4 ms·
Do people want Github to display files in your private repos on github.com? Do you want syntax highlighting and intellisense? Do you want them tokenized for sea
by paxys 3y ago
Do people want Github to display files in your private repos on github.com? Do you want syntax highlighting and intellisense? Do you want them tokenized for search? Should they be available for cloning when you need it? Should they run security scans and identify vulnerabilities? Should you be able to see git blame, diffs, commits, other metadata? Set up build pipelines? Modify contents via an API?
Tell me – how can Github do all of this without programmatically accessing the contents of your private repos from their servers?
- wg0 3y agoOr - how any provider even self hosted, other than GitHub can provide any of that without automated processing of the contents of private repositories?
- marcinzm 3y agoAs I see it people are basically taking a single line of an agreement that explicitly references other agreements out of context: "If you enable data use for a private repository, we will continue to treat your private data, source code, or trade secrets as confidential and private consistent with our Terms of Service."
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoNo, I don't want these features. I want reliable remote git storage, which lets me clone a copy of my source code anywhere so I can do these things locally, on my own machine. People forget that this was the original design and intent of Git as a decentralized protocol. As an industry I think we have become too reliant on Github as some kind of way-far-beyond-git magic tool. This might be fine until it isn't--like when Microsoft decides it's time to start training Copilot on your private code.
- lucasfdacunha 3y agoUse another place to store your git projects then, it's not like Github is the only one. Github is a PRODUCT built around git, not just a place to store your git repositories. I'm pretty sure you will be able to find other services which only exist to host git projects and do nothing else.
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoYou say this as if you think most people have a choice...I've pushed hard in the past for my employer to move off Github but have been met with nothing but blind resistance.
- rockemsockem 3y agoBeing concerned for your own personal reasons about Microsoft scanning your code of one thing. How does it make sense for your employer to switch off GitHub?
- ziml77 3y agoBut that's not your code, that's your employer's code. You might have written it but they fully own it. This doesn't seem like something to be concerned about on their behalf.
- paxys 3y agoThen you shouldn't be using Github at all. Problem solved.
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoTell this to my CTO.
- paxys 3y agoWhy? It's his company, his code, his decisions. You are free to use whatever you want for your own projects.
- misnome 3y agoDoing remote storage _still_ requires their servers to read and process your repository data.
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoAlso, for what it's worth, I was extremely surprised and concerned when my private repos appeared in code search results. I had to triple-check that it wasn't showing up when logged out or logged in to a dummy account without access to the repo. This behavior is definitely not intuitive and if there's a way to disable search indexing on private repos I'd do so.