2 ms·
This isn't kindergarten, I don't want all discussion reduced to anodyne abstractions. I think we can handle a robust exchange of views now and again, even if th
by anigbrowl 3y ago
This isn't kindergarten, I don't want all discussion reduced to anodyne abstractions. I think we can handle a robust exchange of views now and again, even if they're not expressed the way you would express them.
- dang 3y agoNo one's asking for 'kindergarten' and I'm a bit puzzled why you would use that word, since the kindergarten side of the internet is the very flamewar dreck we're trying to avoid.
- rat9988 3y agoI think you don't realize that you are in fact treating us as kids or teenagers. Telling someone his, in good faith, comment, is below the guideline threshold is insulting. It's one of the polite, absolutely not vulgar, ways, to say someone's comment is idiotic without answering it. If you think someone hasn't provided enough evidence to back his claim, please ask him to do in a meaningful discussion. The kind of remarks where you just assume someone is just a weird internet troll, do not serve the discussion, nor the website users. Please understand that saying something politely, as in hiding behind the guidelines, doesn't make it acceptable if the message is insulting. We should thrive to build a community based on mutual respect.
- dang 3y agoI don't agree that HN moderation comments are doing anything like that. Most of the posts I reply to aren't idiotic (to use your word), and most comments that might strike me personally as idiotic (again, your word not mine) are within the site guidelines. Moderation isn't about assessing who's right or wrong on a topic. That's the community's job, and I'm pretty sure the bulk of the community would not at all appreciate it if we tried to take that role.
- rat9988 3y agoThe guidelines are kind of vague on purpose. When you say that some comment is a flamebait it is insulting. When you say that someone's comment is just an internet trope, it's insulting. You don't just enforce guidelines, you also make a very subjective judgement. I'm not going to argue anymore, I feel like talking to a politician that answers with bad faith and dodges the point.
- anigbrowl 3y agoIt's an idiom I use a lot, because 'be nice and polite all the time under any circumstances' is something I associate with kindergarten. Small children don't have flamewars, although I see how they're reminiscent of schoolyard fights. Still, I think posters need to accept some expressive/emotive language in discourse. 'Good luck with that' may be a trope as a way to sarcastically express skepticism, but it's hardly offensive or conversation-terminating.I like to know how people are feeling in regard to a contentious topic, whether or not I find them or their argument agreeable. draining away all emotion/idiom introduces its own problems; callous or cruel remarks may be couched in pseudo-objectivity and the language of necessity/inevitability.
- pastacacioepepe 3y ago> I think we can handle a robust exchange of views now and again, even if they're not expressed the way you would express them. The comment in question didn't add anything to the discussion, it was just a snarky remark. Hence no actual exchange of views could be derived from it, only insults between factions.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI found it meaningful and efficiently communicated, even though I disagreed with the person's opinion.