20 ms·
California will begin backing intentional burns to control wildfire
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoIn recent years historic mega fires have raged across the globe in Siberia, Australia, the Amazon, Canada, and throughout the American northwest. Not sure how you can blame all that on American forest management practices.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 3y ago> “Fight fire with… well you know” I recommend the Good Fire podcast for anyone confused by this headline.[0] [0] https://yourforestpodcast.com/good-fire-podcast https://yourforestpodcast.com/good-fire-podcast
- faeriechangling 3y agoBegin? California has been doing intentional burns since before Europeans arrived, as the article points out. Headline seems like it was written badly on purpose just to clickbait people unfamiliar with the subject.
- jerf 3y ago"Resume" across a time period of multiple human lifetimes doesn't really convey the correct implications. If I happen to share the same business as my great-great-great-grandfather nobody is going to call that "resuming the family business".
- faeriechangling 3y agoHere's prescribed burnings from 2019 in California. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/sep/03/wildfires-drones-controlled-prescribed-burns https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/sep/03/wildfires-dr... No idea what you're on about.
- jerf 3y agoI inferred from your text you were referring to controlled burns done before European colonization. Apparently incorrectly.
- dylan604 3y agoHuh? That sounds exactly like what marketing people would do for your business. Est 2023 vs Est 1923 would lend a heck of a lot more credence.
- bobthepanda 3y agoIIRC isn’t a big problem that the burns also fall afoul of pollution rules? Did they fix that as well?
- pixl97 3y agoWhen the law is dumb the law is what needs to change. You either have a controlled burn that burns up trees and brush. Or you have an uncontrolled burn that burns up trees and brush and cars and homes and cities and people and every other harmful thing that you really shouldn't burn.
- taeric 3y agoThis feels reductive and unlikely to help. Would you allow your neighbor to do a controlled burn of leaves in their yard against your fence? It is easy to see a straight line from that concept to this. Turns out, rule making is hard.
- bradyd 3y ago> Would you allow your neighbor to do a controlled burn of leaves in their yard Yes, this is extremely common in the south east.
- taeric 3y agoUh... no? Letting them do it in their yard, fine. You do it against my fence, and you will get yelled at. It gets out of control and hits my property, you will be paying to fix it. That is, ultimately, the crux of the problem here. Literally, the point is they are building a fund so that prescribed burning can be insured. Edit: I should say that I'm playing loose here, as this is a conversation, not a debate. That said, I did include the "against your fence" on purpose. I'm well aware of rules on how you can burn, for example: https://www.cobbcounty.org/fire/fire-marshal/outdoor-burning https://www.cobbcounty.org/fire/fire-marshal/outdoor-burning.
- 3y ago
- whalesalad 3y agoThis article makes it seem like this is a novel concept? California/CalFire has been doing this forever.
- rch 3y agoThey've intended to do this consistently, but confounding factors like air quality guidelines have prevented them from keeping up with the required rate of controlled burns. I can't recall exactly how far behind they are, but if they're permitted to put aside those constraints (unlikely) it'll still take decades at this point.
- Plasmoid 3y agoThere's also fire safety too. If you do a controlled burn when it's too dry then you've just started a massive wildfire.
- bluGill 3y agoOnly if you haven't been keeping up with your controlled burns. If you are keeping up even a dry year shouldn't get out of control.
- vwcx 3y agoAir quality issues are two-fold: the (legal) mandated limits and the popular concerns. The latter are often the blocker on small/regional burn seasons. It's late winter/early spring, land manager is ready to go, and the nearby town doesn't love the smoke.
- bcrosby95 3y agoI wish people could convince these towns that the smoke will come one way or another.
- kurthr 3y agoYep, I find most of the discussion around it profoundly uninformed. California averages (corrected 127 thousand) --1.8Million-- acres of prescribed burns a year. They were happening in the 1980s and 90s (when there were mistakes that cost lives), and have been since the 1870s. Unfortunately, the list of prescribed burns is now only available from ARCGIS and the simple list appears gone: https://data.ca.gov/dataset/prescribed-burns https://data.ca.gov/dataset/prescribed-burns Here's a paper published in 2020. https://www.mdpi.com/2571-6255/3/3/44 https://www.mdpi.com/2571-6255/3/3/44 Prescribed Burns in California: A Historical Case Study of the Integration of Scientific Research and Policy It's a complex issue so there's lots of reasons why prescribed burns aren't done more, but they have been done for years, and there are new laws to make it easier. The challenges include: Air Quality Laws, Insurance Liability, Federal control of National Forest, and the high population in the Wildland Urban Interface and large number of houses near areas that need fire control. People do build houses in areas called Devil's Canyon and Black Hill, but at the same time large areas of grass and scrub have burned annually each year in Lake County so burns there obviously don't help. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-10-07/newsom-signs-fire-law-paving-way-for-more-prescribed-burns https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-10-07/newsom-s... Every article seems like a chance to spread misinformation with lazy analysis and conspiracy theories about Jewish Space Lasers, Climate Change Denial, or that controlled burns haven't been part of California fire control for all of living memory. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2022/10/28/fact-check-california-uses-controlled-burns-reduce-fire-intensity-climate-change/10588334002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2022/10/28/fac...
- alexb_ 3y agoI'm shocked this isn't being done already. But what on earth is the reasoning in this article? There are plenty of great reasons to do controlled burns, but for some reason the article says controlled burns are good because: > purposeful burns have been used by Indigenous people to keep forests and wildland healthy for millenia. When talking about the reason for overgrowth, the article talks about how it's the fault of Europeans who said controlled burns are primitive. The person they reference is not someone in the forest service, or someone who is an expert in this. They reference the "UC Davis professor of Native American Studies Beth Rose Middleton Manning". Is this article supposed to be about controlled burns being put in California? Or is it supposed to be how the europeans were so stupid, native americans were so smart, and wildfires are the fault of westward expansion? Why not talk about more concrete reasons that controlled burns are good without appealing to it being opposite of racists?
- cmh89 3y ago> The person they talk to is not someone in the forest service, or someone who is an expert in this. They talk to "UC Davis professor of Native American Studies Beth Rose Middleton Manning". They didn't talk to anyone, they just used an article with more depth to support their little, less deep article. >Is this article supposed to be about controlled burns being put in California? Or is it supposed to be how the europeans were so stupid, native americans were so smart, and wildfires are the fault of westward expansion? Why not talk about more concrete reasons that controlled burns are good without appealing to it being opposite of racists? What does this mean? You can't talk about wildfires in the west without talking about how westward expansion brought terrible forest management practices and suppressed traditional management practices that kept forests healthy. How are you involving racism in this topic?
- alexb_ 3y agoThank you, corrected. It's not that I don't think that discussion has a place. It's that I don't think saying "natives did it" is a justification for bringing it back. There are plenty of great justifications for bringing it back, and I'm glad they are, but "native americans used to do this" is not a reason. That sort of reasoning is how you get people claiming that "alternative medicine" is better than the medical miracles we produce today. You need actual data and reasons to support things, not just "native americans did it and racist europeans rejected it".
- jscipione 3y ago“They’re starting again in California. I said, you gotta clean your floors, you gotta clean your forests — there are many, many years of leaves and broken trees and they’re like, like, so flammable, you touch them and it goes up. I've been telling them this for 3 years now, but they don't want to listen.” President Donald Trump Old Forge PA, 2020 https://www.youtube.com/live/nN9mo_Zxdk0?t=2081 https://www.youtube.com/live/nN9mo_Zxdk0?t=2081
- vore 3y agoDidn’t he suggest having people go rake the forest to solve the problem?
- bequanna 3y agoA “brush rake” is a heavy equipment attachment which is very common in logging/forestry.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agohttps://heartland.org/opinion/trump-was-right-about--raking-finnish-forests/ https://heartland.org/opinion/trump-was-right-about--raking-... > In Finland, after clear-cutting a forest area, crews use heavy machinery (similar to what is used in this video) to “rake” or gather tree harvesting residues, tree roots and other material into huge piles. The biomass is then chipped onsite after it has dried up sufficiently, and chips are hauled to local heat-producing plants to generate warmth for local residents.
- reportingsjr 3y agoThis has absolutely nothing to do with material build up and drought conditions that exacerbate extreme forest fires. What you linked is weird propaganda about Finnish forestry companies trying to utilize clear cut areas more effectively.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoThe main gist was clearing forests areas, not that method. California wasn't doing anything at that time. Even the method he mentioned is used (as opposed to what the juvenile mockings suggest) but for a slightly different but related purpose. Enjoy this and the instance where the German was laughing at Trump when he warned against over reliance on Russia.
- pengaru 3y agoUnless something's changed recently, California doesn't control such things within its own borders for a huge swath of its forests. The federal government does, and that's been the crux of the matter for as long as I've paid any attention to it.
- B1FF_PSUVM 3y agoNeeds a new ad campaign, perhaps with a smokey bear advising: "Remember, only you can promote forest fires"
- taeric 3y agoThe headline would make more sense if it highlighted that they are looking to help insure prescribed burns. The point being that they have wanted this for a long time, but the risks associated with doing a burn effectively make it so that nobody will do it. All of the talk about whether or not successful controlled burns should be done are somewhat moot. Nobody is arguing against that. Pretty much they never have. The barriers seem to have always been in costs associated with containment and what happens when that goes wrong. Edit: I should add that I stated the "never have" too strongly. It was never unanimous that it was a bad idea. I would be a wrong if I said absolutely nobody ever said it was a bad idea.
- bagacrap 3y agoSo this sets aside money to cover claims against controlled burns that ultimately cause unintended damages. Instead of $20M, the budget should be whatever the total damages were on average per year for the past ten years.
- Spivak 3y agoGiven they haven't allowed controlled burns before that would be $0. You have to make an informed guess the first time.
- bagacrap 3y agoThey've always allowed controlled burns. I've personally seen them happen in California in regional parks. The problem seems to be that not many authorities want to do them because of liability concerns. In any case, I meant that the budget should be aligned with the normal amount of damage from uncontrolled wildfires.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoYes, but not nearly enough by a long shot.
- efa 3y ago>Prescribed burns are generally focused mainly on acreage and reducing the amount of fuel available for wildfires; cultural burns are focused on what needs burned to revitalize woodlands and promote biodiversity. I wish they'd elaborate on how this is done. Focuses on what needs to be burned? Meaning a type of tree? Just the undergrowth? Curious how fire can be controlled to just specific elements in the landscape.
- wongarsu 3y agoFrom my layman understanding: usually it's just dry undergrowth and dead stuff that burns. Getting a healthy tree to burn needs a lot of heat or time, so if you burn frequently enough the undergrowth burns away long before the trees have a chance to catch fire. If too much flammable material has built up, remove undergrowth from around the tree trunks (or inversely, stack dead branches under trees you want to burn, though not sure if anyone does that).
- mmis1000 3y agoI think it's really hard to burn a healthy tree. Water is good at controlling temperature. Even you use a blowtorch on a healthy tree. You will just make a black taint on it. And a big healthy have tons of water in it. Make it even more durable to fire. To make a healthy tree burnable. You first need tons of heat source to prepare the wood itself so it is dry enough that actually burnable. But a healthy forest shouldn't have that level of heat source to make it doable (otherwise it will burn itself away someday, just like current situation of CA) Prescribed burn here exists to remove the fuel, so it never pile up to the level that "Once it ignited, everything burns regardless of it is a healthy tree or what. And it burns forever because everything is burnable at this level of temperature".
- nineplay 3y agoA strange article considering that California has been doing prescribed burns for years[1]. You could read it and easily believe that this is some new and novel approach. Many groups agree that California needs to do more but describing it as "California will begin backing intentional burns" seems intentionally misleading. The author's digression into European's attitudes toward Native Americans doesn't seem to add much to the discussing except give them some cultural warrior brownie points. [1]https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/california-needs-more-fire-prescribed-burn https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/california-needs-more-fire... > In May 2018, then-governor Jerry Brown set a goal of burning 500,000 acres of wildlands each year by 2023—a start at treating the 20 million acres that California’s Forest Carbon Plan estimates would benefit from prescribed fire or manual thinning.
- mistrial9 3y agono, the controlled burns so far have been miniscule and error-laden. There was a control fight between CalFire and other agencies over every detail. Multiple, massive fires occurred in the intervals when they were arguing about it behind closed doors. The past-Chief of CalFIRE was terminated over this and other issues; his immediate successor was given more than 10x the budget that CalFIRE ever had. Money is a problem in the woods. Firefighting is genuinely harsh and dangerous, the people they have to run it are largely military culture.
- nineplay 3y agoNone of that justifies a headline of "California will _begin_ backing intentional burns". Already this thread is full of comments condemning California for its wooly-headiness.
- lost_tourist 3y agoI can see regulations requiring them to do a 5 year study per 10 acres for environmental impact on local flora and fauna.
- scythe 3y agoCalifornia still lags far behind Florida, a much smaller state, in the acreage of prescribed burns per year. SW Florida is a tropical savanna climate, having a winter fire season. Around 2 million acres per year are burned, and have been since I was a child. https://www.fdacs.gov/Forest-Wildfire/Wildland-Fire/Prescribed-Fire https://www.fdacs.gov/Forest-Wildfire/Wildland-Fire/Prescrib...
- mistrial9 3y agothe backlog for implementing this is decades old; there is no unified voice, and ad-hoc opinionated materials can attract readers quickly, for the wrong reasons perhaps. There is no joy on this topic - its a brutal mess, with more to come. Popular media is going to produce contents like this, again.. and yes there is collective anger under the surface. Somehow, rational thinking must stay alive, while the venting and posturing continues in the open.. It is worth considering Australia, Greece, the far-North scrub forests.. are all facing this, without the budgets and science of California.
- willmadden 3y agoGood! Now if the bureaucrats would only allow the power companies to clear underbrush from beneath transmission lines...
- wholien 3y agowent on a short hike around Mammoth Lakes in California with a retired US Forest Service guy, and he told us a story about how they manually surveyed an area that had been fire suppressed for many years. They counted the number of trees per acre, and compared that to the number of trees per acre to an area near Mammoth (Bishop maybe) that hadn't been fire suppressed. I don't remember the specifics anymore, but basically there were far fewer trees per acre in the area that did not have fire suppression, but the trees were far healthier / bigger as they did not have to compete for resources. While the trees in the fire suppressed area were smaller and made for a less healthy ecosystem.
- WalterBright 3y agoAnother thing that can be done is use selective logging. I.e. thin the forests out by logging trees here and there. Or do both. Thin out the substantial trees with selective logging, which reduces the fuel load, then burn the undergrowth.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI'm not sure how it's done in California, but in a lot of places, they do something kind of similar to this. In areas with a very large buildup of fuel that puts trees at risk of burning, they will cleacut a ring around the planned burn to keep the fire contained. However, they would not normally log all the trees within the burn area. The goal is to preserve the trees and clear out the fuel that has built up at the underbrush level. After the burn, mature trees help suppress further underbrush development. When trees are removed, it leads to a lot of secondary growth, which both promotes fire and is heavily susceptible to being killed by fire. This is fine if the goal is to maintain the area as a more open field-like space via frequent controlled burns (which we honestly should be doing more of; meadows are highly ecologically valuable), but if the goal is to maintain it as forest, then you don't want to remove mature trees.
- mynonameaccount 3y agohow about allowing loggers to cut down some trees instead of just burning it or capturing that energy released. Allows people to take that home for firewood. Personally, I burn wood for the winter and cooking.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoI'm not personally opposed (though most of that kind of harvesting might disturb a lot of habitat, potentially introducing non-native invasives. But, it is also a fact that a lot of plant life is dependent on fire.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoYou don't burn to kill the trees. You burn to clear up the dry, flammable plant material on the ground. If controlled burns are conducted regularly, this fuel does not build up enough to create large fires that kill trees.
- kyrra 3y agoWSJ ran a commentary piece on this yesterday that includes some improvement details not in this article. https://www.wsj.com/articles/fight-fire-with-fire-if-epa-allows-particulate-pollution-canada-prescribed-burn-54f52987 https://www.wsj.com/articles/fight-fire-with-fire-if-epa-all... > Under the Clean Air Act, wildfires are considered “exceptional events,” and the pollutants they emit are typically exempt from regulatory scrutiny. Prescribed burns generally receive no such exemption when the Environmental Protection Agency measures a state’s compliance with air quality standards. States may face penalties including loss of federal highway money if they exceed pollution standards while mitigating against more harmful smoke from wildfires. ... > Obtaining an exemption for a prescribed fire under the Clean Air Act is already so arduous that states are reluctant to implement or expand burn programs. The Government Accountability Office recently reported that the approval process is so burdensome that only one state has submitted and been granted an exemption from the EPA, a project in Kansas in 2012.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoJust one more obstacle to having a sensible fire regime. Sheesh. If you do prescribed burns early in the season, the fires will be small, and not out of control (generally). That prevents worse air pollution later. In general this differentiation between "acts of God" and "acts of Man" is a real problem. You neglect a forest until it burns down a community, and you're innocent. It was an act of God. You try to prevent that from happening by doing controlled burns, something goes wrong, and it burns down some houses; busted.
- 2devnull 3y agoThe EPA is not as powerful as they should be. We should prioritize clean air over property damage from fires. Sadly the voters and both parties will get that wrong, albeit for different reasons.
- kyrra 3y agoThe question is, does it prescribed burn cause more air particulates than a wildfire caused by too much underbrush?
- iepathos 3y agoOne of the caveats not really talked about here is that national parks are actually the responsibility of the federal government to take care of not the state of california. So, only so much california can do if white house ignores responsibility to do controlled burns on the 6.3 million acres of national parks here where wildfires have often started.
- hyperthesis 3y ago> fund’s purpose is ... demonstrating that prescribed and cultural burns are low risk, so private insurance companies will enter the market. How does a fund demonstrate that? The linked legislation (https://wildfiretaskforce.org/prescribed-fire-liability-claims-fund-pilot/ https://wildfiretaskforce.org/prescribed-fire-liability-clai...) claims "rates of escape and loss are very low" already. Insurance companies' actuaries are experts at quantifying loss, so if it is low already...?
- tree-related 3y ago[dead]