfQe-Kw&pp=ygUTZHVhIGxpc... He just butchers an otherwise perfect song! Will report back with results. Edit: Results are great! https://voca.ro/13ar1g88LSKK https://voca.ro/13ar1g88LSKK
- brennopost 3y agoCan't you just listen to the version he's not featured on?
- sergiotapia 3y agoI'm not sure there's an "official" version? I've listened to a few on youtube and it seems like they are all fan-made.
- brennopost 3y agoTrack 5 on Future Nostalgia is Levitating without Dababy's verse.
- jonathantf2 3y agoThe first thing that comes up on Apple Music when you search for Levitating is the version without DaBaby.
- pradn 3y agoThis is exciting. It adds to the tools creators have to remix songs. A middle ground between full AI and full human-made songs is a mix, like what Bronze AI has done with one of my favorite songs. (https://bronze.ai/listen/jai-paul/ https://bronze.ai/listen/jai-paul/) A less rosy scenario is like Spotify generating music to get around having to pay artists.
- mmh0000 3y agoThis is the coolest thing ever! I like to have multiple hour continuations of songs which I use to help me fall asleep. In the past I've made my own, but I'm terrible at audio editing. It is a ton of work and, for me, really hard to get right. After a little bit of experimenting with Mofi, it seems to do a very good job and selecting when to repeat a sections. [edit] Here's my first attempt for a 30 minute song: https://mofi.loud.red/edit/ebbf4b410181aa767152945cbb6a2d67910710e1 https://mofi.loud.red/edit/ebbf4b410181aa767152945cbb6a2d679...
- jtbayly 3y agoI wish this worked. I wanted to listen to an example. But all I got was “You haven't imported this file yet. Import it first to use it.”
- jaflo 3y agoFearing copyright lawyers, I implemented this message so you cannot share audio by just sending a link anymore, but have to import the song yourself to be able to use it :( You can use this example though if you just want to try: https://mofi.loud.red/edit/8bd3fdf780f8c3927e41029f3b957f8a7ed96863 https://mofi.loud.red/edit/8bd3fdf780f8c3927e41029f3b957f8a7...
- kkwtflz 3y agoLocal storage can be easily bypassed if you don't encrypt the values in that array...
- BonoboIO 3y agoThis gives me "Not Imported You haven't imported this file yet. Import it first to use it."
- Workaccount2 3y agoPerhaps tangential to this project, but I have always wanted something that can detect different instruments/sounds and allow me to adjust the volume on them/remix them. There are a few songs I love, but some of the best parts seem to be "buried" under other instruments.
- MitPitt 3y agoThis can be done with quite aged AI actually. You can split a song into vocals+instrumental, or even vocals+drums+bass+other https://github.com/Anjok07/ultimatevocalremovergui https://github.com/Anjok07/ultimatevocalremovergui
- silon42 3y agoI'd like to simply filter vocals (for listening while work/coding/...)... any tools for that? Preferably local without requirement for AI/nVidia card...
- JohnFen 3y agoInteresting. Is there any chance you would release this to run natively rather than as a web service?
- jaflo 3y agoI think it could be possible (backend is in Python), but for most users a web service has a lower barrier of entry. Could you share your use case? I am curious.
- JohnFen 3y agoThere's nothing special about my use case. It's just that I avoid relying on anything that is only available as SaaS, because it can vanish or change at any time without notice.
- cyberax 3y agoCan we use something like this to remove the laugh track, please? PLEASE? It needs to be generalized to video content, but the task is a bit easier.
- wpietri 3y agoMy big question: what have you learned while working on this (very cool) project?
- jaflo 3y agoThis project brought together a lot of different pieces of engineering and was a larger personal project for me, so there were a lot of parts and making those work together was a challenge at times. For the backend, I found it helpful to implement monitoring proactively to be able to detect and debug issues without having to bug users which has been really helpful so far and allowed me to make some performance improvements too! For the frontend it was interesting to optimize the result searching using the Web Worker + WebAssembly approach. I found some interesting ways to speed up things by parallelizing and, interestingly, manually collecting garbage in the WASM runtime. And of course learning about the entire audio analysis portion and reading on how to find similar sections of audio!
- RyanShook 3y agoThank you for making this tool. So impressive how many features work well in this initial version.
- personjerry 3y agoI'm enjoying the results, I can make my favourite tunes 10 minutes long and often it's pretty seamless! I can't wait to get sick of all my songs :) Is the project open-source?
- jaflo 3y agoGlad you like it! Sadly this version is not, but this project is a rewrite from an old version I created that is open-source! https://github.com/jaflo/snipsnip https://github.com/jaflo/snipsnip If you are interested in audio analysis in general, I would also recommend checking out librosa: https://librosa.org/doc/latest/index.html https://librosa.org/doc/latest/index.html
- omegaworks 3y agoGetting an SSL error - invalid HTTPS certificate. Site is being tagged as malware.
- jedberg 3y agoThe way this works is interesting. I asked it to cut 30 seconds from the middle of a song (a spoken word portion without music) and then shorten the track by 30 seconds. I figured it would just cut that out and do some fancy blending of the music before and after the cut to make it sound good. Instead I got: at 00:00 a 00:16 segment (00:00–00:16) at 00:16 a 00:51 segment (02:05–02:57) at 01:07 a 02:31 segment (01:34–04:05) at 03:39 a 00:11 segment (04:03–04:14) It's adding and repeating chunks of the song and cutting other parts and I'm not sure why.
- lelanthran 3y agoMy word is this impressive. I uploaded Wuthering Heights[1], selected just the trailing guitar solo (3:09 to just before the fade-out starts), and got a bunch of seemless sounding 3m tracks of just that guitar shredding away. All the ones it generated were perfectly cut and pasted, with one exception in track 2 where I could tell where it was cut/pasted. Can't wait to try it with the guitar at the end of Brothers in Arms (Dire Straits), or the flute solo in Locomotive Breath. If anyone is looking for a good use of AI, I wouldn't mind a webpage that lets me say "complete this solo that was abruptly cut short" and get something great. [1] This one is especially sad because the sound engineer/producer later lamented that he faded the solo out so quickly because the player was still improving like mad and what he had left after the fadeout was apparently better than what he had done while recording.
- InCityDreams 3y agoThanks! I took up guitar because recorded solos were never long enough.
- EwanG 3y agoFirst thought was that we finally have an answer for Symphony No. 8 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._8_(Schubert) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._8_(Schubert))
- emmanueloga_ 3y agoReally nice! Do you use a library or service to find the self similar points, or is it your work? Found a bunch of cool related links here [1]. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Music_information_retrieval https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Music_information_retrieval
- jonathantf2 3y agoSeems kinda cool but I'm stuck on "Loading results... (0%, 0 of 19 done)"
- anon_cow1111 3y agoSame here, you have any script blocking etc?
- frankfrank13 3y agosuper fun to use. very useful right away
- personjerry 3y agoIt would be cool if you could link to a particular cut (i.e. a five star 10 minute version I really like)
- danhau 3y agoVery cool! It seems to struggle with mixed meter music, though (understandably). I've uploaded a song of mine that's mostly in 6/8, but has some bars of 7/8. It still makes smooth transitions, but on the wrong beat, which is very noticeable. I will try it again with a song in only one odd measure, maybe that works.
- diggum 3y agoI was fortunate to help bring similar tech to life as a PM for Adobe Audition and Premiere Pro in a feature dubbed Remix. Since we were designing to help music fit the duration of a scene or video project, our goals resulted in a slightly different experience from those of music fans wanting to recut a song for general purpose listening, but it worked like magic for most tracks. Still one of my favorite projects that I worked on.
- diggum 3y agoAnd I just realized you acknowledged it at the bottom of the page! ;)
- jaflo 3y agoThe tech behind the Remix feature looks really impressive! I haven't used it myself, but while working on this project I had some people mention it to me and I looked at some videos showing how it's used. Very cool feature!
- mmh0000 3y agoAfter spending all afternoon playing with this. I have two inputs. 1] A lot of the heavy lifting is done client side, which is excellent; I have a super fast processor! But, watching the CPU utilization, it seems to spike the CPU for a few milliseconds, then waits for a second or two and, spikes the CPU again, then repeats. I suspect there may be some significant performance improvements to be had on client recomputes. 2] While it is doing recomputes, it would be great to get a progress bar or, at least, a message saying, "This will take a long time, be patient." It took me multiple attempts to determine that the service was indeed working, just that my client was taking its sweet time recomputing.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoSeeing the domain has me curious, is it a reference to a Pokemon[0] or is it something else? (Sorry for off-topic!) > On repeat: Make an extended version of your song's favorite part by choosing the catchy part and seamlessly repeating part of it! John Mulaney's "Best Meal I Ever Had" story[1] had me wanting to do this for Tom Jones' What's New Pussycat so I could play that as an inside joke with some friends. This would definitely have made that easier. (Ultimately, I had a version of the song which started in the middle and "ended" right before it "started" so the effect could be mimicked if the file was played on loop. This had a short silence manifest as the media player "loaded a new song" from its perspective; didn't have that issue in Audacity.) [0] https://www.pokemon.com/us/pokedex/loudred https://www.pokemon.com/us/pokedex/loudred [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tv1l1eUhN-E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tv1l1eUhN-E (Usually called "The Salt and Pepper Diner")
- jaflo 3y agoYes, it is! I wanted a short domain for side projects, and then this one came across and I registered it. I tried to give an homage to the Pokemon in the favicon in the root domain :) https://loud.red/favicon-32x32.png https://loud.red/favicon-32x32.png And yes, I had this issue while testing also! A lot of players added a small gap when looping which was a bit annoying to test with...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Jamesmoorez 3y ago[dead]
- netvarun 3y ago[offtopic] Could you share what tool you used to generate the demo gif/video? Very nicely done!
- peterdigital 3y agoWould love to sort by most cuts just to see what happens
- hkab 3y agoCool! It seems to work well with slow songs, the transition is very smooth
- benkaiser 3y agoInteresting how the youtube videos are pulled down in a cloud function and stored on a file host for caching. I know there is a disclaimer about making sure you have the applicable rights, and IANAL, but this is for sure violating some terms and potentially copyright when users are using videos they don't have rights to.
- empyrrhicist 3y agoAre you worried about trademark infringement? https://mofi.com/ https://mofi.com/
- ben7799 3y agoTotally.. Mobile Fidelity is also in the music space, I'd expect a lawsuit or the name of this software to have to change.
- JonathanFly 3y agoWhat's the difference between "Search" and "Edit song"? It seems like Search is just about length, and Edit also considers sections you marked? Or does Edit do the same thing but with many edits, rather than a few?
- edonhametsu 3y agoIf you're stuck on Loading (0 of 19), make sure you have a new enough Firefox version to support dynamic import for workers (https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1540913 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1540913, i.e. 113 or newer). For example, ESR 102 does not have the feature and it breaks the site.
- xadoc 3y agoHow do you get the audio from Youtube?
- nicexe 3y agoI use https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp You can use -F to get the available formats and find out an audio-only stream then -f FORMAT to download the specified stream.
- EGreg 3y agoPretty soon I can see how people will make a content-aware fill for relationships, heartfelt messages etc
- boffinAudio 3y agoI like this but there are a lot of studios in the world where I will never be able to access it, so I'd really like to have a standalone/non-web version if its at all possible. I'd pay for that.
- superasn 3y agoThis will be great for my programming music. Though it's just anecdotal but I have seen that the quickest way to enter into the zone is to play repeating loops at 140 bpm. Unfortunately I haven't really found many of these as most of the tracks I love are non looping. I think this can take care of it. Kudos on making this!
- nicexe 3y agoI tried lengthening Another Day by Dream Theater from 4:26 to 8:00. I set it to avoid the segment that the key changes and to favor the 2 solo segments. It doesn't seem like its doing a good job. Only the first 5 seconds of the intro made it and then is just repeating over and over the big solo. In the end, a very small part of the short solo makes it in as an outro. Maybe it works better at shortening songs or maybe changing duration closer to the original duration.
- yanuzay 3y agoIt's possible to add multiple files and added them at once?
- T3RMINATED 3y ago[dead]
- LorenDB 3y agoThis is pretty good! However, there are some unusual splices. One I found was with a recording of Cumberland Gap[0]. If you run a 10 minute loop, you'll find that the first splice in multiple tracks (happens at about the 2:30 mark), the song suddenly cuts to the middle of a mandolin solo that clearly doesn't belong there. With that being said, I'm still overall impressed by this. [0]: https://youtu.be/VAk4_CMn7To https://youtu.be/VAk4_CMn7To
- yumikai 3y agoSuper cool, not what you would typically think of when it comes to gen music!
- okinawamist 3y agovery cool. is this purely DSP based?
- objectspace 3y agoCool!
- SillyUsername 3y agoPlease add the option for a longer fade out, plenty of songs finish too early and it would be great if they could just fade out rather than stop abruptly.
- IndigoIncognito 3y agoI wish google ranked services like these right at the top when users search for these tools, currently they are filled with ad filled, paywalled, slow & tedious media editing services I wouldn't mind giving money to services like this
- zedadex 3y agoAs a fan of tools like this and Eternal Jukebox, I cannot wait for the ones that have an option to request a cut specifically, like "from approximately this point, jump back to around this other point", while using the 'smart' features to line up the audio cuts (I'm sure stuff like that is built into the CC suite but I'm not springing that kind of money to recut a few of my tunes for personal listening ). With Eternal Jukebox I was able to emulate it by setting the jump percent very high manually at the right time (but had to be paying attention + had to get lucky with which branch it took), whereas here I'll see if I can get it going by calculating what the cut I want would set the song length to, and requesting that length and fewest cuts. (Edit: didn't work) Sometimes the simplest features are the easiest to overlook but most useful
- Jamesmoorez 3y ago[dead]