4 ms·

If the explosion was heard Sunday night wouldn’t this mean there’s a possibility the crew was stuck for some time and knew they were likely going to die?

• LilBytes 3y ago
  An explosion at that death is nearly always critical and catastrophic. That an explosion would occur and there might be a glimmer of hope is closer to 0 than any other number.
• jethro_tell 3y ago
  Not a chance. The whole problem with subs is that water weighs about 8lb per gallon. So, at 4000m you're looking at something between 4500 5500 psi. Thats a small truck worth of pressure every square inch in the hull. Once you breach the structure, think crushing a tin can in the middle, things collapse pretty fast. As do bodies. If you figure your body is 2 foot by 6 foot, the pressure would be like parking 100 fully loaded 18 wheelers on a single body within a split second of each other. Every book or encounter you read about submariners has a section talking about the creaking of the bulkheads and wondering how long it can hold because it's such a nature defying act to build something that can hold that pressure out in the first place.
  • antognini 3y ago
    > creaking of the bulkheads One of the counterintuitive features of submarines is that they're not built to be waterproof at the surface. The various parts of the hull aren't welded shut and instead rely on the external pressure to press them shut at depth. Making them waterproof at the surface ends up making them less able to resist the pressure at depth.
    • upon_drumhead 3y ago
      So what do they do when they run on the surface?
      • martijnvds 3y ago
        .. sink?
      • antognini 3y ago
        My understanding is that they pump the water back out.
  • xwdv 3y ago
    The timeline says the sub was expected back at 3PM, but the implosion was heard at night. So in between the hours of 3PM to when the explosion was heard, I speculate the sub was somehow trapped and unable to leave the wreck site, until after finally spending all that time at depth something happened that suddenly caused an implosion.
    • 111111IIIIIII 3y ago
      Your comment was perfectly clear to me. I'm not sure how it was so misinterpreted.
    • jethro_tell 3y ago
      Ah, I did misunderstand your comment though from what I heard the implosion was heard about 2 hours after the sub left the mothership. Which would put them there before entering the sub and before making it the full depth. I'm sure it will be a little more clear as all the parts get put together.
  • deleted 3y ago
    [deleted]
• JohnBooty 3y ago
  It's hard to find authoritative links, but by all indications I have ever seen or read, implosion is nearly instant. The pressure differential is large. As soon as the hull gives way it's essentially like a bomb explosion in reverse. I suppose it's possible that some external piece of the sub might have exploded and left the sub itself stranded but intact on the ocean floor. However, it seems that's not what happened -- pieces of the sub's main body were part of the floating debris field. It provides some level of comfort to know that the passenger's demise was likely instant as opposed to slow and terrifying.