9 ms·
Why is it so rare to hear about Western cyber-attacks?
- yesbut 3y agoBecause of the "we good, they bad" mentality. We are saints, right?
- hoppery 3y agoI should hope not, that would be depressing waste of taxpayer money. FTA the West is just significantly better at playing this game.
- yesbut 3y agoWe are most certainly engaging in cyber attacks against states that we are antagonistic against. Here are a few of the more public operations: * Stuxnet: In 2010, the Stuxnet worm was discovered, which targeted Iran's nuclear facilities. It was widely reported that the United States and Israel were behind this cyber attack. The attack aimed to disrupt Iran's nuclear program by targeting specific control systems. Source: The New York Times - "Obama Order Sped Up Wave of Cyberattacks Against Iran" * Regin: Regin is a sophisticated cyber espionage platform discovered in 2014. It is suspected to be a joint operation conducted by the "Five Eyes" intelligence alliance, consisting of the US, UK, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. Regin targeted various entities, including governments, research institutions, and telecommunications providers. Source: Symantec - "Regin: Top-tier espionage tool enables stealthy surveillance" * Flame and Duqu: Flame and Duqu were sophisticated cyber espionage tools discovered in 2012, believed to be associated with state-sponsored actors. While attribution is challenging, it has been reported that these attacks were possibly conducted by the US and its allies. The primary targets were in the Middle East, including Iran. Source: Symantec - "Flame: Questions and Answers" * Equation Group: The Equation Group, classified as an advanced persistent threat, is a highly sophisticated threat actor suspected of being tied to the Tailored Access Operations (TAO) unit of the United States National Security Agency (NSA). It was responsible for developing and deploying sophisticated malware and exploits. The group's activities spanned several years and targeted various countries worldwide. Source: Kaspersky - "Equation: The Death Star of Malware Galaxy"
- gordian-not 3y agonot saints but better
- gdy 3y agoBetter how?
- gordian-not 3y agoFor example not using cyber warfare as a tool for intellectual property theft on an enormous scale and fighting such attempts Defending against unchecked aggression in europe Preventing radical islamist organizations from attacking western soil Fighting north korean attempts at nuclear blackmail and mass computer-based money stealing operations
- Geezus_42 3y agoSo we're better because we think we can protect ourselves from colonialism coming back home? All the things you're implying others do to us are things we have done to them or others.
- gordian-not 3y agointellectual theft? are there any western companies benefiting from economic espionage? also please explain which examples of western colonialism are you seeing now or in the past 50+ years
- gdy 3y agoAnd what about unchecked agression in Iraq?
- postsantum 3y agoHere is a hint: "For instance, the leaks organisation says Marble has test examples in multiple languages: it is possible for a person creating malware to set their spoken language as being Chinese, Russian, Korean, Arabic and Farsi. Thus, CIA created malware could potentially be developed to appear as if it was emanating from another country. The CIA has not commented on the disclosures." https://www.wired.co.uk/article/cia-files-wikileaks-vault-7 https://www.wired.co.uk/article/cia-files-wikileaks-vault-7
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoCouldn't, say the chinese or russians, do the same thing and develop malware in way that makes it look like it came from US?
- c00lio 3y agoOf course. Attributing attacks properly is extremely hard, if not impossible. It is far too easy to fool the used attribution methods.
- postsantum 3y agoNo, because they cannot ask BBC to publish an article about that
- chiefalchemist 3y agoWhy not title it "An example of why Western journalism isn't journalism at all"? Or perhaps "'Journalism' as driven by intelligence community press releases"? Or even "More civilians die in CIA commanded drone attacks, but we'll never tell you. Ever wonder why?" These are the same mindless parrots who label anything outside the narrative a conspiracy theory. Accuse them (i.e., self proclaimed journalists) of bias, blindspots, and/or being lazy? Again, conspiracy theory. According to them they're doing an outstand job as The Fourth Estate. I can't decide if they actually don't realize what pathetic tools they are, or if they run stories like this to rub it all in our faces. It's a sad state of affairs.
- senttoschool 3y agoThis is the problem with western media's treatment of China. The relentless demonizing of China is either a coordinated effort in the mass media, designed by governments agencies, and/or exaggerated to get clicks/views by writing "China bad". But many Americans swear that "freedom" means they don't drink any propaganda.
- golergka 3y agoCountry that is actively perpetrating genocide on its own citizens and sells organs of its people on the black market doesn't need any demonizing. That's not even mentioning the communist regime. Humanity seems to have learned the lesson with fascism, but it somehow missed the same exact lesson with communism.
- senttoschool 3y ago>Country that is actively perpetrating genocide on its own citizens and sells organs of its people on the black market doesn't need any demonizing. So we're now going to label "re-education camps for extremist muslims" as genocide? What do you think China should do prevent extremist muslims living inside China from randomly killing innocent people, which was fairly common? How would you label the US killing innocent muslim civilians and invading muslim countries? That seems more like a genocide to me. This is my point. The amount of anti-China propaganda in western mainstream media is so blindingly strong that we can no longer have a logical conversation about China.
- freshpots 3y agohttps://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/china-xinjiang-uyghurs-muslims-repression-genocide-human-rights https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/china-xinjiang-uyghurs-musl... Millions of people... millions. They're not all extremist Muslims that China is doing this to.
- golergka 3y agoDoes nothing click when you type “re-education camps” with your own hands?
- tikk 3y agoMedia Objectivity and Bias. Most people think journalists should be impartial by default. That's bullshit, of course. The (only) truth, that matters, is the one that makes your team (feel) stronger. If we would celebrate (our) successful cyberattacks like blablabla, then the responsible institutions and companies would wrap it in some nice narrative and the media would tell the story a bit more often ...
- blueflow 3y agoI've analyzed the logs of failed login attempts to some SSH server of mine. The most common source AS'es are: - AS9808 China Mobile Comms, China - AS4837 China Unicom, China - AS132203 Tencent, China - AS211252 Delis LLC, US - AS209605 Host Baltic, Lithuania - AS4134 China Telecom, China - AS16276 OVH, France - AS134963 Alibaba, Singapore - AS45102 Alibaba, China "china bad" or not, i have hard data that most of this spam orginates from chinese or chinese-controlled ASes.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoBet there is someone on Chinese HN commenting the same, but with the location set in America
- blueflow 3y agoCheck answers to this thread later, i asked a friend from Peking and he will grab some logs during the weekend. Will post the new list of AS'es here.
- Sophira 3y agoOr is proxied through them.
- orbz 3y agoThere’s pretty much no reason not to proxy through multiple international jurisdictions to avoid detection. Each hop raises the cost of investigation and delay by an order of magnitude.
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoWhen I did itsec work we joked that the #1 indicator of an attack from Russia was a sudden dropoff of connections from Russia. I immediately assume that traffic origin has been spoofed
- c00lio 3y ago
- nubinetwork 3y ago> Why is it so rare to hear about Western cyber-attacks? Because they claim stuxnet was made by Israel. Deny, or pass the buck. We didn't do nothing, move along citizen.
- c00lio 3y agoBecause attribution of cyber-attacks is a guessing game. One that is easily manipulated. Together with wide-open networks, shitty endpoint security and missing abuse handling in Eastern countries, they could be originators or proxies for an attack. It isn't really possible to distinguish those, there can be hints, but those hints might as well be planted. So all the "China is attacking us" panic might still be "Western criminals are attacking us, China is just helping through their gross negligence".
- bollos 3y agoThrows me back to the Olympic Destroyer malware from 2018 and all the layers of red herrings that were stuffed into it.
- MaxPengwing 3y agoYou got my curiosity, where mIght I find more info on this? It sounds really interesting.
- Geezus_42 3y agoDarknet Diaries has an episode on it.
- bollos 3y agoAs someone else already mentioned, there's a Darknet Diaries episode about it. There's also a Wired [0] piece about it from Andy Greenberg who also adopted it into his (in my opinion) excellent book Sandworm: about how the Kremlin slowly got more and more dangerous in terms of cyber warfare capabilities. [0]. https://www.wired.com/story/untold-story-2018-olympics-destroyer-cyberattack/ https://www.wired.com/story/untold-story-2018-olympics-destr...
- willcipriano 3y ago[flagged]
- 3y ago
- Arnt 3y agoIs it actually so rare? The stories seem to appear semi-regularly. Consider the last year's attacks on Russian ministries etc., or what Snowden revealed about the NSA, or things like this: https://arnt.gulbrandsen.priv.no/tmp/nsa.png https://arnt.gulbrandsen.priv.no/tmp/nsa.png Last time I read about banking/phishing swindles, Florida was named as a main source.
- formerly_proven 3y ago> UPDATE (1/27/14): Shepard says she reached out to the seller and was told they entered the wrong tracking number. She hasn't received the package yet. She also says the new tracking details show that it has now been sent to Seattle, but to the wrong zip code, and "didn't ship until after [she] got the original notification email." That's left her unsure of "what to make of it and feeling paranoid," she told me via Twitter.
- Arnt 3y agoThat's also a story about a western cyber attack. Unproven, uncertain, definitely a story, and given the address involved, definitely western.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoAfter all the shenanigans we know the CIA and NSA have already done in the past, why should anyone assume they’re not involved in cyber attacks as well?
- red-iron-pine 3y agoThe question is not that are they doing it -- we know they are -- but why doesn't anyone talk about it more? There is the obvious western media bias there, but we don't hear about it in Asian or African or other media, either. My guess is that Western ops are slick, and that the Russians and Chinese are just so prolific in their attacks.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoWell, the CIA wouldn't attack its allies. That leaves only a handful of targets in the world, chiefly, China and Russia - both of which have issues of language, media accessibility, and open internet.
- mewmew07 3y agoWhat is the answer to the question in the title of this article? https://chat.openai.com/share/2bfd7c50-284c-48f6-b6d3-816d21ab7c55 https://chat.openai.com/share/2bfd7c50-284c-48f6-b6d3-816d21...
- somat 3y agonpr had an article about one nsa operation. https://www.npr.org/2019/09/26/763545811/how-the-u-s-hacked-isis https://www.npr.org/2019/09/26/763545811/how-the-u-s-hacked-... Ransomware attacks bother me enough that sometimes I fantasize that this sort of thing was the standard response. Sure go ahead and hit a US company with a ransomware attack. But be aware that there is a good chance it puts you in the crosshairs of a nsa battalion whose whole mission is to ruin your day. Perhaps not the smartest team but they are motivated, have incredible resources and the ability to operate while legally protected by the us government. Then I sober up and realize why this is a terrible idea.
- glimshe 3y agoTyrannies like China, Iran and Russia, the usual targets of such attacks, aren't interested in divulging that the "decadent West" was successful at conducting a cyber attack and hurting them.
- dragonwriter 3y agoBecause covert attackers never talk and the targets of Western attacks are less likely to talk than Western targets of attacks are.