7 ms·
BrowserBox Pro goes open-source
- keepamovin 3y agoRelevant hash link: https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro#for-open-source-use https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro#for-open-source-use
- Naac 3y agoThe title should be changed as it is not "open source" as is used when talking about software licenses, or as defined by the OSI [0] [0] https://opensource.org/osd/ https://opensource.org/osd/
- CuriousCosmic 3y agoFrom the git repo. For open-source use: If you are creating an open source application under a license compatible with the GNU GPL license v3, you may use BrowserBox Pro under the terms of the GPLv3. For non-commercial use: You can use BrowserBox Pro for free for non-commercial use cases. This means government and public institutions, non-profits, private researchers and individuals are covered by this protection when their use is done without any anticipation of commercial application. This is provided under the terms of the Polyform Non-Commercial License 1.0. From time to time, our non-commercial users may desire an license arrangement different to the one provided by the standard Polyform Non-Commercial License 1.0 to suit their needs both now and in future, and such terms may be approved and negotiated on a case-by-case basis typically for a fee or other remunerative or protective arrangement. It's licensed under multiple licenses, one of which is the GPLv3 which is not only open source, it's also free software. By every definition this is open source software.
- keepamovin 3y agoThanks! I know it's confusing, and I'm a little unsure about whether it's "Open Source" if like this, too. If anyone can tell me this is false, that's good as it's important to get right. But I think it's fine.
- binarycrusader 3y agoYes, this is similar to what Qt did / has done for years. I personally think it fits the definition of "open source" since it's multi-licensed.
- ignoramous 3y agoFor open-source use If you are creating an open source application under a license compatible with the GNU GPL license v3, you may use BrowserBox Pro under the terms of the GPLv3. For non-commercial use You can use BrowserBox Pro for free for non-commercial use cases. This means government and public institutions, non-profits, private researchers and individuals are covered by this protection when their use is done without any anticipation of commercial application. This is provided under the terms of the Polyform Non-Commercial License 1.0. Well, this isn't exactly dual license, but the presence of GPLv3 comprehensively nullifies Polyform, so it is FOSS. IANAL.
- CuriousCosmic 3y agoIt's better interpreted as decreasing degrees of permissivity. 1. GPLv3 or later 2. polyform non-commercial for non-commercial non-GPLv3 (or later) works. 3. commercial license for commercial non-GPLv3 (or later) works. --- In other words, Use GPLv3 however if you can't use GPLv3 but are non-commercial, use polyform non-commercial. Otherwise buy a commercial license.
- keepamovin 3y agoYes!
- ignoramous 3y agoYou may want to reword as "licensed under either GPLv3 or Polyform Non-commercial 1.0 at your option" or some such, like most rust-lang projects do; ex: https://github.com/rust-lang/rustup https://github.com/rust-lang/rustup Then give guidance on why one might choose one license over the other.
- binarycrusader 3y agoConfusingly, that's not in the "LICENSE.md" file (at the time of this post): https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro/blob/boss/LICENSE.md https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro/blob/boss/LICENSE.m... Which is showing this commit: https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro/commit/84f35db2f953236b34aa0f81f1e2fa8f5b1b1572 https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro/commit/84f35db2f953... Only in the README.md file: https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro/blob/boss/README.md https://github.com/dosyago/BrowserBoxPro/blob/boss/README.md
- keepamovin 3y agoAlright, I'll put that in the license file! :)
- RobotToaster 3y agoIs the any reason someone would choose to use it under the weird Polyform licence over the GPL?
- keepamovin 3y agoA government, non-profit or security researcher (or institute, for instance) could use it to build their own proprietary code that is not under GPL, but that uses BrowserBox Pro.
- Tomte 3y ago> By every definition this is open source software. No, it's not. "If you are creating an open source application" is a usage restriction/discrimination. That's not allowed for open source licenses. It also follows that it runs foul of GPL3's prohibition on additional restrictions. I guess it's supposed to be a user-friendly wording about using it in your own development (this is GPL code, you can link it with your GPL code). But it actually means that unless you're developing open source software, you may not use it. Not even unmodified. It's probably not what the creator means, though.
- CuriousCosmic 3y ago> "If you are creating an open source application" is a usage restriction/discrimination. That's not allowed for open source licenses. No it is not. "If you are creating an open source application you may use the software under the GPLv3 or later" means "if you want to comply with the GPLv3+, you may use it under that license". This is just licensing all the software under 3 separate licenses: 1. The GPLv3 or later with no added conditions. 2. For non-commercial, closed source use you can use it under https://polyformproject.org/licenses/noncommercial/1.0.0/ https://polyformproject.org/licenses/noncommercial/1.0.0/ 3. For commercial, closed source use you can buy a commercial license. That's fully acceptable for GPLv3 and open source licensing in general as long as the software can be licensed by you under each of those 3 licenses separately (i.e. the dependencies are all compatible with each license and all contributors have either signed over their rights or have documented agreement to the above licensing conditions). This is for the exact same reason that you can find dual GPLv3 (or AGPLv3) and closed source commercial licensed projects. It takes a bit of work on the IP management side but it's perfectly acceptable.
- Tomte 3y ago> "if you want to comply with the GPLv3+, you may use it under that license". That's what they mean, but the wording does not support that. There is no way to use it under GPL, without developing something.
- deleted 3y ago
- Pannoniae 3y agoThe OSI's definition is not like a heavenly authority. It's not a trademark, so I can call something "open source" even if I put it in the license file that you aren't allowed to use it if you are a red panda. (which is usage discrimination) What OSI says and what I am allowed to call open source are not the same things.
- vincnetas 3y agoso what are the use cases for this tool? i read and still cant understand what problems does it solve and how one would use it.
- tux1968 3y agoFound a short blurb of theirs: "BrowserBox powers multiple use-cases, including: in-app browsing, co-browsing, remote isolated browsing, easy 3rd-party embedding, and human-in-the-loop robotic RPA monitoring and interaction." Essentially, it is remote desktop for the browser, converting rendered pages into images that are transmitted to the client instead of html. The demo shows interacting with Youtube and watching a video.
- keepamovin 3y agoThanks! Definitely the README could be more clear. It's a product that sits at the nexus of a few different things. Just briefly some companies that are doing somewhat similar things (I may have missed some, there are a lot!): - Cloudflare (from S2): https://www.cloudflare.com/products/zero-trust/browser-isolation/ https://www.cloudflare.com/products/zero-trust/browser-isola... - RemoteHQ: https://www.remotehq.com/ https://www.remotehq.com/ - HyperBeam: https://hyperbeam.com/ https://hyperbeam.com/ - Ericom: https://www.ericom.com/ericom-isolation/ https://www.ericom.com/ericom-isolation/ - Symantec/Broadcom (from FireGlass): https://www.broadcom.com/products/cybersecurity/network/network-protection/web-isolation https://www.broadcom.com/products/cybersecurity/network/netw... Cybersecurity uses: - defensive cybersecurity: remote browser isolation is another layer to protect against browser zero-days from compromising your devices and network. So called "zero trust" approach of assuming compromise. - email attachment and link opening: people can open email attachments in the secure document viewer and open dodgy looking links without risking their local workstation - pentesting and malware analysis: researchers can investigate potential malware from a distance Process integration and automation: - you can embed browsers in your website in a way that circumvents iframe restrictions. This can make it easier to build dashboards and integration portals. - you can use BrowserBox Pro to attach to your running Puppeteer / Playwright or other Chrome instances and interact with them in real time. People find it useful for debugging automation issues and getting them unstuck from bot-tests and errors. It's like driving manual for a challenging stretch on your FSD! Remote work: - co-browsing as a way to collaborate: you can have multiple people interacting with a web site in real time. Userful for remote teams who need to debug an issue or discuss content and design - co-browsing as a way to socialize: some people enjoy doing watch parties and syncing up their viewing with friends - co-browsing as a way to educate: trainers use it to deliver interactive lessons and as a way to monitor and aid development skills in apps VPN and remote desktop: - people use it as a way to circumvent country specific blocking by spinning up a VM in another zone and accessing the content they want from there - people use it to access web-based apps, which in some areas have largely replaced desktop apps. It's like a lighter weight remote desktop in that case. Random and miscellaneous use cases: - honestly we're quite surprised at the way people use it sometimes. One of the first customers wanted it as a way to manage multiple online personas for their own privacy. Somehow they preferred that to having multiple local browser profiles. Currently I wouldn't say it's particularly optimized for any of these subsets. But it's a great starting point for people building any of these applications. While we have a rough idea, as shown above, now we're in the process of asking people exactly how they use it and deciding if we should narrow our focus to a particular customer set, or keep it broad, and build out multiple feature domains in parallel.
- jameszog 3y agoSo, could this be useful for situations where users have old devices which struggle or cannot get up to date browsers- could they use this option to view the future web? I see so many tablets and laptops which would love to be able to browse the web but fail.
- keepamovin 3y agoYes! Actually we added a Flash integration for a similar use case (via Ruffle). Specifically to your question: people have used it from their old iPhone 4 to connect to a remote copy of the latest Chrome, for instance.
- andrewstuart 3y agoThis is the sort of thing I’d invent. More a hobby than a business. Technically cool, you can make up some use cases if you try hard enough. No real compelling purpose though. I’ve spent many years building useless stuff that was technically cool. A solution looking for a problem.
- keepamovin 3y agoYou’re very perceptive! That’s a great sledge (put down, for non-Aussies). I had the same fear. But thankfully our customers rescued me from that delusion! :)
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoIt's not a hobby. You just didn't market it properly. CloudFlare has the exact same product https://www.cloudflare.com/products/zero-trust/browser-isolation/ https://www.cloudflare.com/products/zero-trust/browser-isola... You need to learn to sell, and not just build.
- keepamovin 3y agoI totally agree! That's our failure: it's not that it's not a product, it's that we didn't market it properly. Thank you! :)
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoI suggest you leverage the open source nature to gain publicity, and offer a hosted cloud version. Change the licensing to a clear cut apache license and remove all the current "strings attached" usage clauses and put any "enterprise" features in a specific folder to make it obvious. Companies are more willing to pay for a hosted service, especially if you can figure out compliance like HIPAA, SOC2 etc. Another value added service is a "managed hosting" offering, where you connect to their GCP/AWS/Azure account via OAuth and deploy the (managed) instances directly on their infrastructure, billed to their own cloud account.
- kwerk 3y agoI’ve wanted a full browser on iPad forever for remote web dev. This is intriguing
- account-5 3y agoSorry but I don't get it. Not a Dev or anything so may, and likely is my ignorance, but having skimmed the GitHub and comments here I don't know what this is for still. Can someone ELI5?
- Timon3 3y agoIt's essentially a website with an interactive video stream of Chrome, a browser inside your normal browser (but not necessarily running on your PC). Like a remote desktop connection (e.g. RDP, VNC), but only for streaming a browser.
- keepamovin 3y agoGood description. This is browser isolation (aka remote browser isolation, or RBI, or "cloud-based internet isolation", or CBII), with co-browsing (i.e, multiplayer mode, in HyperBeam's excellent parlance!) and other extensions (like remote devtools) built in: it’s basically a building block for many applications. But i see i’m going to have to do a lot better with the copy! You can read more about it on our blog: https://blog.dosyago.com https://blog.dosyago.com
- keepamovin 3y agoJust wanted to thank everyone for the lovely, heart-warming, encouraging and constructive response here. Lots of great ideas and new love on the repository, and to those of you who have emailed us, thank you we are working through a large backlog so we will get back to you! :)
- MrMarkItDown 3y agoHey, this looks really cool. I'm currently making a youtube watch party site, I'm a bit confused on why someone would spend 40k on a 1 year license for browsing though.
- keepamovin 3y agoThat’s for 1000 licenses! In one pack: that should be more clear!
- MrMarkItDown 3y agoWouldn't that work out to be 400$ per user? You mentioned use cases like cyber security and this might make sense there but how does this model work for something like automation, browsing, or rdp?
- keepamovin 3y ago40,000 divided by 1,000 is 40, right. Or 3.33/seat/month. 40K is yearly, not monthly if that's where you got a bit confused.
- MrMarkItDown 3y agoAh okay my mistake. Thank you that makes sense.
- jarym 3y agoHas anyone tried this and Kasm and have thoughts on how the two compare?
- keepamovin 3y agoSorry forgot to put that link in. Yes Kasm is definitely a competitor! I think they’re good but don’t think their browser adapts to mobile displays? As in you end up, trying to look at a desktop browser if you’re on mobile. I could be wrong tho.
- deno 3y agoYou could run this locally as a step beyond security model offered by for example Qubes OS. Instead of a VM for just a browser why not a VM for every tab as well.
- keepamovin 3y agoIt’s possible. You could set it to run only 1 tab per browser, and 1 pro instance per VM.