2 ms·
I wouldn’t consider chaos, depressions, lack of food, and societal collapses as fine outcomes for humans and civilisation.
by latexr 3y ago
I wouldn’t consider chaos, depressions, lack of food, and societal collapses as fine outcomes for humans and civilisation.
- throwaway5959 3y agoWhat parent is really saying is, “it’s not going to impact me so it’s fine for humanity to suffer”
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> wouldn’t consider chaos, depressions, lack of food, and societal collapses as fine outcomes for humans and civilisation Within the (rhetorical) context of potential extinction, surviving is just fine. The intersection of folks gearing up on climate change and far-flung humanitarian outcomes is limited. The fraction of the first doing it for the second, smaller still. Recognising incentives—even unsavoury ones—is key to changing behaviour. If you are middle class or above in the rich world, or over 50, climate change is unlikely to ruin you. If you’re in the upper class in the rich world, climate change is unlikely to materially inconvenience you or your direct descendants. (You may even see opportunity.) Acting on the environment has to come from a place of stewardship and compassion. Self-interested quips per Carlin, while pithy, don’t hold. This framework explains why haughty climate activism fails; you’re trading someone’s present living standard for another’s future. Uncompensated, that will provoke backlash à la les guillettes jaunes, Canada’s trucker protest or whatever coal country is up to right now.
- latexr 3y ago> you’re trading someone’s present living standard for another’s future. People in the present are already dying from the consequences, and rich countries aren’t immune. https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20210823-deadly-flooding-in-germany-belgium-fueled-by-climate-change-study-finds https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20210823-deadly-flooding-...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago190 people in west Germany and south Belgium. Tie this directly to the trucker we're trying to convince to accept a gas tax. You can't. Unless there's a fluke personal relation, they're transactionally separate. That's the problem with this line of argument. If you're arguing on selfish, transactional merits, it's fair to dismiss on the basis of one's personal experience. For most people in the rich world, that experience does not include clearly-identifiable bad effects from climate change, nor will it in the proximate future. "Save yourself" doesn't work if the person you're pitching isn't actually in peril. (To highlight the point, that same person would likely support flood defenses. Even if their house is on high ground.)
- latexr 3y ago> If you're arguing on selfish, transactional merits, it's fair to dismiss on the basis of one's personal experience. Fair point. If I understand your larger argument, you’re saying that appealing to a selfish person’s selfishness may be ineffective or even counterproductive if we can’t make the subject matter directly relevant to their unique situation. What’s your approach, then? If all you can get from them is either complacency or doing the bad behaviour out of spite, ignoring altogether may be best.