3 ms·
> In the United States, the government holds hundreds of millions of acres of land in trust... True. > ... and it needs to be relinquished in part to help gro
by AnimalMuppet 3y ago
> In the United States, the government holds hundreds of millions of acres of land in trust...
True.
> ... and it needs to be relinquished in part to help grow the actual base of humanity they hold stewardship over
Almost entirely false. See, the land they hold, they hold because nobody ever claimed it under the Homestead Act. Nobody could figure out how to grow enough to feed a family, even with 168 acres of it. This mostly means that there's no water there.
I'm pretty sure that the solution to the housing crisis is not a few square miles of waterless sagebrush in private hands. If you build a city there, where are the people in it going to work? (If they're currently homeless, they're probably not going to get hired for the kinds of jobs where work from home is possible.) How is it going to integrate into the surrounding economy? Where is the food going to come from? Where are the roads for the food going to come from? Where are the power and the water going to come from?
And even if that is the answer... what private hands? Mine? I don't have the money to develop it. Blackrock's? The banks? I don't think you're going to think that approach is the answer, either.
(True, some of that land is forest rather than just sagebrush. But if the federal government sells it, it will be bought by someone wanting to log it flat for the timber. That won't leave it with cities on it, either.)
- NegativeK 3y agoI live in a state where the federal government owns a lot of that land that nobody could figure out. The feds still try to sell it. Nobody buys it, because it's _still_ useless. It's a bad investment to buy shriveled land, build a residence on it that's incredibly far from basic necessities like gasoline and food, and then pay money to have water trucked out to your remote ass.
- jcranmer 3y agoWikipedia has a map of the ownership of federal lands here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_federal_land.agencies.svg--basically https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_federal_land.agen..., the yellow lands are the lands never sold and largely represent the stock of available federal land. The green lands are parks and US forest (which is often, but not always, parkland as well in some sense); the red isn't the federal government's, it's Indian; and the other land is owned by agencies for their own purposes (most notably the military, and the resale value of former weapons testing ranges isn't great). As you say, a lot of that yellow land is basically desert or semidesert and uninhabitable. Although that understands the nature of the problem, since the US did manage to sell off a large swathe of uninhabitable land--the High Plains was sold off in the late 19th century, only for the Dust Bowl to happen and people to realize that in fact, no, this wasn't good farmland.
- kdmccormick 3y agofixed link [1] [1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_federal_land.agencies.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_federal_land.agen...