6 ms·
Bloomsday: The library’s one-of-a-kind copy of “Ulysses”
- dontupvoteme 3y agoI had no idea Joyce was banned in America for a while. Thanks, the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice.
- Synaesthesia 3y agoIt's got graphic descriptions of not only sex but bodily functions like menstruation.
- imdsm 3y agoNot the worst things to write about. Kinda normal things really. Everyday things.
- lapetitejort 3y agoEveryday things, required to propagate ourselves as a species, and yet bizarrely squeamish to certain populations. My father, a normal person born in New England, still can't believe that people use the word "pregnant" in public. He expressed this to me as recently as a few weeks ago.
- Synaesthesia 3y agoApt the time it was unprecedented
- dumpsterlid 3y ago[dead]
- Synaesthesia 3y agoJoyce never intended for the book to only be read by university professors - he was a man of the people and intended for the book to be read by ordinary people. Still a guide is kinda necessary when tackling it.
- twoodfin 3y agoThe RTÉ radio production is essentially word-for-word complete, fully cast & wonderfully performed. It’s my recommended on ramp to the novel for anyone intimidated by the prose style. Ironically (intentionally?), Joyce simultaneously wrote wonderfully for the spoken word form, but insisted on typography that makes who’s saying what often obscure. https://www.rte.ie/culture/2022/0610/1146705-listen-ulysses-james-joyce-podcast/ https://www.rte.ie/culture/2022/0610/1146705-listen-ulysses-...
- dumpsterlid 3y ago[dead]
- mackrevinack 3y agoi must check that out when i get home. frank delaney did short podcasts every week where he went through a few lines at a time. he never got to finish the full book unfortunately but its what i usually recommend to people because its very casual and easy to listen to
- richeyryan 3y agoThe audiobook, narrated by Jim Norton, is also great. His delivery is quite engaging, and any parts that might be a bit impenetrable while reading flow over you, and you can hook back in later.
- ramesh31 3y ago>Joyce never intended for the book to only be read by university professors - he was a man of the people and intended for the book to be read by ordinary people. Honestly, he intended the work to be read aloud publicly, in the same vein of epic storytelling as The Odyssey. There's even a recording of him reading a few pages, it's absolutely mesmerizing: https://youtu.be/ZhW0TrzWGmI https://youtu.be/ZhW0TrzWGmI
- richeyryan 3y agoI saw a production of Ulysses twice in the Abbey Theatre in Dublin on two separate runs. I had already read the book, but seeing it performed was a completely different experience, like seeing a Shakespeare text performed in film or on stage. Similarly, I saw an adaptation of the Cyclops episode in the New Theatre, which was incredible. I know Ulysses is unfilmable, but I'd like to see someone like Paul Thomas Anderson try.
- DC-3 3y ago> including Joyce’s notation that the book was based on “The Odyssey,” without which the world might never have noticed the connection Given that 'Ulysses' is the Roman name for Odysseus, I think we might've worked it out :p
- twoodfin 3y agoI’m guessing this was a bit of dry humor. It’s interesting to speculate on the most efficient argument that Ulysses takes “The Odyssey” as its primary source material purely founded on the text minus the title.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lotophage 3y agoI only recently discovered his letter to Nora Barnacle professing his fondness of her farts. Quite possibly the funniest thing that I have ever read, although I did feel a tinge of guilt since it was never intended for the public.
- ironSkillet 3y agoWebsite is rendering without the content for me - anyone else?
- fjfaase 3y agoInteresting story. Last year, I found Volume 2 of the 1932 edition from The Odyssey Press in a charity shop for just €0.50 [1]. At home I discovered a round paper sticker with the words 'Buning' and 'Djokja'. It seems it either was sold in Yogyakarta are belonged to someone who lived there [2]. [1] https://www.iwriteiam.nl/D2201.html#26 https://www.iwriteiam.nl/D2201.html#26 [2] https://www.iwriteiam.nl/D2201.html#27 https://www.iwriteiam.nl/D2201.html#27
- madaxe_again 3y agoI always feel so uncharitable when I find something special in a charity shop. The best find yet was from oxfam in Winchester - Arabian Nights, numbered and signed by Dulac, 1914 edition - £2, as the spine was (had it restored) damaged. Oh, and a rather nice Moxon Idylls of the King, same shop a few months later, which I think was £25. Both are worth a fair bit, but I’ve no intention of parting with them. Non-literary works… a tiny watercolour by Nolde, gallery stamped and all, for £5. That, I sold at auction as I’m not much of a fan of his, and it paid for the renovation of a cottage. I think these days they’ve largely wised up, but I still can’t resist a delve whenever I go by a charity shop.
- DoughnutHole 3y agoThose all seem like shockingly rare finds - do you spend a great deal of time investigating different charity shops? Most I find are full of utterly mundane second hand mass-market paperbacks.
- madaxe_again 3y agoI stick my head in pretty much any charity shop I pass to get a feel for the place, and there’s a huge variability in what you’ll find. Winchester’s second oxfam was a goldmine, as was their municipal dump - got a lovely set of late 18th c. Anglo-Indian rosewood dining chairs for a nominal sum at the latter, which took me all of an afternoon to bring back to life. Broadstairs in Kent I also had some great finds. It’s to do with the local populace - elderly, wealthy, and often lacking inheritors - and then they staff in the shops being just parochial enough to have no idea what they have. Big cities, forget about it, you’re more likely to win the lottery.
- bambax 3y ago> The final twist: Benoist-Méchin grew into a prominence of his own as a historian and journalist who enthusiastically collaborated with Nazi Germany’s takeover of France in World War II. He was condemned to death as a traitor after the war and eventually had his sentence commuted after seven years in prison. In total, Benoist-Méchin was interned for 10 years: arrested in Sept. 44, sentenced in June 47 and released in Nov. 54. He went on to write well-respected history books; I have read a couple of them. I knew about his conduct during WWII but never knew he was friends with Joyce.
- ramesh31 3y agoTangential, but one of my favorite uses so far for ChatGPT has been to help me finally penetrate Ulysses. It's an almost unassailable work on its' own. Sheer genius, but hard to appreciate beyond the surface level without assistance.
- avemuri 3y agoI'm curious. How do you prompt it?
- ramesh31 3y agoMostly page by page, with text copied from Gutenberg. Generally I'll give it a paragraph (which in Ulysses can be multiple pages...) and start by saying "rewrite this in plain simple english" for the summary. Then I'll have it start rewriting in different forms, i.e. "rewrite this as a haiku" or "rewrite this as a poem in iambic pentameter with a modern setting using contemporary vernacular". Then once I understand the central themes, I can dig deeper and ask how it relates to the story as a whole, or how it ties back to events from The Odyssey.
- cdelsolar 3y agohey cool idea. I've always wanted to read Finnegans Wake, and am trying some paragraphs now with chatgpt. I don't think it's quite what Joyce intended, nor do I know if it makes any more sense, but it is easier to read :P For example: Rot a peck of pa's malt had Jhem or Shen brewed by arclight and rory end to the regginbrow was to be seen ringsome on the aquaface. becomes: There was no sign of Jhem or Shen brewing a measure of their father's malt using artificial light, and the end of the ridge was not visible in the water's reflection.
- mackrevinack 3y agotheres something like 20+ different languages used in the wake and a lot of times its only half a word from one language mixed with another word so i cant see chatgpt being able to parse out all that
- AlbertCory 3y agoJust before the pandemic, I was taking a Stanford Extension class on Ulysses. A few students were taking it for credit, but most of us were there purely because we wanted to be. I'd always wanted to read it. The teacher had been teaching that book since the early 70s. We had a guidebook to help us through it. We all had a particular edition, so the teacher could say "on page 341" and we all could go there. Whatever else you can say, this was about as ideal an environment as you could wish for. Meh. I can see it was groundbreaking in its time, but now? Outlived its shelf life. Stream-of-consciousness was revolutionary, I give him credit, but now it's routine. Even at the time, Einstein, Freud, and Darwin were revolutionizing modern thought, and Joyce was resolutely ignorant of them. People say, "What about all the symbolism? What about all the word play?" Again, I say, meh. Anna Karenina -- now that's a great novel.
- mistrial9 3y ago"one man gathers what another man spills"
- Cupertino95014 3y agoOut of curiosity: have you read the book?
- mistrial9 3y agoI did read some Joyce but not much.. I was not hooked on it or a fan, myself. The experience of a mature adult reader, "seeing the shortcomings of this work" is not particularly praise-worthy even if completely true, in my opinion. Different personalities and intellects may experience that literature at different stages of life, in character development themselves, in retrospect... A work of "art" let's say.. literature.. is not only the words or the story, it is an experience for the reader, and product of the author and their team of teams, the printers and publishers themselves. It is a toe into "cancel culture" to dismiss as trivial or wanting, a work that has in the large, affected many people. Maybe every word of that review is real, to that person, but it does not much good, or show any respect, to spoil it that way.. hence my comment