9 ms·
America aims for nuclear-power renaissance
- neonate 3y agohttps://archive.ph/LDq5u https://archive.ph/LDq5u http://web.archive.org/web/20230626034432/https://www.economist.com/united-states/2023/06/25/america-aims-for-nuclear-power-renaissance http://web.archive.org/web/20230626034432/https://www.econom...
- brucethemoose2 3y agoGood! I'm surprised the government is even pushing this. Nuclear is such a long term investment, and is so politically toxic among loud extremists in particular, that it doesn't make any political sense to push. Yet it is happening.
- bluedino 3y agoThe price is what kills it.
- kyrra 3y agoIt's the regulations that kill it (which drives the cost and timelines so high/long).
- beej71 3y agoAnd it's the NIMBYs that kill it.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe last US nuclear renaissance wasn't killed by NIMBYs. The plants had plenty of local support. It didn't help.
- derriz 3y agoHave you specific examples? The biggest failures associated with the last nuclear “Renaissance” were project/budget failures - e.g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nukegate_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nukegate_scandal - same in Europe where the “new generation” ERP has been a budgetary and timeline disaster.
- flatline 3y agoThe US still does a ton of nuclear energy and weapons research. Policy is generally made by the people doing the actual work - who influence politicians - than by the politicians themselves. We live in a high technology society, and make a lot of policy based on scientific R&D. There is plenty of populist rhetoric, but aside from that the Western world is largely run by scientists and technologists, for better or worse. Nuclear power will never not be on the table as long as humans have nuclear capabilities.
- fakedang 3y ago> There is plenty of populist rhetoric, but aside from that the Western world is largely run by scientists and technologists, for better or worse. Germany says hi
- lordofgibbons 3y ago>There is plenty of populist rhetoric, but aside from that the Western world is largely run by scientists and technologists Lobbyists and campaign donors who donate 10s of millions of dollars would strongly disagree.
- ftl64 3y agoHistory, forgotten. Chernobyl happened just 37 years ago. RBMK had a flawed design, this could've only happened in a corrupt socialist country, you might've said, but then we got Fukushima 25 years later. Now you might say that the new generation reactors will never misbehave in such a way, that we've learned from these mistakes, but accidents happen, negligence and corruption happens, wars and terrorist attacks happen, and any reactor, if mishandled, has a potential to irradiate half a planet. I'm familiar with both sides of the debate and am not strictly against new nuclear power plants, but you comment is a microcosm of what I think is wrong with the pro-nuclear side of the debate. We do have a history of devastating accidents and close calls, so why dismiss our concerns as those of loud extremists?
- brucethemoose2 3y agoI think this is a valid, serious concern, and I was thinking more of the unreasonable nuclear pollution/waste fear and the "why bother" pro fossil fuel attitude. But when it comes down to it, I think the metdown risk is worth modest investment in new and existing reactors, in reasonable locations, using low risk designs. The scenario where the world leans too heavily into fission seems impossible.
- Moldoteck 3y agoOk please state total nr of people that died bc of nuclear plants disasters(direct and radiation) After that, pls state total people that died bc of fossils pollution+ disasters+ radiation from coal Pls also total nr of people that died bc of hydro disasters(we can add those to solar and wind since hydro is used as backup for them by storing excess) Not debating, just interesting how numbers differ in context of you mentioning chernobyl and fokushima, world should already have stats
- stkdump 3y agoI don't know. The US has the biggest public support for nuclear power amoung all western nations and even amoung the world is close to top. Also a lot of public figures that are vocal advocates of nuclear power are Americans. The most powerful group of voters (due to the two party system), the independents, favor more investment in nuclear power. So I don't see this at all.
- DarkNova6 3y agoNot a single word on bureaucracy… the single driving cost issue is the lack of industry of scale and vastly different regulations in each state. Learning how to do nuclear means learning how the french did it in the 70s. You need knowledge sharing and expertise in the construction of these things to achieve nuclear within time and budget. The first reactor is always going to be a colossal failure because, but essential to know where the problems are. But with so many nuclear startups I fear all investment will be dispersed into a range of different approaches, none of which will achieve what is promised. This will be the final nail in the coffin for western nuclear.
- logifail 3y ago> the single driving cost issue is the lack of industry of scale Except for the 2020 MIT study[0] which showed that "contrary to expectations, building subsequent plants based on an existing design actually costs more, not less, than building the initial plant" https://news.mit.edu/2020/reasons-nuclear-overruns-1118 https://news.mit.edu/2020/reasons-nuclear-overruns-1118
- rowanG077 3y agoPretty disingenuous leaving out the reason why: "Many of the excess costs were associated with delays caused by the need to make last-minute design changes based on particular conditions at the construction site or other local circumstances, so if more components of the plant, or even the entire plant, could be built offsite under controlled factory conditions, such extra costs could be substantially cut." In fact, later in the article an expert says that is happening precisely because the US does not have much expertise in this area that leads to exorbitant costs. Precisely what OP is saying.
- Krasnol 3y ago...and there is France with a lot of experience. Never stopped building and still producing huge over budget and overdue failures.
- PaywallBuster 3y agoNot really a renaissance > 6bn fund to help keep existing plants running > [law] made nuclear power eligible for the same tax credits as renewables like wind and solar And the small/modular nuclear projects seem to be going the same way as traditional reactors > NuScale, a startup building a small modular reactor on inl’s campus, recently said the cost of its project would surge by 75%, to $9.3bn
- pfdietz 3y agoI think it's mostly to keep existing reactors operating. Which is not that far from reasonable, given that solar/wind get some level of production subsidies. A CO2 tax and no renewable or nuclear subsidy would be better, but that's not politically possible.
- NPC82 3y agoOn top of the problems outlined in the article... I don't understand how people in my state of California can sit easy with this concept knowing what happened to Japan/Fukashima just over a decade ago. What is the thinking that we can run a nuclear power plant on a major fault line (eg:Diablo Canyon) any better than the Japanese (corrupt company or not - in commercial energy business I take this as a given - à la ENRON). We have wasted real estate on top of people's roofs we can safely cover with solar and wasted energy going to empty parking lots (buildings, offices, etc.). Why not work on the workable rather than throwing nuclear at the problems? Is this really the quickest and most logical action to take? I ask these questions in earnest, I am not being paid by an oil company...
- midoridensha 3y agoThe entire state of California is not on a fault line. Surely there's some seismically-stable places in the state where such plants could be built. I agree, America has no business building a nuclear plant anywhere near a fault line. But America isn't like Japan: there's tons of safe places within American territory where there's almost no risk of significant earthquakes. The same isn't true in Japan.
- NPC82 3y agoI am referencing specifically Diablo canyon since it was mentioned in the article, but a lot of energy plants need huge water sources. This is either for emergency procedures or efficiency which makes them attractive to build pretty much anywhere there's ocean or water - which happens to be where most fault lines are in California.
- midoridensha 3y agoOk, but (layman here) my understanding is that nuclear plants don't need water; they can use cooling towers instead. I think America's largest plant, for instance, is in the Arizona desert (Palo Verde).
- 3y ago
- bruce511 3y agoI'm a fan of nuclear, and based on proximity [1] the power I get is nuclear. But the chances of the US, or practically anywhere really, building substantial new nuclear facilities is close to zero. Wind and solar are plentiful, cheap , quick to build, and offer immediate returns. If i have a few billion to invest I'd pick one of these over nuclear. Basically wind and solar don't rely on foreign countries for fuel, are simple to run maintain, replace etc. In the case of wind land use is minimal. Solar can be deployed in already-urban environments. Environmental damage from catastrophic failure is basically zero. Of course there is the storage problem, but there are various potential solutions to that. Pumped hydro, compressed air, hydrogen production, and others. I expect more innovation in this space. Don't get me wrong, nuclear is safe, clean(ish), and provides a good base load. But regulation, planning, costs, and all the other layers make actual building of them very unattractive. I'm not confident they'll ever see the light of day. [1] yeah, I know that's not how it works.
- devjab 3y agoI’m not a fan of nuclear power. I do work in an investment bank that’s currently on the top 10 of organisations for building the most solar plants in Europe, so there is that disclaimer. That’s not why I’m against nuclear power though, I’m against it because of the risk, but I’m not sure that is an issue in a country as large as the US. Depending of course on where you build the plants. If we build one in Denmark, and it went wrong, then our entire country could end up uninhabitable. And I know the plants are very safe, but look at what’s going on in the Ukraine, or how Russia blew up the gas lines recently. Again something that is probably less of an issue within the USA. So I think countries like the US should probably do a nuclear renaissance, while other countries should stick with renewables. I wouldn’t worry so much about the storage issue. We currently build and deploy batteries that are inside shipping containers, effectively solving our storage issues. It should be noted that “our” storage issues aren’t the same as the grids issues, ours is intended to be able to store excess power. Basically you cannot sell power when the grid is full, and currently that means solar plants dump it into nothing. The batteries allow us to store it for months. Of course we also use it to sell power at better prices, but I did say we were an investment bank. Battery tech is only going to improve. It’s sort of ironic that Tesla was so early with some of the storage solutions that other companies actually build today, but sometimes it’s not a good idea to be a first mover I guess? The big push is largely funded by countries like Germany going for full renewables of course, and Tesla didn’t have that at the time.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoPrintable solar will be so cheap that every house facade will have solar put on it. We will have so much energy that we don't know what to do with it.
- xerxesaa 3y agoCan you share more details on this? It sounds a bit overly optimistic, but I admittedly don't have a lot of experience in this space. If you have some links to news articles or publications talking about progress and cost, I'd love to read them.
- jaggederest 3y agohttps://energy.mit.edu/news/solar-cells-printed-on-paper/ https://energy.mit.edu/news/solar-cells-printed-on-paper/ https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/photovoltaics/printable-solar-cells https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/pho... Seems like cool stuff. Photolithography is very expensive compared to offset printing, so it would be interesting to see low-efficiency but very low cost solar modules using processes more like offset press.
- jaggederest 3y agoI think even today, most places in the US would be better off building solar than nuclear. The opportunity cost alone makes it nonsensical. We're very close to the point where solar + battery quickly and easily replaces the majority of new electrical generation. I live in a place where solar is not even especially viable and it's starting to make economic sense even here. Given the timelines involved in building a nuclear plant, you're better off saving your money for 8 years and then spending 2 years building a solar plant with current tech - prices will drop significantly over the 8 years, so nuclear compares even less favorably.
- ImPleadThe5th 3y agoI don't understand why we couldn't do both?
- pfdietz 3y agoThe last Nuclear Renaissance in the US turned out spectacularly badly. I don't see this one going anywhere.
- epistasis 3y agoThe key failure seems to be a lack of attention to technical details and costs. There are big PR pushes, trying to convince people that nuclear is back as if it's a political problem or people just need to have good vibes. But in reality it's all a massive construction project, and the best vibes in the world are no substitute for a dedicated team of highly skilled planners with deep knowledge who don't put up with any bullshit. That dedicated team is what nuclear has been missing, not the rah-rah bystanders cheering from the sidelines. Yet I never see much effort out into the actual management of these projects...
- Lammy 3y agoIMO “nuclear power” itself is a scare term. Let’s call it an atomic energy renaissance instead!
- Eisenstein 3y ago"Mass to energy transfer systems".
- pfdietz 3y agoI'll call them "Tinkerbell energy systems". After all, the nuke bros tell us we just have to believe in it.
- epistasis 3y ago> A recent report from the doe suggests that America could triple its nuclear-power generation, to 300 gigawatts, by 2050 I need to see this report because as phrased it comes across as a joke. Which is not unexpected from the DOE, which has shown not so great ability to predict the future. But still... Assuming we start in 2030, the first time we expect a new SMR to hit the grid (and quite optimistically), we need to build an additional 100GW to replace retiring current nuclear for a total of 400GW between 2030 and 2050, or 20GW/year. At 10 years per GW of construction, that's 200GW of sites under construction at any given moment. These numbers are simply not plausible. We will be adding 100GW/year of new solar car before 2030, at current rates of increase. That's about 20-25GW/year when corrected for capacity factor. Given the extreme disadvantage that nuclear has on price, the DOE estimating 20 GW/year of new nuclear has to be from someone with rose colored glasses and no concept of pricing or economics.
- anonu 3y agoLots of people in this thread talking about how nuclear is not necessary given the rise of renewable sources. But one thing that is not mentioned is x-axis... time. Nuclear is the only clean option we have today to drop our dependance on fossil fuels in the big way necessary to avoid 1.5 or 2 degree average global temperature increases.
- epistasis 3y agoOnce your consider the x-axis of time, I think it's clear that nuclear will not help us decarbonise, or at best will be a bit player. If nuclear becomes useful, it will likely be after we have already solved carbon-free energy systems, and come into play only because it has somehow become cheaper than other terrestrial methods of electricity generation, storage, and distribution.
- andrewinardeer 3y agoThe cost of building reactors is far dwarfed by the cost on the environment and economies over time.
- epistasis 3y agoI don't think there's a super large environmental cost from nuclear reactors... it is an awful lot of steel and concrete. But amortized over typical lifecycles it's not much emissions, even if we don't yet have ways to zero out those steel and carbon emissions. As for "economies" I can't quite understand what you mean by that.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoExcept we don't have that nuclear capability and it takes decades to build lots of new nuclear capability during which current projections indicate we'll instead deploy lots of wind, solar, and storage, outstripping any new nuclear capability by an order of magnitude or so. The reality is that most projections (even the pessimistic ones) get us to net zero around 2050-2060. Most of that is driven by renewables. I'm actually hopeful that more optimistic scenarios are possible because of continued improvements in cost of renewables and storage which would enable faster rollout for less investment than currently projected. If people find a way to drop the cost of nuclear by an order of magnitude to finally deliver on its potential, I'm all for it. Great stuff otherwise but it's just too expensive currently. In short, I don't see that happening any time soon. We might actually get fusion before that happens. And we shouldn't be betting on that either. It might happen, it might not happen. Either way, we need to get rid of fossil fuels. Right now wind, solar, and batteries are looking pretty good in terms of mass production and deployment of new capability. There's a gap with nuclear and it's widening rapidly. Most of that is cost driven. It's just a lot cheaper/faster/better/less risky/etc.
- DiscourseFan 3y agoI'm not an expert on these things, but Nuclear has its uses and there are places where Solar/Wind doesn't make sense and we will need to fill in the energy gaps with something cleaner than coal and natural gas. I just don't think giant batteries that have to be serviced every so often is a viable solution for places that don't get a lot of sun year round.
- pfdietz 3y agoWell, you can check that belief against evidence at this site: https://model.energy/ https://model.energy/ Surprisingly, at very high latitudes there's a ginormous amount of wind. Also, using batteries as the only storage modality is Dumb Engineering. (Polar regions are not a good use case for nuclear anyway, due to almost total lack of people. The largest grid in Alaska has an average power flow of just 600 MW, btw, and Alaska is highly populated compared to, say, the nothern provinces of Canada.)
- woodpanel 3y agoResiding in Germany, the country with one of the world’s most expensive kWhs I urge you Americans: Milk this Overton Window as much as you can because the Luddites will be back.
- locallost 3y agoElectricity itself is cheaper in Germany than e.g. in nuclear France, especially now. The difference is that most of the actual costs in Germany are on the utility bill, whereas in France the EDF made a 20 billion loss last year and it only exists still because it's state owned. But the true costs will be paid, likely through taxes. Around 300 Euros per capita will be paid to plug the hole for last year alone. My family of four would thus pay around 1200 Euros in taxes just to make up for that loss, which is almost two years of "expensive" German electricity we actually spend. So what is expensive again? What is unfortunately not on the bill in Germany is the price of nuclear waste storage. The producers of nuclear power paid a fraction of the actual costs (that could end up at over 100 billion) to rid themselves of the responsibility. If it was on the bill where it belongs, that would really kill nuclear forever.
- pyrale 3y ago> whereas in France the EDF made a 20 billion loss last year and it only exists still because it's state owned. EDF made a 18 billions loss in 2022 mostly because of government decisions. Welcome to French state-owned companies, the government giveth, and the government taketh away. This doesn't happen to German electricity companies. > My family of four would thus pay around 1200 Euros in taxes just to make up for that loss, which is almost two years of "expensive" German electricity we actually spend. Your family of four spends €50 per month on electricity? You're heating and cooking with gas right?
- locallost 3y agoIf the government giveth and then taketh away, those are just two sides of the same coin. Electricity providers in Germany can go bust at any time, and that's fine, there are hundreds of them. Our electricity bill is currently 60 a month (used to be 50), and we usually get a tiny bit paid back. Heating (warm water in general) is gas, but everything else is electric including cooking which we do daily. There was a price cap of 40c per kWh (or something like that) introduced recently, but other than that it's "what you pay for is what you get". A transparent system where you have the true price stimulates energy efficiency. People that want to waste energy are free to do so, but should not have the rest subsidize the behavior. There are dozens of tiny things that you can do every day that have no effect on your life, yet save a lot of energy and money: avoiding being straight up wasteful, e.g. leaving things on for no reason; paying attention to energy efficiency of the devices you buy and run; paying attention to what you do, e.g. when you boil an egg, put a lid on, boil the water and switch it off, it will keep boiling until it's ready since the stove is hot (this becomes mostly irrelevant with induction). On a level beyond that, is your fridge normal sized, or does it store food for three weeks, that you then buy with you gigantic car in a huge shop 15km away (and the shop is there because the land is cheaper, and the energy spent on having that system work is massively subsizidized). Etc. etc. A lot of things you think are tiny, but as a whole end up being significant. We spent a few months abroad a couple years ago, and there you'd get a note on your bill comparing your consumption to the same month the year before. We were routinely at 50% of the previous tenants.
- CrampusDestrus 3y agoWe have the means to assure energy abundance for the entire world, which would trickle down into all sorts of other abundances, and yet we cannot stop the nuclear boogeyman.
- fwlr 3y agoGiving nuclear power access to the same clean energy subsidies as solar/wind seems like common sense policy that all sides can agree on, at the very least. Safety regulations are extraordinarily robust one-way ratchets so the price of nuclear power will probably be forever burdened by excessive regulation*, which is unfortunate. I do believe if nuclear power is pursued it will quickly benefit from many of the economies of scale and technological advancements that have been seen renewable power, especially solar - although whether this will be enough to counter-balance safety regulation costs is unclear, leaning towards pessimistic. Unfortunately, the strongest argument against nuclear power is simply that its time has passed. The ‘window’ for nuclear power opened in the 1960s, and it closes forever when battery technology gets good enough to cover baseload/offpeak requirements using stored solar power. If we assume that’s 20 years away, we can conclude that nuclear power has squandered three quarters of its ‘window’ (this is a more conservative estimate than you might think - recently the entire state of South Australia has posted several seven- and ten-day runs of solar and wind providing 100% of power needs, partly due to hundreds of megawatts of large battery storage). On the topic of Australia, incidentally, one of my hobby horses is for Australia to become a ‘nuclear fuel superpower’ country. It is estimated that we have almost a quarter of the planet’s total uranium deposits, and we have a significant mining industry capable of extracting it, even after its decline from its former vibrancy. All we are really missing is a significant nuclear fuel processing industry, we instead simply export mined nuclear ore. We will probably never be a nuclear power superpower (nuclear power plants are banned in every state and territory), but it is still quite practical for us to become an ethical and trusted supplier of nuclear fuel to first-world countries pursuing nuclear power, relieving them of their dependency on Russian nuclear fuel. *: It is possible to perform low-touch retrofitting of most (base load) coal power plants by simply replacing their coal-burning heat source with a nuclear heat source, leaving every other part of the power generation and transmission infrastructure in place. The plant would produce the same power output, but cut emissions by ~100%. However if you did do this, the retrofitted plant would immediately be forced to close, because the radiation levels from prior years of coal-burning pollution would already exceed some regulated standards for nuclear power plants. I have seen estimates that living in the shadow of a coal plant is roughly 0.1 mSv while living in the shadow of a nuclear plant is roughly 0.02 mSv - both well below the 1 mSv exposure limit, which is in turn well below the total radiation load of ~3 mSv natural background and ~3 mSv manmade radiation experienced by an average US citizen in an average year.
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoToo late, renewables have already reached parity output with nonrenewable options in some jurisdictions. And wind/solar has proven its cheaper/cleaner than digging Coal. Nuclear fission facilities are a subsidized loss-leader 1950's technology. 1. No one wants the waste, and every dump has leaked (erasing these off google maps doesn't unpin the Geiger-counter net downstream) 2. No one wants to live near Reactor facilities cooling ponds 3. micro-reactors and the like... are fools errands that ignore the costly reality of securing the life-cycle of these facilities. 4. A $7B Fission facility could also equip every home on a distributed infrastructure in Texas 7 times over. Many homeowners are getting non-subsidized solar themselves, as they realize they will end up paying for the same boondoggle centralized projects. The AstroTurf and scientific hubris is not enough to pass off this technology as sensible. Nuclear power only makes sense for deep space probes, the north pole, or a large submarine. Have a wonderful day =)
- foverzar 3y agoAnd it is decades away from its competitors like China or (especially) Russia. The problem with nuclear industry is that there isn't some single key piece of tech - you need shit load of expensive nuclear infrastructure, different recycling plants and different types of reactors running various nuclear materials at different stages of their lifecycles for years - if you want to have anything resembling a closed loop, without dumping tons radioactive materials you have no idea how to deal with. I wonder how the US is going to fast-track this kind of work involving extremely hazardous materials. I see that the topic of "spent fuel" is still a distant mysterious benchmark, since the US can't even supply itself with nuclear fuel without buying from evil incompetent Russia.
- credit_guy 3y agoI love nuclear. And I think nuclear power has a good shot at a renaissance. But I think nuclear has a problem internationally. Proliferation. I once heard personally the former defense secretary Robert Gates that if Japan wants to build a bomb, they could do it in a matter of weeks. Online I heard numerous times people agreeing with this assessment, and adding South Korea too. One might say that Japan and South Korea are the "good guys", what's the problem? The problem is of course that you can't guarantee how long good guys remain good guys. And that there is nothing special about South Korea and Japan, basically any country that has a few nuclear power plants can at some point acquire whatever know-how Japan and South Korea have. How comfortable would you go to sleep at night if Turkey had nukes? What if there is an Islamic revolution in the United Arab Emirates and ISIS takes possession of 4 GigaWatt scale reactors?
- pfdietz 3y agoJapan had a fast reactor program. To fuel that fast reactor, they had spent fuel from their reactors reprocessed (in Europe) and the plutonium separated. They have a stockpile of tonnes of reactor grade Pu (which, contrary to assertions, can be used in weapons, particularly if you have access to tritium for boosting, which they do.) Japan's fast reactor program has enabled them to do a kind of deniable proliferation, stockpiling enough Pu for ~1000 bombs, without actually building the bombs yet. Smart of them; it's an insurance policy against China in case the US nuclear umbrella were to suddenly disappear. To power the world with nuclear needs breeders, so Pu separation will likely be everywhere. And the Pu obtained from the blanket of a fast breeder is even purer 239Pu than so-called "weapons grade".
- credit_guy 3y agoIn the end it does not matter how Japan acquired the ability to build the bomb. I just searched wikipedia, and it appears this ability is widely known and acknowledged. It even has a name: nuclear latency [1], the ability of a state to develop a nuke on a short notice, also known as the "Japan option". Wikipedia lists that these countries have this ability: Japan, Canada, Australia, Germany, The Netherlands, South Korea, Taiwan. All these countries want to have friendly relations with the US, so presumably they would not build a nuke without first asking for permission. But if these relations were to go sour then we'd see a few new nuclear states. Just today there was discussion here on Hacker News about Sweden pursuing more nuclear power towards its goal to decarbonize. Sweden is not a NATO member yet. Could they one day decide that a few nukes could be the best insurance against Russian aggression? Finland is a new NATO member, just like Poland. Both share an uncomfortably long border with Russia. Both have numerous nuclear power plants. Will they one day seek nukes? Or at least seek to acquire "the Japan option"? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_latency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_latency