4 ms·
The Ferengi were a joke when they first appeared on screen - they were drooling, barely literate space cavemen. The "evolved" Ferengi actually match the writers
by krapp 3y ago
The Ferengi were a joke when they first appeared on screen - they were drooling, barely literate space cavemen. The "evolved" Ferengi actually match the writers' original intent of portraying them as a parody of American capitalism.
And the Borg weren't portrayed as a hivemind in their first appearance, either. They were simply a vastly superior species that doesn't consider the Enterprise or its crew anything more than resources, and so they just start carving the ship up with a laser. Guinan even says it may be possible for the Federation to advance to the point of dialogue with them. The focus on assimilation was added later.
And the existence of a queen does make sense (although of course insect queens aren't actually monarchs.) A purely unstructured and decentralized hivemind would be incapable of the necessary degree of planning and organization necessary to accomplish anything, much less maintain a quadrant-spanning technological civilization. A hierarchy is still necessary, and in fact the original concept for the Borg more closely resembled an insect colony (which they couldn't do because of budgetary constraints.)
Also from a purely Doylist point of view, a villain needs a face and a voice, otherwise it's just a force of nature. A hurricane can be dangerous and dramatic but not compelling as an antagonist.
And TNG didn't invent the Borg Queen anyway, that was the movies. If you're going to blame a series for ruining the Borg look at Voyager.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoVoyager had its moments and was a good fun “junk food” trek (great for unwinding after work, as I found out while marathonning all things Trek a few years ago) but yeah, the stuff Janeway manages to pull off with a tiny underpowered science vessel cut off from Starfleet, particularly with regard to the Borg, was ridiculous.
- sgt 3y agoI love Voyager. If you want to call it junk food trek sure, but it has some depth as well. The most depth were some of the Dominion DS9 episodes, in my opinion. But overall I still rank TNG the highest, then VOY, followed by DS9. That's my top three. As for 4th, that's something we should discuss over a beer.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoFor me the highlights of Voyager were some of its characters. The Doctor and Seven both grew into their roles very well and Tuvok is one of the most convincingly Vulcan characters who isn't Spock, for example.
- sgt 3y agoAnd Janeway - such a great character development.
- fbdab103 3y agoReally? If you grabbed S1 Janeway and plopped her in the finale, I felt she was mostly the same (minus Future timeline Janeway grieving for Tuvok/Seven)? Obsessed with getting the crew home and willing to bend the rules, yet still sticking to Federation principles when push comes to shove (ie refusing the handful of opportunities which would have plopped them into the Alpha quadrant).
- sgt 3y agoWhat you say makes sense if you put it that way. Maybe she evolved more as a person than a leader?
- batch12 3y agoNot every version of Janeway's ship and crew made it. We followed the path/timeline of the successful one. For instance, Harry and Naomi Wildman's voyager was destroyed. There was also the year of hell, etc.
- fbdab103 3y agoMirror Ship Harry - talk about a plot point that never gets addressed again! For an episode-of-the-week format, it would be difficult to callback to that, but that feels like it should become a personality-defining moment: I should not exist, except my parallel version was killed, and the captain decided I should survive.
- jccalhoun 3y agoThe show was really hurt by making it be so episodic. At the end of most stories they had to reset things (unless it was cast changes). How many times was Voyager taken over and had some non-Federation tech installed only to have it removed by the end of the story?
- Izkata 3y agoProblem with that is, they were so bad at continuity in Voyager they had to make an episode with a fake ship (cloned on the demon planet) that gets destroyed, so minor issues with previous episodes could be explained away as having taken place on the duplicate ship. Imagine how much worse if could have been of they had to keep track of actual plot relevant continuity...
- krapp 3y agoIt's heresy but I think Picard did a lot to redeem the Borg as a menace by showcasing how traumatic assimilation is through Picard and Seven's character arcs, even though it also wasted so much potential by not actually using them, and I liked Annie Wersching's manipulative queen.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoI think it was Rich Evans who said it would be way better if Voyager gave up at some point, and decided to found a new federation in the delta quadrant. I think I agree with him, because yes, the suspension of disbelief sort of piles on after a while.
- tenpies 3y agoThe whole handling of Species 8472 was a let down. For once, the Borg had a credible challenge that had arrived at a higher technological capability through completely different means. Then, in the span of an episode, the Voyager crew not only figures out a way to crush 8472, but somehow does it with technology that the Borg have much better mastery over. It's as if a cavemen taught a sharpshooter how to be a better marksman.
- arp242 3y ago> Also from a purely Doylist point of view, a villain needs a face and a voice, otherwise it's just a force of nature. I always felt that they don't is exactly what made the Borg so scary; they can't be talked to or negotiated with. They just exist to assimilate. Nothing more or less. No compassion, no humanity. Before the Borg queen they really were a force of nature, but with laser phaser guns and shit. The replicators in Stargate had the same effect. I felt there too they went too far by explaining the origins and having "human-like" replicators (I'm a bit fuzzy on the details, as I never cared all that much for Stargate and it's been ages since I watched it).
- data-ottawa 3y agoI have the same thoughts on the Borg. They’re like a virus, they’re a local optimum that is both logical and nearly inescapable.
- Izkata 3y agoThe origin worked for me: it's a grey goo scenario, technology that escaped control of its creators. The human-form replicators were an evolution of the technology during the show, not part of their origin. Happened while they were trapped in a time dilation field.
- lostmsu 3y ago> a villain needs a face and a voice, otherwise it's just a force of nature I agree with the parent. A force of nature is not a bad way to present the Borg.