3 ms·
Fediverse: We want adoption in the Fediverse. Meta: Sure. Let's get 2B into the Fediverse with Instagram Threads. Fediverse: No! Not that sort of adoption! Bl
by rvz 3y ago
Fediverse: We want adoption in the Fediverse.
Meta: Sure. Let's get 2B into the Fediverse with Instagram Threads.
Fediverse: No! Not that sort of adoption! Block Meta from the Fediverse now!
As expected and predicted in [0]: 'Instagram's success on ActivityPub is also Mastodon's nightmare and it tends to more centralization.'
Looks like Threads is going to be the biggest Mastodon-compatible network on the Fediverse and the other admins of larger instances who signed those NDAs won't block them anyway, with the smaller ones making themselves irrelevant if they do.
Meta once again is winning.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36012434 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36012434
- SamWhited 3y agoYou're right, we don't want that sort of adoption! We want slow, paced, organic growth. Users should join the fediverse because they want to be there, not because a giant corporation cut their accounts over to a new service that supports some random thing they've never heard of and don't understand. The culture clash that will result from Facebooks decision could be devastating, so naturally people are pushing back against that kind of adoption. > with the smaller ones making themselves irrelevant if they do I don't think this is true. The fediverse started out as a way to specifically have small services where users (mostly trans and queer users early on) wouldn't be harassed all day. "Irrelevant" only makes sense if you're thinking from the perspective of "get as many users as possible", but the fediverse isn't really about that. Small servers of marginalized people talking in private spaces where no one is harassing them is still extremely relevant.
- nobody9999 3y ago>...with the smaller ones making themselves irrelevant if they do. Irrelevant to who and/or what? I'd expect that most instances aren't interested in the stuff going on over on Meta's services, most likely because they're on the fediverse to get away from them. What's more, not every site wants to monetize their users or maximize engagement. Rather, they aim to be a community. If your[0] goal is to "increase your reach" to improve your economic prospects, then small instances will likely be irrelevant -- to you. If that's your goal, I don't want you on my AP instance anyway. There's way too much of that elsewhere. [0] That's a general "you," not rvz specifically.
- praisewhitey 3y ago>This 'ActivityPub' interoperability also happened with Gab, which became the largest Mastodon instance at one point and then almost all instances de-federated with it. wasn't this Pawoo.net? I remember Gab switching to mastodon but they weren't really big, unlike Pawoo which was by far the biggest instance at one time.