3 ms·
I am curious how reliable that air quality data is in the first place. I cannot find anything about Breezometer having invested in installing air quality meter
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
I am curious how reliable that air quality data is in the first place. I cannot find anything about Breezometer having invested in installing air quality meters all around the world.
https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/sycbrdpbi https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/sycbrdpbi
This article says they are using “machine learning” and “AI”. Makes me think it is all fake.
https://www.breezometer.com/pdfs/Ultimate-Guide-to-BreezoMeter_s-Air-Quality-Technology.pdf https://www.breezometer.com/pdfs/Ultimate-Guide-to-BreezoMet...
Their own documentation indicates the air quality measures they provide are just guesses based on their models. Page 4 basically says actually measuring particulates in the air is very costly, and so their solution is to come up with models to predict what it might be.
- pnpnp 3y agoYes - it’s much like now weather forecasting works. Data points may come from 2 places 100 mi apart, but what if someone lives between them? Temperature or other weather data is often an extrapolation based on official weather data collection points, and AQI data is no different. How that data gets extrapolated varies wildly by implementation. edit: Also a fun fact, I live 2000ft above and 50mi from the nearest forecasting center in a valley. “Weather apps” are about as accurate as throwing darts at a board up here, because the models used to extrapolate known data completely fall apart with all the variables. Our best source of data is the “short term weather discussion” by NOAA, which just gives some generalizations based on local weather knowledge.
- aziaziazi 3y agoTwo differences between weather and AQI forecast: - AQI strongly varies with local human activities, e.g. a coal power plant in between the 2 places 100 miles appart. - temporal and hardly predictable human activities, e.g. a chem industry without good attenuation system that boost its production to fill a special command. Or an attenuation system that breaks.
- crazygringo 3y agoNot just forecasting, but reporting values right now. Spatial interpolation is much more non-obvious than you might initially assume, when the data points are coming from arbitrary locations and not a regular grid. For anyone curious, here [1] is a good place to start, or look up "Kriging interpolation". The basic implementation of any kind of continuous temperature estimation is to have a generic equation that relates how temperature naturally varies by altitude, use that normalize the temperature reported by weather stations according to altitude to create a "flat" temperature map, interpolate to create a smooth continuous temperature map using something like Kriging, and then de-normalize the temperature at a desired point according to the altitude of that location. There are always going to be hyper-local variations that won't account for (are you on the sunny side or shaded side of a mountain? is there an air current? how is vegetation/buildings/asphalt affecting it?), but it's the basic starting point. [1] https://geobgu.xyz/r-2020/spatial-interpolation-of-point-data.html https://geobgu.xyz/r-2020/spatial-interpolation-of-point-dat...
- counters 3y agoEh, kriging is overkill relative to the skill you end up with since fine-grain spatial variability in weather can arise from a lot more than the static factors you can pull into such a scheme. This is why objective analysis techniques are typically preferred. More importantly, high-resolution priors are universally available from weather models, so there is no need to just to ever naively interpolate between weather observation stations very far apart. One of the reasons that consumer weather apps perform poorly is because in many cases, the companies producing them arbitrarily choose some sort of spatial or temporal resolution requirements, and then throw the problem to an engineer or data scientist who probably doesn't know much more than these simple interpolation techniques (and I absolutely lump kriging into the 'simple' category these days). A modicum of domain knowledge applied here produces a much better product with substantially less effort.
- crazygringo 3y agoI'm curious if you could expand -- I researched this a while ago but what I'm describing is as deep as I got from various online tutorials. What kind of objective analysis techniques? And where does someone get high-resolution priors from? Are you saying that companies have gone out and done a one-time mapping of temperature etc. at a e.g. 1-mile grid across the US? (Which would be over 3 million points at that scale, compared to the ~10,000 US weather stations?)