27 ms·
All of these services / plugins / demos are incomplete without analyzing Flash cookies. I worry the result is people thinking they're more anonymous than they r
by nostromo 15y ago
All of these services / plugins / demos are incomplete without analyzing Flash cookies. I worry the result is people thinking they're more anonymous than they really are. (You can view your Flash cookies here: http://www.macromedia.com/support/documentation/en/flashplayer/help/settings_manager07.html http://www.macromedia.com/support/documentation/en/flashplay...)
I'd really like to see the browsers take on this practice. Safari, for example disables 3rd party cookies by default, but leaves open this huge hole via Flash.
- dpres 15y agoCan't speak for anyone else, but I always run my browsers with Flash disabled or uninstalled so Flash cookies make no difference to me.
- grandalf 15y agosame here
- kenrikm 15y agoClicktoFlash/ClicktoPlugin (Mac) is great, you only execute flash if you want to. This little app saves me hours of battery life on my Macbook Air. I don't know what's available on Windows/Linux however if you're on a Mac I can't recommend it enough.
- jarek 15y agoDepending on your browser, you might be able to do this directly in browser setting. In newer Opera versions, the setting to enable click to flash is at opera:config#UserPrefs|EnableOnDemandPlugin
- caf 15y agoThe FlashBlock plugin for Firefox provides "click to Flash" functionality.
- spindritf 15y ago> you only execute flash if you want to NoSciprt allows you to do that, so does Flashblock. I'm sure there are similar plugins and extensions for browsers other than Firefox (well, maybe not NoScript, it seems pretty unique).
- blasterford 15y agoEven stranger to see no mention that cookies aren't needed at all to track users successfully. Check your browser at http://panopticlick.eff.org/ http://panopticlick.eff.org/ Basically, using useragent, plugins, time zone, language, screen size, etc etc etc, you can fingerprint a user pretty reliably without using cookies. Cookies are just an easy way to track users client side, but if there is an 'assault' on cookies, then people will just start relying more on server side tracking of users instead. Disabling 3rd party cookies etc really achieves nothing. Also, there's numerous methods you can use to store "cookies" in the browser these days, (localstorage api, http cookies, flash, cache etc) If you really don't want to be tracked for some reason, disable javascript, clear out your user-agent, and use TOR.
- Cieplak 15y agoWow, there's a lot of unique information there that I didn't expect, such as installed system fonts. Hashing this information could generate a fairly reliable primary key.
- yesimahuman 15y agoNot mentioning names, but I used to be involved in a project that used this method to track users. From my observations, it was very useful as filter for further analysis. It's not perfect, but really quite good.
- drostie 15y agoMaybe, but there would have to also be passes through the data afterward to link identities. Hashing is dangerous since browsers are living, dynamic beasts. When someone updates their browser, their useragent changes, and you'll want to keep their new identity as an extension of their old one. Not to mention that people use multiple browsers. So there's going to be a vital step of "linking the new identity to old ones" which can happen on a different thread more dedicated -- but you'll need to keep data. You'll probably truncate ultralarge fields and then GZIP them or so, rather than just hashing them. One interesting thought: how much space would you need to pull this off? Chromium generates 12 KB of data which can gzip to 3KB, Firefox generates 5 KB of data which can gzip to a little over 1KB. Truncate-then-gzip could be used to keep perhaps 0 - 4 KB per person. Assume that your average user uses ~2KB. That's still rather a lot, when compared with what you can do with counters -- 8 bytes or so to store. If you wanted to keep your database under 2 TB, you could only handle a million people, not hundreds of millions. So it would really be a big distributed project to link identities as they evolve over time. I imagine that's one huge factor in using tracking cookies; it's lazy for scaling.
- dialtone 15y agoWhat this service does is analyze which URLs are fetched from the sites you visit and compare them with a list of known tracker URLs. It doesn't need to care for flash cookies or such, it's there to inform you of who's on a page potentially tracking you. It raises your awareness so you can properly act on it. Another plugin that existed for a while is Ghostery: http://www.ghostery.com/ http://www.ghostery.com/ this one also blocks the fetch of the URL so whatever cookies they might be using becomes irrelevant. Most of these tracking pixels are not flash anyway so blocking flash won't accomplish anything. Blocking Javascript will do something of course but some are only images so it will still be pointless and you'll still be tracked. The reality IMHO is that it's better to be targeted by relevant ads than to see dating/scammy ads everywhere.
- ocdprogrammer 15y agoI got these on Chrome and they work quite well together: AdBlockPlus, Ghostery, DoNotTrackPlus. I guess they are available on Firefox too.
- jacobr 15y agoI have made ~/.macromedia a symlink to /tmp, which means Flash cookies are regularly wiped.
- politician 15y agoGreat solution! Note to self: figure out how to do this in Windows
- ashmud 15y agoUse mklink /j or junction (SysInternals). Optional: Combine with a ramdisk, such as Dataram.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoCannot upvote this enough. I just saw the trash in ~/.macromedia and was stunned. Immediately rm -rf everything and made the symlink. Will be doing it on my girlfriend's macbook as well.
- cs702 15y agoI'd be reluctant to make a symlink inside your home directory to a system directory like /tmp -- there are always unforeseen consequences. (For example, every backup of your home directory could end up including an unintentional copy of _everything_ in /tmp at the time of backup.) IMO it's better simply to add "rm -rf ~/.macromedia" to the list of shell commands that get executed upon every login -- or add the commmand as an entry on your personal crontab.
- newman314 15y agoAlternately, I uninstalled Flash months ago and use Chrome whenever I need Flash. Seems to have worked out okay for me.
- hammock 15y agoAlternatively (since the little Flash UI sucks), in these two places- Windows users: Documents and Settings/yourusername/Application Data/Macromedia/Flash Player/Shared Objects/your flash userid/ Documents and Settings/yourusername/Application Data/Macromedia/Flash Player/Macromedia.com/Support/Flashplayer/Sys/ Mac users: Places/yourusername/Library/Preferences/Macromedia/Flash Player/SharedObjects/your flash userid/ Places/yourusername/Library/Preferences/Macromedia/Flash Player/Macromedia.com/Support/Flashplayer/Sys/ Wow. I have flash cookies from over 700 sites.
- GoodIntentions 15y agoYou might like this: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/betterprivacy/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/betterprivacy...
- keporahg 15y agoI use a Firefox plugin called BetterPrivacy: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/betterprivacy/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/betterprivacy.... You can set it to clear your Flash cookies at the end or beginning of each session.
- re_todd 15y agoI love BetterPrivacy. I'm surprised every day, when I close the browser, how many flash cookies it reports it will clear.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoTry setting the "Website Storage Settings" to 0 on that Flash settings page. I did that ages ago and haven't noticed anything break because of it.