5 ms·
Greenhouse gas emissions hit ‘all-time high,’ approaching point of no return
- brian-armstrong 3y agoCalling it a point of no return suggests that, once passed, we are free to go on sinning
- Ekaros 3y agoIf we can't win isn't it better to have as much fun as we can when we still can?
- raffraffraff 3y agoNah. It's still a case of "exactly how bad do you really want it to be?"
- willcipriano 3y agoHow dare you, it's already too late! https://web.archive.org/web/20230307215203/https://twitter.com/gretathunberg/status/1009757391515156480 https://web.archive.org/web/20230307215203/https://twitter.c...
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoIt might be. They didn't say we'd all be dead in 5 years, just that we'd possibly pass a tipping point. I guess we'll find out.
- latexr 3y agoEvery reply on that thread either misunderstood the claim or is arguing in bad faith. The quote doesn’t mean “everyone will be dead in five years unless we stop using fossil fuels before then”, it means “unless we stop using fossil fuels in the next five years, everyone will die at a later point as a consequence of the irreparable damage”. Do you understand the difference?
- willcipriano 3y agoRight, and we didn't so no point in trying now since we are all going to die anyway.* *or the climate scientists are wrong again
- latexr 3y agoWe’re all going to die, climate change or not. But you can die sooner and in greater pain or later and more comfortably. Which do you prefer? If you had a chronic disease, would you take medicine to stave off the adverse effects and preserve your quality of life for longer? Or would you throw your hands up and let the disease ravage you since there’s no cure? And remember: in the case of climate change your decision doesn’t affect only you but others as well.
- willcipriano 3y agoWant to do analogies, let's do analogies. What if you had a doctor who told you to stop eating ice cream or you were going to die. He keeps making predictions, you'll have a heart attack in 5 years, you'll get diabetes in 6 years, you'll be dead within the decade. The years pass and his predictions don't come true. Worse yet, you find out that he has a fridge full of Ben and Jerry's at home and publicly supports government funded ice cream socials (wars). At what point would you stop trusting the experts? Keep in mind it's really hot in many parts of the world and their economies could really use some ice cream.
- latexr 3y agoYou’ve lost me. Are you claiming that climate change isn’t getting worse and that climate scientists support wars? I don’t want to mischaracterise your point, I’m genuinely not sure if I understand it.
- 999029190 3y agoI'm not OP, but I'm claiming exactly that. I'll go further. I don't even consider so-called climate scientists "scientists."
- latexr 3y agoThat’s an interesting observation. I would hope that as a species we’d realise that beyond the point of no return there’s still a path that we can take to make the outcome less painful instead of going scorched earth (pardon the expression) but I’m under no illusion that will be the case.
- yongjik 3y agoYeah, I really don't like this kind of messaging, because (in all likelihood) humanity will blast past those "points of no return," all ten of them, and after that the dialogue is going to be awkward.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoNotwithstanding all of the climate change deniers and shills around still arguing nonsense. The problem is saying there is an arbitrary boundary of no hope. The danger is in the learned helplessness this reinforces and the lack of action it suggests. This is an ongoing existential emergency to the survival of all life on the planet. The result will be a desertified Earth if nothing is done. What must happen immediately are draconian policy prescriptions that require leadership. This is because industries and people will not stop polluting voluntarily because they view it as their right to pollute and ruin the planet because they did it yesterday and they want their profits, their hamburgers, or doing burnouts in their ICE sports car. "Because I want, I will do whatever I want" is their logic. It's a Tragedy of the Commons at present that cannot be resolved by asking nicely. Fossil fuels, meat agriculture, open clinker refinement, and more will have to change, and there is an urgent need for bio carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) at scale that isn't anything remotely like #TeamTrees that actually takes carbon from the atmosphere and disposes of it somewhere safe for millions of years in an economical manner (preindustrials levels can be reached for under $25-30 T).
- BenFranklin100 3y agoWhen the environmental left starts taking nuclear energy and carbon taxes more seriously, I’ll start taking these warnings more seriously. As of now, the impression I am left with is that the people making these dire warnings think climate change is less dangerous than new generation nuclear power plants, which aren’t particularly dangerous all things considered.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoIt's not the "environmental left" that's holding back carbon taxes. In fact, most of the world has embraced carbon taxes, including China, California, Washington, Canada, EU and so on. The USA is a bit of an outlier here, and it's not because the environmental left are in control there.
- BenFranklin100 3y agohttps://washingtonmonthly.com/2021/04/26/the-weird-but-hopeful-politics-of-a-carbon-tax/ https://washingtonmonthly.com/2021/04/26/the-weird-but-hopef... https://time.com/5447748/washington-state-carbon-tax-climate-change/ https://time.com/5447748/washington-state-carbon-tax-climate... https://www.politico.com/story/2018/12/09/carbon-tax-climate-change-environmentalists-1052210 https://www.politico.com/story/2018/12/09/carbon-tax-climate... EDIT: To provide context on why the Left finds carbon taxes dubious, it’s that carbon taxes are very likely regressive. That is, they are though to hit poorer people harder: https://www.nber.org/digest/jan10/how-regressive-price-carbon https://www.nber.org/digest/jan10/how-regressive-price-carbo... I agree, but I think this is an example of the perfect being the enemy of the good. We can craft companion policies that lessen the regressive nature of carbon taxes, while still maintaining the benefits of carbon taxes. Also, please address my main point about the environmental Left’s rabid opposition to nuclear power over the last 40 years.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoCan you highlight polls or some other data source showing that the "environmental Left" is rabidly opposed to nuclear power? The best current poll reporting I can find don't distinguish beyond major political party: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/03/23/americans-continue-to-express-mixed-views-about-nuclear-power/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/03/23/americans... You're also mentioning their opposition over the last 40 years, yet not comparing it to the latest and greatest nuclear power plants. Presumably many people are unaware of advances in nuclear power technology. Edit to add: Thirdly, if the rabid environmental Left is opposed to nuclear power, I'd expect them to also be opposed to most of consumerism for other reasons (such as the environmental impacts of resource extraction). If they believe necessary power can be had from non-nuclear, non-carbon-intensive power plants (such as wind or solar), then to support nuclear power would be basically supporting the continuation of a consumerism that they generally see as bad for the environment. To only take greenhouse gas emissions seriously when rabid environmental Leftists completely change their worldview seems counter-productive. You have to take it on its own evidentiary basis.
- LatteLazy 3y agoEvery year we emit more, and yet somehow we don't see the total fall. It's as if we're not doing enough. But we are talking about it. What more does physics want than heartfelt commitments to do nothing now?!
- raffraffraff 3y agoMaybe take a few frivolous flights somewhere. Because I'm sure the money you give the airlines will go straight into investing in decarbonising air travel or something.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoFunny thing is, if we did nothing, we would solve the problem. We could just stop -- flying airplanes, running power plants, driving cars around. The situation would be improved tremendously if we all just sat on our asses. Do the bare minimum to keep food happening, that's it. But that isn't allowed, because everybody's in an arms race with everybody else, and hardly anyone can feed or shelter themselves autonomously in this environment. No, we have to keep doing shit -- carbon-emitting shit -- to justify our existences.
- latexr 3y ago> Earth is approaching a “point of no return,” with catastrophic outcomes such as widespread flooding, heatwaves, and famines looming. Humans are approaching the point of no return. As George Carlin put it: “The planet isn’t going anywhere, we are. (…) The planet will shake us off like a bad case of fleas”.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Humans are approaching the point of no return Putting it bluntly, humans will be fine. Civilisation, even, will be fine. The coming chaos is one of migrating people, economic centres and food production. Rich, cohesive nations will see depressed growth. Poor or fractured societies will collapse.
- latexr 3y agoI wouldn’t consider chaos, depressions, lack of food, and societal collapses as fine outcomes for humans and civilisation.
- throwaway5959 3y agoWhat parent is really saying is, “it’s not going to impact me so it’s fine for humanity to suffer”
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> wouldn’t consider chaos, depressions, lack of food, and societal collapses as fine outcomes for humans and civilisation Within the (rhetorical) context of potential extinction, surviving is just fine. The intersection of folks gearing up on climate change and far-flung humanitarian outcomes is limited. The fraction of the first doing it for the second, smaller still. Recognising incentives—even unsavoury ones—is key to changing behaviour. If you are middle class or above in the rich world, or over 50, climate change is unlikely to ruin you. If you’re in the upper class in the rich world, climate change is unlikely to materially inconvenience you or your direct descendants. (You may even see opportunity.) Acting on the environment has to come from a place of stewardship and compassion. Self-interested quips per Carlin, while pithy, don’t hold. This framework explains why haughty climate activism fails; you’re trading someone’s present living standard for another’s future. Uncompensated, that will provoke backlash à la les guillettes jaunes, Canada’s trucker protest or whatever coal country is up to right now.
- isityouyesitsme 3y agoIn most of 2020, and large parts of 2021, the U.S. economy tanked, along with a substantial number of active road users, air travelers, manufacturing services, logistics, etc. Even today in my not-quite-urban living area, the traffic seems to be 2/3 what it was in 2019. I live under a pretty big rock. Is there any explanation why this serious reduction of greenhouse has had no effect?
- javagram 3y agoTraffic and driving is up compared to 2019. Mass transit use dropped dramatically. The economy only tanked for a brief period in 2020 and then had massive stimulus injected that led to a rush for consumer goods and real estate. Oil production increased and more oil and gas are being burned. Overall the trajectory for generation of greenhouse gases did not change significantly.
- isityouyesitsme 3y agoHmm, most of that passes the smell test to me, thanks. The part that doesn't: I'm admittedly looking only at my Urban area, but traffic is much less than it was. I still commute to the office, and it just isn't what it used to be, even into the city. My commute takes about 10 minutes less than it used to, 15 minutes instead of 25. Obviously not a huge city, but definitely one that is well known across the U.S.
- kuhewa 3y agoResidence times of greenhouse gases are on the years to centuries timescale. The economy tanking was a blip in the rate emissions were added to the atmosphere, but the net balance was still positive. And even if it wasn't, a single year of net zero emissions would make a near negligible change to the existing inventory of greenhouse gases, which is up almost 50% over the highs of the past 800k years. There would be a detectable drop in methane (half life of 10.5 years) but not too much for CO2 (hl of 100+ years). Getting to net zero isn't going to substantially reduce the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere or stop warming in it's tracks, it's just about limiting how much higher the temperature is going to get (at least for the short to medium term).