4 ms·
What is the context here? If the chart is correct, why did deer disappear almost entirely around 1900, what led to the almost complete rebound by 1950, and why
by crazygringo 3y ago
What is the context here?
If the chart is correct, why did deer disappear almost entirely around 1900, what led to the almost complete rebound by 1950, and why the recent downtick?
- tptacek 3y agoMassive population expansion in the US coupled with a lack of any real regulation modulating the harvest of deer; both deer hide and venison were mainstream commodity products in the 1900s and are specialty products today. Their populations are now managed pretty carefully, but, just as importantly, their natural predators weren't really husbanded back into their ranges, so, in many places, their only real predator now is car bumpers.
- mpsprd 3y agoIn Canada, the leading cause of death for deer is actually hunger/hardness of the winter. source: My hunting license class 5 years ago
- Kon-Peki 3y agoAccording to the chart, white-tail deer populations started to crash between 1700 and 1750, and then all deer populations fell further starting around 1850 and hitting bottom near 1900. But really, only white-tail deer populations have recovered since then, with the “other” group crashing again to all-time lows. Odd
- analog31 3y agoThe downtick could be chronic wasting disease.
- tptacek 3y agoDeep population dynamics seem to be pretty well studied, and what I'm reading is that this is mostly attributed to land use issues?
- maxerickson 3y agoThe number of permits issued is probably the single largest factor. States manage the herd size up to encourage hunting (which brings in hunting tourism, and to some extent, license revenues). Start issuing more permits and you get less deer.
- mikedamav90 3y agoOr how about why data stops at 2016? What’s currently the status of the deers in 2023? Climate change is clearly having an impact on our whole ecosystem.
- time0ut 3y agoI’ve seen a shift in deer management in my state over the past decade or so. Archery season has been extended, the number of anterless tags increased, and this year, any resident that wants one can have one - no more lottery. I am no expert, but I assumed it to be in response to their population. I only ever harvest one as that is plenty of venison for me, but the population could certainly sustain more.
- berkle4455 3y agoThey were hunted the brink of extinction just like bison.
- javman 3y agoPopulation tanked around 1900 due to no regulations and massive human population moving west and everyone shooting deer on the way. Conservation movements (mostly by sportsmen AKA hunters) led to regulations (each state now has a wildlife or game department to set hunting seasons) and a shift away from harvesting anything to mostly just harvesting bucks during short seasons. Recent downward trend is due to several things: 1. Loss of habitat due to humans. Mule deer are known to migrate hundreds of miles, and there are a lot of highways to cross. Winter habitat is being paved over for human progress. (Cool video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIAyb-1uwTg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIAyb-1uwTg) 2. Chronic wasting disease is an issue in wild mule deer populations with no cure (similar to mad cow disease) 3. Harsh winters can take a toll and really slow any chance of mule deer population growth. Certain places in Wyoming this year had 100% fawn mortality (every deer less than a year old died due to the harsh winter, see: https://www.wyomingnews.com/rocketminer/news/state/what-s-in-store-for-the-devastated-wyoming-range-deer-herd/article_683dcd66-0937-11ee-9d68-435ff4cfbeab.html https://www.wyomingnews.com/rocketminer/news/state/what-s-in...). 4. The internet has enabled a lot of out-of-state hunting, by making it easier to find places to hunt (Google Earth, OnX, etc.), learn how to hunt better, and understand the regulations, so there are more hunters on the landscape with better technology. States manage for this and limit the number of hunters and shorten seasons. 5. Predator re-introduction/recovery as well as many states that have banned certain types of predator hunting. This can be a touchy subject among hunters. A lot of people are okay with deer and elk being hunted but not wolves, cougars or bears. I've been deer hunting for 30 years. My experience is with mule deer and black-tailed deer on the west coast and Rockies. Not much whitetail experience, but I do know that whitetail deer in the east and south don't have as many predators and do well in agricultural landscapes. They can have two or three fawns each year so their population can grow quickly. Mule deer inhabit harsher landscapes (mountainous terrain mostly).
- mhardcastle 3y agoRegarding (1), for blacktails I'd add meadow encroachment. Parts of their range have sees a sizeable portion of the meadows where they browse taken over by conifers and shrubs. These were kept in-check by fires pre-1500.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]