3 ms·
The product is valuable because of the thousands of small decisions you made as you were developing the product. The source code is just the manifestation of th
by gruseom 18y ago
The product is valuable because of the thousands of small decisions you made as you were developing the product. The source code is just the manifestation of those decisions. In other words, the product is valuable because of its design, not because of the source code that describes that design. Just because someone has access to a product's source code doesn't mean they can make valuable decisions about it.
That's the key insight of Peter Naur's classic article "Programming as Theory Building". (That's Naur as in BNF.) He starts with the question: why is it that code, even well-written code and even well-documented code (rare as that is) isn't sufficient to allow a new team to effectively take over development of a system? His answer: the program is not the source code, but rather a shared mental construct (he says "theory", you said "design") that lives in the minds of the people who made it. Source code is a textual representation of that construct, but it's a lossy one. So if you lose all the original people, it's hard to reconstruct the program.
Edit: I posted the article to YC ages ago but that link is broken. You can get it here: http://web.archive.org/web/20080209152318/http://www.zafar.se/bkz/Articles/NaurProgrammingTheory http://web.archive.org/web/20080209152318/http://www.zafar.s...
- aaronblohowiak 18y agoFascinating! Thanks for making the connection.