6 ms·
I don't get this. People are saying Meta will do the same thing when Threads or whatever they call it comes online. Looking at the networks themselves, there a
by jeroenhd 3y ago
I don't get this. People are saying Meta will do the same thing when Threads or whatever they call it comes online.
Looking at the networks themselves, there are massive differences in user numbers. Nobody but a few geeks used XMPP. Nobody but a few geeks use Mastodon, Mastodon could never even handle all Twitter users moving over. Then there's a huge influx of normal people into the network because a big company experiments with being friendly with open standards. A system used by tend of thousands is joined by millions.
When those millions move away, the old protocol isn't killed. We're still in the situation that nobody but a bunch of geeks use XMPP. Some of those geeks don't care enough and stick with what works (though I doubt they've landed on Google Chat).
Those millions brought in by Google and Facebook didn't care about the federated nature of an extensible messaging protocol, they wanted to talk to their friends. Some of their friends had weird usernames that didn't end in gmail.com or facebook.com, that's the normal user experience.
XMPP sucked as a messaging tool and even today it still sucks because there are only a few clients out there that actually support basic group chat that everyone expects these days. Mastodon sucks because of usability problems (try following a user from a linked thread, the weird popup system is user hostile at the very least).
When some big company joins your network, you'll have to find a way to keep up with it or it'll leave again. Threads will join Mastodon, probably stir up some drama, and then defederate. Mastodon will then quickly go back to its natural state, a slightly smaller network of servers like it is now.
If your users jump ship because the competition made a better version, that's not killing your protocol. That's highlighting the problems with your current protocol, and your dependence on someone else's customer base to keep your project popular.
- logicprog 3y agoTbf, Mastodon has about 7 million users, not a few ten thousands: https://mastodon-analytics.com/ https://mastodon-analytics.com/
- rvz 3y ago7 million 'created' accounts throughout its entire existence in 8 years is hardly interesting or early days. The point of the OP still stands that "Nobody but a few geeks use Mastodon, Mastodon could never even handle all Twitter users moving over." Even when Meta connects Threads to ActivityPub, it is a magnificent win for centralization and a complete nightmare for Mastodon and 'federation' and there is nothing they can do to stop it other than just de-federate and stay irrelevant. This post exactly highlights the same thing on what happened to XMPP, but worse. Especially even when admins of other large Mastodon instances can be corrupted by larger companies like Meta with money, NDAs and contracts to allow these instances to federate with Meta. This is the typical 'Embrace, Extend, Extinguish' strategy all over again. As I said before: "Instagram's success on ActivityPub is also Mastodon's nightmare and it tends to more centralization." [0] A paradox that is unavoidable for Mastodon without accounting for its UX failures and risking more centralization to the point where Meta is already winning after when other companies can still 'buy' out admins of very large instances. [1] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36012434 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36012434 [1] https://masknetwork.medium.com/mask-network-acquires-pawoo-net-one-of-the-largest-mastodon-instances-5273504ba92d https://masknetwork.medium.com/mask-network-acquires-pawoo-n...
- lapcat 3y ago> hardly interesting Interesting is a matter of perspective, but I've noticed over weeks and months that your HN account "rvz" has been constantly commenting about Mastodon, so you appear to be very interested, despite your claim to the contrary. ;-) > early days logicprog didn't say it was early days. > Nobody but a few geeks use Mastodon The issue is with "few". Millions of people aren't a few. Perhaps Mastodon users are all or mostly "geeks", i.e., technically sophisticated, but let's not pretend there aren't millions of users. Yes, the number is small in comparison to Twitter and Instagram, but it's large in absolute terms. > Mastodon could never even handle all Twitter users moving over. This is true. Some Twitter migrants to Mastodon want to bring everyone along. Others, such as myself, are happy to leave all of the celebrities, politicians, and trolls behind. My community, Apple developers, for whom I originally joined Twitter back in the day, have almost all migrated from Twitter to Mastodon, and my Mastodon feed is as active as my Twitter feed ever was, while my Twitter feed is now largely dead.
- rvz 3y ago[flagged]
- lapcat 3y ago> Another fan and avid reader of my comment history, deciding to comment directly to me about it. No, we both just happen to read and comment on a lot of Mastodon stories here, myself because I'm a Mastodon user, and you because... well, I don't understand your obsession with Mastodon. Anyway, I have a pretty good memory, and I remember discussing/arguing with you before in the comments of Mastodon stories. > The graph omits the entire history of Mastodon users before Oct. 2022, and it has been around since 2016. Not 2022. Thus, It is not early days and my point still stands. Again, nobody here said it was early days, so your point has no point. > That's the problem with that figure and it is still unimpressive in 8 years. "unimpressive" is a matter of opinion and perspective. I'm impressed that most of my community has migrated. This didn't happen with app.net back in the 2010s, unfortunately, which I'm still sad about and consider a missed opportunity, because app.net was superior to Mastodon in a number of ways. I never wanted 220M people to migrate to Mastodon. You can cackle to yourself that Mastodon didn't become the "New Twitter", and perhaps some people out there in the world believed it would be, but I'm not one of them, and nobody here appears to be one, so you're just inserting irrelevant dunks against your perceived foes into this discussion. Mastodon is not a failure for not having become the New Twitter, with hundreds of millions of users. I see no indication that Eugen Rochko ever had that goal in mind. Mastodon is a thriving community. It's a much smaller community than Twitter, which is fine and good. Mastodon is certainly not perfect, and it could use some improvements, but IMO attracting hundreds of millions of users would wreck everything that's good about it.
- jeroenhd 3y agoI was referring to the XMPP users before Google started federating. Twitter's slow descent into online hell has made Mastodon significantly more popular. However, there may be 7 million users, but about 2 million still use the platform at all. Two million people is a lot of people, but compared to Twitter's 240 million user accounts and Instagram's 2350 million user accounts the Fediverse is a spec of dust.
- NoRelToEmber 3y ago> Those millions brought in by Google and Facebook didn't care about the federated nature of an extensible messaging protocol, they wanted to talk to their friends. Yes, and instead of using "true XMPP" to talk to their friends and contribute to its growth, Google diverted that flow of new users into its own product. Sure the growth would have been far slower without Google, but this way Google managed to steal a few users that would have joined XMPP even without Google, on the false promise of compatibility. Instead of slow, healthy growth, what happened was fast, parasitic growth, and on top of it all it added a maintenance burden for XMPP developers trying to maintain compatibility with Google. You say XMPP was small - that's the point! To kill competitors before they become a threat.
- jeroenhd 3y agoIf Google knew how to kill a competitor's messaging platform they wouldn't be starting two new chat apps every year. I don't believe that Google decided to pick XMPP because it formed an actual threat; rather, XMPP was open source, freely available, and had a whole bunch of code all ready to go. Why invent your own if there's a free, documented protocol already out there? WhatsApp picked XMPP as a basis for their messaging infrastructure when it started out. It never even bothered to federate with XMPP, but the technology still worked. XMPP's miserable state isn't some evil Google plot, it's a lack of user interest and a failure to effectively market the protocol. Unlike previous attempts, WhatsApp actually took off, easily overtaking Google's own fledgling messaging service, because it knew what people wanted: "chat without SMS charges". This left some space in other countries where SMS was essentially free, but nobody managed to capture interest in XMPP there either. I know one XMPP client that everyone agrees is somewhat usable, Conversations, and it looks like development and design stopped somewhere around 2014. Absolutely nothing stood in the way of XMPP taking the place that Line, Telegram, Signal, WhatsApp, and all the others, but there was simply no interest in making a good product out of a federated service. Matrix is trying again, with big companies using it instead of IRC, and it's struggling to survive in a world where Discord looks better and works better.
- NoRelToEmber 3y agoYou talk as if XMPP failing on its own, and Google trying to kill it, are mutually-exclusive.
- dredmorbius 3y agoFediverse MAU is on the order of 1.4 million FYI <https://fedidb.org/ https://fedidb.org/>