6 ms·
Can you expand? To a layman like myself, tracking is part of communications and it seemed clear there was no tracking because they didn't know where the sub was
by crazygringo 3y ago
Can you expand? To a layman like myself, tracking is part of communications and it seemed clear there was no tracking because they didn't know where the sub was.
What is the specific type of tracking device you're referring to? What signals does it emit? And if overall power was lost, for example, why wouldn't the tracking stop just like communications stopped?
- nicce 3y agoBoth will be lost at the same time. We don't really know such signal. Submarines cannot communicate more hundred meters in the bottom of sea. Sea water absorbs the signal quite well. When the signal is lost, the expectation is that the submarine is under the water. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communication_with_submarines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communication_with_submarines
- bilekas 3y ago> When the signal is lost, the expectation is that the submarine is under the water. Yes! This is true, I would just like to clarify that there is a difference between 'coms' and 'transponder' here. Some friends of mine conflate the two and think they are almost on the same 'circuit'. In most cases of the Sub (specifically military because there are not many tourist subs), you don't WANT to be located unless in an emergency, whereas here in this situation you most certainly do and in that case you can be located by way of the transponder. Th
- krisoft 3y ago> Submarines cannot communicate more hundred meters in the bottom of sea. Sorry if I am misunderstanding you. It sounds like you are saying that it is impossible to design a system which would be able to keep in contact with the submarine/submersible all the way down to the bottom? Because if that is what you are saying that is simply false. We have the technology to keep in contact with a submarine all the way to the bottom of even the deepest oceans. This is not even speculative. We know it is possible because James Cameron had full communication during his dive all the way to the deepest point on earth. Here is a really cool article about the technical challenges with that system: https://www.hydro-international.com/content/article/communications-to-the-deepest-point-on-earth https://www.hydro-international.com/content/article/communic...
- nicce 3y agoIf you read the article, you know that the context was extremely specific and not suitable for general use. The noise is too big problem. In ”normal” context such signal is not currently known to be really possible. You know that submarines are not equipped with these. The ship on the surface had to drop cable 100 meters below the ship to combat noise. Which means that for communication to be possible, ship cannot really move. And the ship is supposed to be almost directly above the submarine, to reduce the noise again. For signal to be practical, it should go either over the surface or go long distances horizontally and be usable even with some noise.
- krisoft 3y ago> If you read the article Rest assure that I have read the article i have linked. > the context was extremely specific and not suitable for general use What does general use mean? The context is the same. We are talking about an expeditionary submersible having constant and reliable communication with its support ship all the way to the bottom. This was the setup of Cameron’s dive and this was the setup of the ill-faited Titan mission. Are you claiming that this is not possible?
- 111111IIIIIII 3y agoThis is HN. People here will defend "lean startups" to the grave, as long as it's not their own grave.
- nicce 3y ago> We are talking about an expeditionary submersible having constant and reliable communication with its support ship all the way to the bottom. The lost submarine in this context had no similar support ship. It made connection to base on being on the surface from long distance. ”General” would mean that either submarine is capable for keeping long distance communications regardless if is is diving or on the surface. Either to any closeby ships or even the ground station. And for that there is no reliable technology yet.
- somat 3y agoTo clarify EM waves which are used for most(all?) tracking in the atmosphere, are attenuated very quickly in water. Underwater sound waves work better. I don't know what this submarine used but I would expect at minimum an acoustic transponder to aid in underwater tracking. with a acoustic telephone as a comm channel. However reading about some of their other engineering decisions this is probably too optimistic of me. Data recorders(airplane black boxes) have a sound pinging unit for this exact case. being lost under water.
- bilekas 3y agoSo we're actually really good at enforcing circuits and components against atmospheric pressures. Also they run relatively low voltage. As an example I can immediately think of the Compatt devices, they're tested and proven far beyond 4Km depth, and they come with a few options of power supply. They have their own independent power source as you would expect, but depending on the configuration can pull from the device / vehicle. The v4 of the Compatt also comes with extensive warnings around the power draw in relation to reserve so if for example they left and it was only on battery-power for some reason, it will start screaming. The fact that from reports (obviously we don't know for sure) they went at the same time, sadly Occam's razor. Edit : Disclosure : Worked on firmware for off-shore drilling rigs with devices measuring the vibrations and resistance of material being probed for viability.